Author Archive

  • Mon, Aug 22 2011

    Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.

    EVAL 168

    Inventor: Fred Bartel
    Selected: Modern Building Toy

    Community: 10

    D: 6
    M: 6
    V: 6
    Staff: 19

    Total: 47

    Design felt that this was a very interesting concept – it is true that architectural technology has advanced a lot without any true evolution in the way that it is mimicked by toy companies. Definitely a fun opportunity to explore different joints and materials. Market thought this was interesting and differentiated. If advertised correctly, this could grow virally and have mass distribution across toy stores everywhere. Would need to be addictively fun to play with. Viability noted that sourcing would depend on what materials were chosen – we don’t currently have a wood vendor lined up. We would want to partner up with a vendor with experience in the children’s toy category to make sure that we meet all regulatory requirements. Various patents for “complex” building toys do exist, but a detailed design would be required in order to determine patent opportunities.

    The Rest of the Field…

    Inventor: Shah Chowdhury
    Submission: Key Holder

    Community: 33
    D: 5
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 48

    Design, calling this “Switch for keys”, felt that this was a good solution to discomfort and clothing damage. We would need to ensure that it is made with enough quality that keys never fall out. Also, would need to make universal by allowing for all sizes of keys. Market didn’t find the problem to be especially large and felt that it is a bit of a novelty item. They noted that the retail price would be so low that volume would have to be massive – something that they didn’t feel comfortable with. Viability felt that we might need to partner up with a vendor with experience with these kinds of rotating mechanisms. The company “Keyport” already holds several design and pending utility patents for this commercial solution, so protection would be unlikely.


    Inventor: Marc Zayas
    Submission: Hanging Pot Rack

    Community: 29
    D: 5
    M: 6
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 47

    Design thought this was a interesting idea, though the need for install would perhaps be a put-off to consumers. We would have to explore how to store the pot lids as well. Some similar products do exist on the market. Market thought that since this is DIY, consumer demand would be low. It would be easy to communicate this product at retail, especially stores like Home Depot and Loews. Viability noted that it would need to either be universal to all cabinets or made in different sizes, two unideal options. Making this strong enough to hold many pots and pans would be a significant engineering challenge. Since this submission is a merging of “slide out” and “hanging kitchen storage”, both of which are public domain, patent protection would be highly unlikely. Though everyone sympathized with the problem and felt that this solution would work, it would be too hard to sell and doesn’t work 100% with the Quirky product line.

    Inventor: Jared Joyce
    Submission: 360 Degree Scissors

    Community: 27
    D: 6
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 44

    Design felt that this could be useful for cutting linear foods, such as celery, carrots, sausage, etc. It could be potentially tricky to clean. The use of 2 blades rather than the proposed 3 was brought into the discussion, since getting a clean cut from 3 overlapping blades can be difficult. Applications outside of the kitchen (pipe cutting, for example) were noted as a possible angle for this product. Market felt that this was differentiated and conceptually interesting, but it might not sell very well when put into competition with paring knives. Viability noted that we would need to find a vendor with a lot of blade experience to make sure that this product could indeed be useful (sharp, correctly sized, etc.).  The submission is very close to the “Cuban Crafters Revolucion” cigar cutter, but the patent application was abandoned, thus narrow protection could be an available option, given an innovative approach. Many people mentioned safety concerns (fingers getting cut) and also the fact that it would only be useful for a handful of food items.

    Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
    Submission: Tablet Mini-Office

    Community: 26
    D: 3
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 40

    Design felt that this could end up being a very bulky product, difficult for shipping, use, and sales. Also, similar items already exist on the market and this is not really any more innovative. In general, a slim bag would probably be more useful in most use cases. Market agreed that this would be bulky and not especially unique. However, we do have the distribution to get this into retail. Viability felt that though we have vendors, we may want to look for more. There wouldn’t be much engineering work to do since its just a combination of existing products. Patents and pending applications exist for various design approaches to this problem, so design-around might be necessary.

    Inventor: Jeff Castel
    Submission: Sticky Earbud Organizer

    Community: 25
    D: 2
    M: 5
    V: 8
    Staff: 0

    Total: 40

    Design didn’t see any true innovation in this submission – similar items exist on the market, many of them using the same winding method. In addition, the problem isn’t very noteworthy, as you can just wrap your cable around your device. Market stated that we definitely have the distribution and it would fit well into our cord organization line-up. It could also be a good Back to College item and might be useful for promotional marketing opportunities. Viability noted that we have suppliers for this type of product. No concerns over updates in device hardware, as it would attach to any screen. Meaningful patent protection would be highly unlikely, considering that many commercial products are available. A patent for a similar design solution is in the works, so a design-around might be required. Most people didn’t think this was something that people really want nor need. It also adds bulk to a very streamlined device.

    Inventor: Craig Brown
    Submission: Perforated Bowl

    Community: 11
    D: 6
    M: 5
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 29

    Design felt that this does solve a small problem that is pretty universal. However, similar solutions are on the market (it even seems quite similar to Ventu). This might be a good opportunity to look into layered materials and aesthetics. Market saw this idea as just a strainer berry bowl scaled up for larger quantities. There was some questioning as to whether elimination of juice would indeed lengthen the life of a fruit salad. Viability noted that sourcing, manufacturing, and engineering challenges were all heavily dependent on what materials were chosen for this design. The design, as submitted, seems unlikely to be patentable. Design-around may be necessary.

    Inventor: Angelo Cacchione
    Submission: Never-Dull Knife Set

    Community: 17
    D: 6
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 32

    Design felt that sharpening knives is indeed a common problem. This could be an opportunity to do some rigorous testing and consulting with professional knife manufacturers and sharpeners. Market noted that this category of products is extremely competitive and highly concentrated within a small number of brands. Also, the problem doesn’t really shout out to consumers. Viability said that we would want to partner with people who really, really know what they’re doing with knives. There would be significant engineering challenges in making this product, as sharpening can be a real art form when done right. The submission is too conceptual to determine anything about patentability.


    EVAL 169

    Inventor: Seun Ajanwachuku
    Selected: Easy Pour Teapot

    Community: 18
    D: 6
    M: 6
    V: 7
    Staff: 16

    Total: 53

    Design liked this concept, noting that it would have to be elegant and aesthetically pleasing in order to be conmpatible with the ritual of tea drinking. Similar hand-operated pumps are used for kerosene heaters, but this is new to the teapot category. The downside of this submission is that it would need to be battery operated. Market also approved of this product – it would fit into our distribution channels and could be priced at a reasonable yet marginally-responsible price. Viability noted that we would probably want to partner with either a teakettle or pump manufacturer. Making this product work as described (and safely!) will definitely be an engineering challenge, but we believe our staff is up to it. No patents exist for this exact product idea, so patent protection might be available.

    The rest of the field

    Inventor: Khames
    Submission: Rolling Laundry Basket

    Community: 36
    D: 5
    M: 6
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 53

    Design felt that although the form factor with integrated wheels is visually interesting, it will probably cost a lot to manufacture and isn’t necessarily a unique idea. There’s also the concern of “runaway laundry” when you put a hamper on wheels. Market thought that this was an interesting product, especially for apartment/urban environments. It does fit our current prouct line-up and it solves a notable probelem, but it may be too big to ship and keep on retail shelves. Viability noted that we do have plastics vendors, but they may not be able to make something this large. Giant injection molds make the operations team crawl under their desks, as they don’t bring big profit margins, are hard to ship, and generally need to be superb products to have a chance on the market. The design concept appears to be public domain but narrow protection might be available for an innovative approach.

    Inventor: Art Bauza
    Submission: Vibrating Bracelet

    Community: 23
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 36

    Design felt that this was an interesting application that could potentially be bexpanded to handle other used scenarious, such as telephone ringing, medication time, or bedtime. The major problem with this submission is that you would have to retrofit it to whatever existing doorbell the buyer has in their home. Market called this a “unique solution” but they did have some concerns over where this could be sold and how we can make people understand exactly what it does. Viability noted that we don’t have a specialized vendor for this but that we could potentially double up on the vendors of the pillowcase alarm product. Patents and pending applications as well as some commercial products in the “bracelet alert” category do exist, so design around might be necessary.

    Inventor: Michelle Drake
    Submission: Doorknob Lever

    Community: 22
    D: 5
    M: 2
    V: 1
    Staff: 0

    Total: 30

    Design felt that this was a simple solution to a noteworthy problem for elderly people. This could potentially be a great opportunity for the design team to really strut their stuff and show what brilliant solutions we cnc come up with. The design challenge here would be in making this a universal product that still requires now installation. Market synmpathized with the problem stated in this submission. However, they doubted the viability of making a product that can be as universal as would be required for this type of market. In addition, they believed that there are products already on the market that solve this problem better than this idea does. Viability noted that we would have to make various desings for different home decors and different types of knobs – this is unreasonable and not something worth spending a ton of resources on. In addition, the patent landscape for this type of product is crowded and might possibly require a design-around with minimal chance of protection

    Inventor: Angelo Cacchione
    Submission: Backsaving Bin

    Community: 20
    D: 4
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 35

    Design didn’t feel that this submission had much wow factor – similar configurations exist in the municipal sector and the added functionality of having a dustpan and brush are characteristic feature creeping. Market thought that the problem was universal and noteworthy, but that we have already seen this type of product with Stash-Can. We would have the appropriate distribution for this, but making this at a competitive price point will be difficult, if not impossible. Viability expressed concerns over shipping difficulties, as this would be a pretty large product. In terms of patenting, this idea probably falls under public domain, making it unpatentable. However, narrow legal protection might be available if we were to include innovative implementation or integration of new functions.

    Inventor: Adam Cser
    Submission: Granny Radio

    Community: 14
    D: 4
    M: 2
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 26

    Design saw this as a unique opportunity to design a universal, perhaps iconic, new radio. It could be a nice counterpoint to high-end minimalist options such as Tivoli. Market was scared away from this product due to the highly competitive radio marketplace – there’s a lot of suppliers and an extraordinarily small amount of demand. It would have to sell for a very low price, making this a hardly worthwhile investment. Viability noted that we would need to find a radio manufacturer to help us out with this one – there will be many regulatory tests required that we can’t handle on our own. Depending on the final design, there may or may not be patent opportunities.

    Inventor: Denny Fong
    Submission: Mobility Walker

    Community: 13
    D: 5
    M: 5
    V: 4
    Staff: 7

    Total: 34

    Design felt that this category of products was starved and truly under-designed. It would be a challenge to make this product safe, portable, and useful, but it could also be a unique opportunity for Quirky. Success for this product would follow the path of the UMHO Cane. Market noted that this would be a huge, time consuming product for everyone involved, though that means that getting it right would be a huge win for our design team, opening up doors for the Quirky brand. Viability noted that there are many regulatory concerns that may be best taken over by a medical device sourcer. Engineering-wise, creating a safe walker that can manuever stairs will take a lot of time and effort and may even be un-doable. Patents exist in this category, so the design process might be constrained by the scope of available protection.

    Inventor: Scott Lunsford
    Submission: Leveraged Kitchen Knife

    Community: 7
    D: 6
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 24

    Desing felt that this could potentially be a great opportunity for universal design and a good opportunity for Quirky to move itself into the “knives” category. This definitely works with out current product line. Market liked the concept as well, but was highly concerned about whether this could compete with existing players in this highly concentrated field. There could be a legal risk involved with the dangers of this product – what if a consumer’s hand slips and cuts themselves? In general, this product is not much better than stuff that is currently on the market. Viability noted that we would need a great knife vendor in order to secure our spot in this retail space. There would most definitely be engiennering challenges along the way with regards to making the knifes sharp, useful, and ergonomic. The design submission is very conceptual, thus any patent analysis at this time would be premature and unhelpful.

  • Mon, Aug 15 2011

    Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.

    EVAL 165:

    Inventor: Jon Owejan
    Selected: Folding Bike Basket

    Community: 6
    D: 7
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 16

    Total: 40

    Design felt that this solves a common problem for urban bikers while promoting a healthy lifestyle. We would look to create a bag that’s useful both while shopping and riding. The submitted product sketch could definitely benefit from running through design phases. There was some discussion as to how exactly this would fold, how long it would take to do so, and whether it would be too much of a hassle. Market initially thought that there would be limited market opportunity here, as we don’t have relationships with specialized bike vendors. However, other modes of distribution were brainstormed. Viability noted that though we still don’t have a softgoods vendor, it shouldn’t be a limiting factor. The design submission was too conceptual to provide any conclusive patent analysis, but it seems to lie within the realm of public domain.

    The Rest of the Field…

    Inventor: Louis Lara
    Submission: Non-Slip Silicone Trivets

    Community: 34
    D: 3
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 48

    Design felt that this could have the potential to be something universal and iconic. Modular trivets do already exist in various forms, so we would need to incorporate additional functionality to create something truly unique. Some concern was expressed regarding pieces fetting lost. Market felt that though the concept was interesting, the differentiation from other products on the market was unclear. There would be a small market opportunity within the kitchen tools market. Viability noted that it would be simple to source and manufacture this product. We would want to eliminate the stainless steel insert without sacrificing the protection. There are a few patents registered for adjustable trivets but none that cover the submission’s design, so narrow protection could potentially be available.

    Inventor: Michael Taylor
    Submission: Dryer Shoe Grips

    Community: 23
    D: 3
    M: 2
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 34

    Design felt that because not all dryers have internal fins, and the ones that do aren’t all the same, this product would be hard to make universal. They also expressed some concern over whether this would hinder the drying process. Market felt that the mass-market opportunity was quite limited, especially given the difficulty in making it universal. This might be a bit too novelty for the Quirky brand. Viability noted that the biggest challenge would be engineering and manufacturing a clip that could hold on too the dryer fins for long enough. There are a few patents for approaches to solving the same problem, but they don’t seem to cover the submission. In the end, the risks involved with creating this product outweigh the possible benefits.

    Inventor: Jaak Parik
    Submission: Easy Docking Macbook Device Station

    Community: 18
    D: 3
    M: 4
    V: 5
    Staff: 0

    Total: 30

    Design felt that this would create additional work when travelling with only 1 or 2 peripherals. There was some questioning as to whether this would really be any more useful than already-existing docking stations. There also was some concern over the fact that it would need to be computer specific. Market had similar concerns regarding non-universality and also didn’t quite understand the benefit of this design over existing solutions. Viability noted that we would have to change the design every time Apple changes their computer line-up. This product might have to go through regulatory testing. There is currently a recently allowed patent application patent for a very similar product by Henge Books, so design options and patentability would both be constrained.

    Inventor: Louis Lara
    Submission: Ultima Food Steamer

    Community: 18
    D: 4
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 7

    Total: 40

    Design thought that this sort of product would probably be more useful on a stovetop rather than in a microwave. Although this would fit well in our product portfolio and promotes a healthy lifestyle, the wow factor is minimal and its not entirely unique. Market didn’t feel that this solution made much sense for microwaves, as you would have to open up the door every time you want to remove one of the sections. The clear incremental need for something like this in the kitchen was unclear. Viability noted that we do have vendors lined up who can do this. We would look into designing it to fit multiple sizes, thus avoiding tons of SKUs. Patentwise, it would most likely be public domain on the utility side, though a design patent could potentially be an option.

    Inventor: Chris Barnes
    Submission: Sun-Shield Solar Charger for Cars

    Community: 17
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 31

    Design, though approving of the green-benefits of this idea, found it to be too similar to the direction that QDS will be going with for product 137. Also, theft may be a cause for concern, as having an expensive piece of electronics obviously displayed in your car is very risky. Market was unsure about how much appeal this product would be able to create, especially given theft concerns. Also, doesn’t fit with existing distribution channels. Viability noted that we would probably be able to double up on the same vendor we’re using for p137, though we would need to make sure they are extremely competent, as we would be relying heavily on their expertise. There are patents for solar phone chargers and for windshield sun reflectors but none that combine the two, so patent protection could potentially be available.

    Inventor: Jim Siegrist
    Submission: BBQ Water Blaster

    Community: 12
    D: 5
    M: 6
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 29

    Design felt that this does solve a common problem and definitely works well with our current line of BBQ, cleaning, and outdoor products. We would explore the possibility of include non-hose functionality for quick clean scenarios. Discussion during eval centered around whether water would rust the grill. Market liked the problem being addressed, but there was some questioning as to whether this solution was optimal. However, there definitely exists a considerable market. Viability noted that we are already working on sourcing vendors with similar expertise. Engineering this to make the water spray out the way it’s supposed to could be a challenge. The “Grill Daddy” holds patents that are very similar to this submission (7632033 and 7909526) and thus would limit our design and patent possibilities, but protection could be available for an innovative approach.



    EVAL 166:

    Inventor: Adam Rehak
    Selected: Attachable Scrub Brush

    Community: 25
    D: 5
    M: 5
    V: 8
    Staff: 17

    Total: 60

    Design felt that this was a unique solution to a small problem. Though there was some debate regarding whether the problem was large enough to warrant a solution, the submitted design won over a bunch of people. The final design may beed to incorporate an included cloth to ensure clarity and usefulness. Market thought that it was interesting conceptually, but its strength as a stand-alone item was unclear. There was some concern over whether consumers would understand the product on store shelves – merchandising would be a challenge. Viability noted that we definitely have vendors who can make this and it looks like a very simple-to-make product. There were no patents directly on-point, but the simplicity of the concept may make protection opportunities quite narrow.

    The Rest of the Field…

    Inventor: Anant Gilra
    Submission: Multi-Purpose Electric Brush

    Community: 34
    D: 5
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 48

    Design felt that it may be tricky to successfully incorporate all the features described in the submission. This could work as a mini-Sudsi but it doesn’t have a whole lot of wow factor. Market thought that this submission had one too many features – it would be hard to make and even harder to sell. In addition, the innovation involved here was unclear. Viability noted that we might be able to double up on the Sudsi vendor. A lot of engineering and testing would have to be done with this product to make sure it works with different surfaces. Patent field for motorized brushes is pretty crowded so design-around may be necessary and innovation will likely be constrained by the abundance of prior patents. Overall, too bloated to be commercially viable and would be a difficult product to design and engineer.

    Inventor: Seun Ajanwachuku
    Submission: Brush/Dustpan/Duster Combo

    Community: 33
    D: 5
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 47

    Design felt that the compact size and portability of this submission would be quite handy. All-in-one aspect is very “feature creep” and QDS is currently developing similar products within our own product line. Market thought this is too similar to Broom Groomer to go to market with – cannibalization would be a major concern. Viability noted that we have vendors lined up but it would be difficult to get all these features into the final product while keeping costs down. Patents exist for dustpan and broom kits so the scope of any possible protection is narrow and some design-around may be necessary.

    Inventor: Lani Montalvo
    Submission: Bendable Brush

    Community: 32
    D: 5
    M: 5
    V: 7
    Staff: 6

    Total: 55

    Design felt that this could potentially be useful for cleaning vessels of carying profiles, especially bottles, flutes, kettles, etc. The “uncoiling” feature of this would make it easy to clean the brush. We would definitely want to explore different use cases to ensure that it is indeed useful with all situations. Market thought that this was a very innovative idea, the “snake with a brush” concept is fun and useful. That said, this might only sell to a limited market within the cleaning space. Viability noted that we would need to find a new vendor for this – someone who has expertise in embedding brushes. Material engineering would need to make sure that the bristles can be securely held. Patents exist for many approaches to flexible brushes, so the scope of protection will most likely be narrow and design-around would be necessary.

    Inventor: Tim Hayes
    Submission: Adapting Duster

    Community: 29
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 8
    Staff: 0

    Total: 45

    Design didn’t find this idea to be particularly unique – there are several similar dusters on the market. We would need to make sure that this could bend without physically touching the duster end. The amount of pressure needed to bend the duster may be a concern for delicate goods. Market didn’t think this had much of an advantage over existing solutions. However, it would fit well with currrent distribution channels. Viability noted that we are currently working on building relationships with cleaning product vendors, so we would be able to double up on that. This would be very easy to manufacture and no existing patents describe this submission, so narrow protection could be available for an innovative approach.

    Inventor: Adam Aglietti
    Submission: Sponge Top Attachment

    Community: 6
    D: 5
    M: 4
    V: 8
    Staff: 0

    Total: 23

    Design liked that this solution would allow you to have a better grip when cleaning while keeping your hands away from the mess. However, this arguably achieves the same thing as a scrub brush with replaceable ends. Market found several existing solutions that already exist. It would definitely fit with our distribution, but the lack of innovation is worrisome. Viability noted that we do have vendors for something like this and it would be super simple to manufacture. As submitted, the design is likely public domain.

    Inventor: Nasser Mahamadeen
    Submission: Vacuum Hose Duster

    Community: 5
    D: 6
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 22

    Design thought that the telescoping arm feature makes this submission pretty unique. We would explore different static materials for attracting the dust, as well as ways to make this as a stand-alone handheld device (separate from a vacuum). Market disagreed with the design team, stating that telescoping dusters do exist in the marketplace. Viability noted that we might want to partner up with a vendor that makes vacuum attachments. Regardless, it would be a challenge to keep the duster bristles from getting sucked into the wand part. There are patents for various approaches to this solution so design-around may be necessary.

    Inventor: Robert Kincade
    Submission: Trash Bag Attaching Dustpan

    Community: 3
    D: 5
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 19

    Design felt that this was innovative in that it moved an outdoors product inside the home. It would fit well with out current product lineup. However, there was some debate as to whether this would actually help or hinder workflow – would it remove steps or create more? Market felt that it was a bit farfetched to think that people would buy new bags specifically for this purpose and you can’t depend on everyone having plastic grocery bags around. Similar items exist but are not in mass-retail. Viability noted that we are currently working with a c0mpetitive dustpan vendor, which would help keep the cost down. It would be simple to manufacture and assemble. Many patents exist for various relevant solutions to holding open a garbage bag, so design around may still be necessary.

  • Mon, Apr 18 2011

    EVAL 121

    Inventor: Minka Mlakar
    Selected: Roll-n-Go Yoga Mat

    Community: 19
    D: 6
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 18
    Total: 54

    Design liked that magnets could double as weights to keep the mat flat. The visibility of yoga mats would be great for the Quirky brand name in terms of exposure. Also, it would be an opportunity to explore the challenges of traveling to and from a yoga class. Market felt that the solution, though unique, might be something that anyone could make. And though the yoga mat market is huge, it is extremely competitive. Viability said they saw no problems with manufacturing the item as described. In the end, the possibility for simple yet noteworthy innovation in a new category of products led us to choosing to proceed to development with this idea.


    The Rest of the Field:

    Inventor: Miha Mlakar
    Submission: Smartbells

    Community: 37
    D: 4
    M: 5
    V: 5
    Staff: 0
    Total: 51

    Design thought there might be some room for interesting work, but any design would require the interface to be visible mid-workout. Market liked the simplicity and uniqueness of the product but didn’t think the problem was big enough to warrant a product. Viability felt that making an accelerometer could be a challenge and a design-around might be necessary to avoid existing patents. Overall, a clever idea but not something that solved a big enough problem to create mass appeal.

    Inventor: Tim Hayes
    Submission: Workout Ball

    Community: 36
    D: 5
    M: 7
    V: 5
    Staff: 5
    Total: 58

    Design thought that it would be a challenge to get the halves to connect easily, securely, and cheaply, but that if done successfully, the product would be a good addition to any home gym. Market loved the idea, as long as it provides the user with the same quality workout as any other workout ball. Viability felt that there would be a significant challenge in manufacturing and shipping multiple pieces. Patenting might be available if design was different enough from that of the Bosu Ball.


    Inventor: Eric Shore
    Submission: Gym Bag with Clean & Dirty Pockets

    Community: 30
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 44

    Design liked the idea of exploring ventilation for wet and dirty clothes. Also liked the opportunity to follow different stories (gym to work, gym to class, etc.) in researching design possibilities. Market found the idea to be a good selling point but not unique, better-made by other brands, and not a must-have product. Viability noted that soft goods manufacturing is still a challenge for us but that otherwise it would be easy to make. There was low risk for patent infringement but also very low potential for patent protection.

    Inventor: Michael McCoy
    Submission: Deskerciser

    Community: 23
    D: 3
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 37

    Design felt that “working out at work” had already been explored in the design field in the last year and that the product would need to be ultra sleek for anyone to feel comfortable using it at work, especially with its potential to annoy nearby co-workers. Market thought that the problem was small as was the distribution opportunity due to the product being a bit off-brand. Viability had no real problems with manufacturing but noted a high price point and some patent concerns, which could likely be designed around.

    Inventor: Michael Liu
    Submission: Retractable Jump Rope

    Community: 4
    D: 5
    M: 5
    V: 5
    Staff: 0
    Total: 19

    Design liked the non-tangle feature and the compactibility but stated that the jump rope would most likely be the focus, rather than the push up bar. Market recognized the problem and thought that the solution has mass appeal especially for adults who don’t want to use kid’s products. Had some hesitation about market size. Viability thought the retractibility might provide a challenge. An existing patent might prove problematic and there was potential for product liability issues.

    Inventor: Mikee Shattuck
    Submission: Clean Feet Mat

    Community: 2
    D: 5
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 16

    Design liked this idea for people who can’t bend and balance easily, people who want a “spa feeling” while at home, and people who don’t have slip mats. Market thought that there would be limited demand, the solution seems too novelty, distribution would be minimal, and the problem described does not have a wide audience. Viability found no major problems here – some patents exist for shower foot cleaning and massing mats but could likely be designed around.

    EVAL 120:

    Inventor: Charles Bailey
    Selected: Collapsible Wine Rack

    Community: 25
    D: 6
    M: 6
    V: 7
    Staff: 17
    Total: 61

    Design thought the collapsing mechanism was unique to the market and a very good solution that makes your wine rack never look empty. Exploring interesting materials for functionality and aesthetics would be a interesting challenge. Market thought even thought the wine rack market is extremely competitive, that it would be fairly easy to get retail placement for a product like this – it is unique and solves the problem that the ideator has taken note of. Viability thought this would sell for anywhere between $20 and $100 depending on the construction quality. Though we have suppliers that can make this, there’s some concern over high unit cost. There was some possibility for patent protection. All in all, we chose to move this idea into the development stage with this product because it is a clever solution to a clearly stated problem that we can see ourselves making well and selling a lot of.

    The Rest of the Field:

    Inventor: Joe Ernst
    Submission: Electric Dustpan

    Community: 35
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 4
    Staff: 0
    Total: 46

    Design felt that this idea was very similar to the “Eye-vac” product, but with the addition of mobility. The usefulness of this idea for wood flooring was noted, but there was a question of why someone wouldn’t just use a mobile vacuum cleaner. Market didn’t think the idea was very unique but there definitely exists a good sized market if we could make a better product than competitors. Viability saw no manufacturing problems, but a close patent made this a risky idea to take on.

    Inventor: Marc Rumaner
    Submission: Laptop Drawer

    Community: 31
    D: 5
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 46

    Design liked that it solves the problem of organizing the small items that you need to carry with your laptop but found several flaws in the idea as proposed, including a need for heat ventilation, not being able to fit all laptop sizes, and the fact that the drawer would only be able to hold skinny accessories. Market didn’t think the proposed problem was big enough to create demand. It seems a bit too specialty and not really a must-have. Viability wrote that it would be easy to make, but hard to adapt to different sized laptops. There was slight potential for patent protection.

    Inventor: Rene Diaz
    Submission: Water Gun

    Community: 30
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 44

    Design commented on the lack of a true problem being solved by this idea – at best, it would be a fun new addition to water fights. The design process would consist mostly of looking at fun ways of carrying the gun and squeezing the water out. Market found the idea to be way off brand and not solving any problem. However, good market size exists for water balloons and if we made it really unique, there might be room for retail placement. Viability felt it would be easy to make as it is just plastic, but was confused by how a water balloon could even function as a water gun. There was slight potential for patent protection.

    Inventor: Susan Reed
    Submission: Skillet with Spout and Removable Strainer

    Community: 22
    D: 4
    M: 5
    V: 5
    Staff: 0
    Total: 36

    Although the proposed problem was interesting, Design thought the solution offered was not. Rather than making the task easier, it made it more complicated (it would be just as easy to soak up oil with newspaper or to use an empty can). Market found that it would be hard to sell because of the difficulty in demonstrating its usefulness. They did propose that it could be double as an attachment to put onto other skillets. Viability noted that though we have suppliers for this product, the multiple parts would require high unit costs. Patentwise, there were several close patents. In the end, not something that presented an exciting opportunity for us.

    Inventor: Bill Ward
    Submission: Produce Storage Rack

    Community: 18
    D: 5
    M: 6
    V: 7
    Staff: 6
    Total: 42

    Design liked the solution and felt that there would be room for exploring ripeness and damage prevention. The fact that it could be a line extension for the Farmer’s Market Bag was a positive. Market thought it would have mass appeal but that it isn’t really solving a space problem. Viability stated that we have suppliers to make this, but that it could get pricey. There are no existing patents on the design, but patent protection would be highly unlikely.

    Inventor: Heather Coggins
    Submission: Word Cards for Kids

    Community: 7
    D: 6
    M: 4
    V: 5
    Staff: 0
    Total: 22

    Design liked this idea – it would be a great teaching tool for anyone from autistic children to college students and it could make studying much more fun. If it truly aids learning, then a high wow factor. Market thought that though the concept has appeal, it’s off-brand for Quirky and thus we have limited distribution opportunities. Though the card would not be a manufacturing challenge for Viability, making or finding a speaker that slim absolutely would be. There was very slim potential for patent protection.

  • Mon, Apr 4 2011

    EVAL 118:

    Inventor: Jim Hacsi
    Selected: Collapsible Mop Bucket

    Community: 18
    D: 6
    M: 7
    V: 6
    Staff: 20
    Total: 57

    Design liked the space saving functionality of this idea, along with the many options for use (gardening, bathing pets, etc.) Market thought it was a good solution to a common problem that absolutely has market demand. COuld be the Unhampered of mop buckets! Viability could see no problems with manufacturing, but noted that it could be a challenge to make it rigid, flexible, and watertight. Also noted that there may be a tiny chance for a patent. In the end, we decided to bring this submission into the development phase; it’s a clever solution to a common problem and we could potentially sell a lot of units.

    The Rest of the Field…

    Inventor: Michael Liu
    Submission: Plastic Wrap Dispenser

    Community: 34
    D: 4
    M: 6
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 51

    Design felt that many people could relate to the problem and that the design process could result in a more aesthetically pleasing version than the current available options. Market noted that this sort of product would be an impulse buy. It would work well as a line extension to current kitchen products. However, it asdds another step to the process and though it may look good, you don’t really need it. Viability felt that it would be very easy to make if it was just simple plastic parts. There would be nearly zero chance to get this product patented.

    Inventor: Joseph McMillan
    Submission: Multi Toilet Paper Adapter

    Community: 30
    D: 5
    M: 4
    V: 8
    Staff: 0
    Total: 47

    Design thought that the problem being solved was more of an “annoyance” then a true problem. However, they liked the idea of bringing a normally industrial product to a consumer level. Could be made especially for families with young kids or really anyone in a shared living space. Market didn’t think it would be a must-have ite and noted that it would be very hard to make this universal. Viability had no problems on the manufacturing front but noted that there would be a tiny chance for patentability.

    Inventor: Mike Elliot
    Submission: Ice Bore

    Community: 24
    D: 2
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 37

    Design thought that in addition being a tough engineering challenge, as proposed, the product would be messy to clean and in general was not a much better solution than just running a scooper under hot water. Market didn’t feel like this was an area that really needed innovation – scoopers do the job just fine. Viability noted that although it would be easy to manufacture, engineering would be significantly difficult. Most likely no chance for patent protection.

    Inventor: Marnie Perri
    Submission: Zip Loc Bag Rolodex

    Community: 21
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 34

    Design felt that this idea seemed very versatile in that many different types of people would use it. Though they noted that there was a limited degree of wow factor, they thought that it could be seen as a solution to the “junk drawer” problem. Market thought that the product wouldn’t necesarily fit into Quirky distribution or branding very well and that the problem was not especially large. Viability put the pricing at anywhere between $3 and $20. The softgoods parts would be hard to make, but the plastic ones would be very simple. There would be very little chance of getting patent protection for this product.

    Inventor: David Quirk
    Submission: Mixing Bowl with Control Spout

    Community: 20
    D: 5
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 36

    Design noted that though this solution reduces mess and the need for extra spoons, the potential for leaking and cleaning challenges was not to be disregarded. Perhaps a simpler design would fare better. Market saw this as a possible line extension, noting that there was mass market opportunity if the feature alone could make it stand up to competitors. Viability noted that making the spout mechanism could be difficult. There may be a small chance for patent protection.

    EVAL 119:

    Inventor: YC Chan
    Selected: Tripod Case

    Community: 37
    D: 3
    M: 6
    V: 6
    Staff: 18
    Total: 70

    Though design thought that there was a viable problem being addressed, they also pointed out that there were nearly identical products on the market and that conceptually, the product might be a competitor to DigiDudes. Market thought the feature was an interesting, innovative addition to the camera case market, which is very large. Viability noted that the softgoods could be an issue and that there’s potential both for patet infringement and patent protection. The manufacturing challenge would come in making it “universal” to all cameras. In the end we decided that this product could do very well in the market – there are many situations where it could come in handy and the feature is unique enough to stand out against competition.

    The Rest of the Field…

    Inventor: Denny Fong
    Submission: Flash Enhancer

    Community: 26
    D: 5
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 5
    Total: 47

    Design liked the idea of bringing professional tools to mass market and thought that the challenge of making this product universal without adding too much bulk would be interesting and engaging. Compatibility with the iPhone camera was noted. Market thought that though the solution made sense, there is a lack of market opportunity, as it would only do well in specialty stores. Viability stated that it would be easy to make, as it would just be molded plastic. This product would most likely not be patentable.

    Inventor: Ryan Kent
    Submission: Photo Download Hub

    Community: 23
    D: 5
    M: 7
    V: 5
    Staff: 5
    Total: 34

    Design felt that the world of photo-sharing is currently extremely easy and that this idea, though clever on its own, doesn’t seem to measure up to current models. Market noted the same thing, stating that many similar items exist, along with social media sites that perform similar function. Viability thought that it could sell for $15 or $20. We have suppliers for USBs, but we would need to find someone for the card reader. There seems to be a high risk for patent infringement.

    Inventor: Eric Shore
    Submission: Photostreamer

    Community: 22
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 4
    Staff: 0
    Total: 33

    Design thought this product was much too “novelty”. Also, it would most likely be expensive to manufacture – hooking an ipad up to a tv would be a cheaper, easier alternative. We would need a software engineer. Market noted that the market for digital photo frames is very competitive – retail prices are continually dropping and shelves are dominated by top-notch companies like Pandigital, Sony, and HP. Viability said that this idea could very well need to be sold at a price point of $300, would require a software engineer, and would need to be put through ETL testing. There is a risk of patent infringement and a moderate chance of patent protection.

    Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
    Submission: E-Grips

    Community: 20
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 35

    Design noted that the chance to explore iPad-as-camcorder use could be an interesting task. However, many iPad cases already offer much of the proposed functionality. Market didn’t think the problem was large enough to warrant such a solution and it wasn’t necessarily a “must-have”. Also, not very portable in its current design. Viability could foresee no problems with manufacturing. The patent landscape is complex, but there may be a possibility for protection.

    Inventor: Tyrel Hatfield
    Submission: Battery Charging Camera Case

    Community: 5
    D: 5
    M: 6
    V: 5
    Staff: 0
    Total: 21

    Design liked the way that it solves the problem of messy camera bags with tangled cords and missing batteries – this could be a good product for use before a big outing or trip. Not much wow factor, however. Market favored this type of charging over solar powered cases and thought that it fit our distribution channels. Viability thought that there would be a definite challenge in manufacturing a joint softgoods and electronics product. Seems like there would be very little, if not zero chance of patent protection.

    Inventor: Joshua Beckstrom
    Submission: Steadicam Camera Holder

    Community: 6
    D: 3
    M: 5
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 21

    Design commented on the way that this product would bring professional equipment to a consumer market. They would have to explore ways of keeping this as an “on hand” compact product. Market sees very little mass appeal – it’s a specialty item. The only way this could be viable on store shelves would be if it were compact and telescoping. Viability could see no difficulties in manufacturing (since it is just metal and plastic) other than making sure it worked universally. Price range could be as low as $30 or as high as $100 depending on quality of build.

    Inventor: Claire Davis
    Submission: Sliding Camera Bag

    Community: 4
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 19

    Design didn’t see the wowfactor of this product. It would be useful for keeping fresh batteries on hand, though this functionality is already available in many other bags (though not camera bags). Market didn’t think this was a “must-have” product – it only solves a small problem and is quite specialty-oriented. Viability noted that softgoods is still a category we have issues with. There seems to be a high chance of patentability.

  • Mon, Mar 28 2011

    Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.


    EVAL 116:

    Inventor: Marc Rumaner
    Selected: Dog Bowl

    Community: 23
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 8
    Staff: 14
    Total: 52

    Design felt that this solution could potentially get in the dog’s way. However, exploring “doggy meal time” could be a worthwhile endeavor, as there are many difficulties associated with preparation and clean-up. Market didn’t think this was a very big problem, and our market would be essentially limited to old people and people with bad backs. The market for dog bowls is very competitive and it might be a bit off-brand for Quirky. Viability said that this product would be super simple to make. They noted that though patents exist for pet bowls with upright handles, none exist for telescoping handles, thus there would be a possible chance for patent protection. In the end, we decided to go with this product because there is definitely a lot of room for improving the entire process of feeding your dog, the market is potentially very large, and this sort of product is something we can make very well.

    Inventor: Gary Rose
    Selected: Stemware Saver

    Community: 16
    D: 4
    M: 5
    V: 7
    Staff: 9
    Total: 41

    Design recognized the stated problem as something that indeed does need to be addressed. Solutions on the market are generally not very aesthetically pleasing. Market felt that this could be a good problem-solving product for impulse buyers. However, it already exists and there would be a concern about taking up too much space in the dishwasher. Viability felt that these would need to be sold in packs, perhaps 4 for $20. It would be simple to make and though some similar patents exist, nothing describes the cage idea so there could be protection possibility. All in all, we decided to push this product into development because this is a real problem and a market that needs some forward thinking design, something we do very well.

    The Rest of the Field:

    Inventor: Ryan Kent
    Submission: Emergency Light

    Community: 38
    D:  6
    M: 7
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 57

    Design felt that this was a good solution to a real problem. There would be an interesting engineering challenge in exploring how the product distinguishes between lights turned off and a power cut. Potentially a must-have product in schools, family homes, etc. Market thought there definitely exists sufficient demand for a solution like this and distribution potential is quite large. We would have to make sure it is a universally usable product. There could be a problem with competing against respected, dependable brand names. Viability noted that we would have to find a supplier for the sensor part. There didn’t seem to be any patents out there for this specific design, so protection could be available.

    Inventor: Marvin Blaine
    Submission: Utensil Storage

    Community: 26
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 41

    Design agreed that storing large utensils is definitely a difficulty. However, we already have a rail system in development. Perhaps this could be a line extension. Market thought that perhaps a simpler solution would fare better with consumers, especially since the market is extremely crowded with both kitchen drawers and utensil holders. Viability had no manufacturing difficulties, but did not not think it was very likely to be patentable, as it is very much public domain.

    Inventor: Michelle Brewster
    Submission: Homework Station

    Community: 18
    D: 4
    M: 5
    V: 5
    Staff: 0
    Total: 32

    Desing didn’t think that many students would want to trade their backpacks for this product, regardless of how useful or well made it was. We would look to incorporate mobile work stations for commuters and business travelers. Market thought this solution does solve a common problem. We have the distribution for this through Back to College. We would be competing in a fashion/trendy space. There was some questioning of whether the combination of these features make sense. Viability noted that softgoods are still not “our thing”. Though we could possibiy get this patented, it wouldn’t be very meaningful.

    Inventor: Davide Ferrari
    Submission: Spray Bottle

    Community: 18
    D: 3
    M: 2
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 29

    Design found several similar solutions already on the market and the proposed design would most likely be not much better than those. Though it solves a common problem, it’s not necessarily a problem that people will spend extra cash on. Market thought that though it solves the problem well, no one really wants to buy empty spray bottles. Seems more like a patent licensing opportunity, which isn’t a direction Quirky is taking at this point. Viability felt that this would need to have an extremely low price point (less than $2), thus margins would be way too low. It would be very easy to make. Patent landscape is crowded, but if there was an innovative design approach, there could be a protection possibility.

    EVAL 117:

    Inventor: Andrea Zabinski
    Selected: Hand Juicer

    Community: 28
    D: 4
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 12
    Total: 55

    Design thought that this was a well thought out, original idea. They noted that it would need to be cleaned between different fruits or have multiple devices included. Market didn’t think that the noted problem was really a very big problem and that even if it were, combining a muddler and a juicer seems like “too much”. Viability noted that the plastic parts would be simple to make, and that the only difficult part might be making it sealed so that juice only comes out where you want it. In addition, though many patents exist for juicers and muddlers, none exist for a combination of the two, thus making patent protection a viable possibility. This product was the best of the bunch, combining simple, original design with specialized problem solving.

    The Rest of the Field:

    Inventor: Tammy Turner
    Submission: 3 in 1 Bottle Stopper

    Community: 35
    D: 4
    M: 6
    V: 8
    Staff: 0
    Total: 53

    Design noted that although the concept of adding optional flavors was novel and fun, the general design was very similar to existing shot measure pourers. Market felt that there is definitely a sizable market for this type of item, especially when sold as a 3-in-1. However, explaining exactly what the product is on the packaging could prove to be very difficult. Viability thought that this would be easy to manufacture, with the only challenge being engineering it to seal tightly around the bottle. High patentability score. In the end, not enough of an innovation to warrant the money and effort necessary.

    Inventor: Vincent Vitali
    Submission: Swivel Shake

    Community: 32
    D: 4
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 47

    Design liked this idea – it makes shakers and strainers easier to use while preventing the lid from getting list. Potentially a strong update to a classic piece of equipment. Market, on the other hand, didn’t think this was solving any real problem. In addition, this product lacks a certain degree of wow factor and isn’t nexessarily any better than just having separate products. Viability noted that though easy to make, design-around would probably be needed to avoid patent infringement. Also, it would be an engineering challenge to make sure it closes tightly.

    Inventor: Florian Hoeper
    Submission: All in 1 Bar Set

    Community: 31
    D: 2
    M: 3
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 45

    Design thought this idea fell short of true innovation – it’s really just a bunch of tools in a shaker. Market didn’t see the problem being and noted that it’s “just a storage device”. Viability said it would be extremely easy to make, but there was little to no chance of patent protection. In the end, the probelm was too undefined and the solution was too simple for us to go through with it.

    Inventor: Jared Joyce
    Submission: Liquor Infuser

    Community: 30
    D: 5
    M: 5
    V: 5
    Staff: 1
    Total: 46

    Design thought that his product would fit nicely into the “show” that surrounds bar tending, whilst allowing for flavor experimentation. An original idea in a niche market. Market found this idea to be a unique idea that could potentially stand alone on a retail shelf. The market size is not bad, but not great either. Not a must-have. Viability noted that if made of plastic, manufacturing would easy. If made of glass, not so easy. There exist many patents for liquid infusers so there would probably be very little chance at patent protection.

    Inventor: Iowa Brad
    Submission: Party Tumbler

    Community: 16
    D: 5
    M: 6
    V: 6
    Staff: 8
    Total: 41

    Design thought this could be a fun, new take on mixed drinks. It could be great for parties, BBQs, etc. The main problem with the idea as presented is that it is very kitschy. However, that could be diffused during the design phases. Market thought this could do well in catalogs and on TV as it solves a small problem that occurs during parties. There was a question over whether customers would buy this over a regular shaker. Viability found no manufacturing problems and noted that there are no existing patents for this exact design so it could be patentable. There would be a problem with shipping such a large product.

  • Mon, Mar 21 2011

    Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.


    EVAL 114:

    Inventor: Rene Diaz
    Selected: Smart Corners

    Community: 25
    D: 5
    M: 5
    V: 8
    Staff: 20
    Total: 63

    Design felt that this is a very simple solution to the problem of damaging your iPad and furniture. It addresses the short-comings of Apple’s Smart Cover. However, it would hinder user’s ability to put iPad in a case or sleeve without taking corners off. Market wasn’t positive on whether this solution had enough appeal to get it off shelves. A good idea, but not too innovative. Viability noted that it would be easy to manufacture. Similar items exist but infringement is not a real risk since this idea most likely falls under the category of public domain. We chose to move this product into development because it is a clever solution, perhaps an iconic product, and it wouldn’t take much time to make an awesome design.

    The Rest of the Field:

    Inventor: Marvin Blaine
    Submission: Kitchen iPad Mount

    Community: 34
    D:  2
    M: 5
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 48

    Design found this exact product made by several different companies, some are even sold in the Apple Store. Market noted that this would have to fit all iPads. And though it has mass appeal, it does exist. Viability found this to be an easy product to make and patents wouldn’t be a problem, as it would probably be public domain. That would also mean no protection, however.

    Inventor: Mike Giepert
    Submission: Solar Charging Case

    Community: 31
    D:  2
    M: 3
    V: 4
    Staff: 0
    Total: 40

    Design thought this could be a good solution to low-battery life. However, it is essentially a case and this brief was targeted towards being non-case accessories. Potentially cost-prohibitive. No true innovation here – it already exists on the market for the iPad 1. Market thought that the problem being solved was solved by numerous other charging systems already. They also doubted the feasibility of keeping your iPad out in the sun. Market would not be very large. Viability felt that this would be a challenge on multiple fronts: sourcing, manufacturing, and engineering. The patent space is also notably crowded so any design would require active avoidance of current solutions.

    Inventor: Michael Liu
    Submission: Earbud Cord Management

    Community: 31
    D:  5
    M: 8
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 51

    Design like the simplicity and wow factor of this idea – it sets it apart from other products. Logical line extension to Wrapster. Concern was expressed regarding the fact that you would need to remove this to put your iPad in a case or sleeve. Market felt that this product would definitely work with our current distribution. It solves a good problem, is simple and eady to understand, and is pretty unique Viability noted that it would be very easy to manufacture. The patent landscape does have many solutions already, but none that clip to a corner, thus there could potentially be opportunity for patent protection.

    Inventor: Jeff Tromp
    Submission: 360 Degree Stand

    Community: 28
    D:  3
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 41

    Design simply pointed out that we would be way too late to the market if we were to make this product. Many solutions exist. Market said the same thing, adding that the problem is small and solutions are numerous. Viability had no qualms with manufacturing this and it would most likely fall into public domain patent territory. It would have to sell for at least $40 so we would have to make it look really nice..

    Inventor: Adam Cser
    Submission: Clip on Speakers

    Community: 11
    D:  5
    M: 5
    V: 5
    Staff: 0
    Total: 26

    Design thought this would be a good product for while viewing iPad in bed. We would design to clip-on horizontally and vertically. We would need to look into making this double as a dock, as the market is competitive with such products. Market didn’t see how this could compete with normal speakers on the market, though it does seem to solve a problem. Viability thought we could sell this fore $80 or so. A problem comes up in sourcing, as we don’t have any experience with speakers nor do we have any relationships with suppliers who do. This idea would probably be public domain, so patenting opportunity unlikely.



    EVAL 115:


    Inventor: Jason Hennessy
    Selected: Vase

    Community: 16
    D: 6
    M: 6
    V: 7
    Staff: 15
    Total: 50

    Design felt that this product does indeed solve a problem with a simple solution that is unique to the market. We would explore further simplifying the solution by eliminating plugs and mechanisms. Market also liked the idea, noting that it is a unique spin on a classic product. There could even be opportunity for a wide range of different vases. Only concern is that it may be a little cheesy. Viability found that manufacturing would be simple, but shipping such a large product would be somewhat of a problem. It would be difficult to get a patent for this product. In the end, we decided that we would regret not going with this product – it is innovative, well-designed, and has definite market opportunities.

    The Rest of the Field:

    Inventor: Kate Vallon
    Submission: Extension Cord

    Community: 34
    D:  5
    M: 8
    V: 7
    Staff: 5
    Total: 59

    Design liked the way that this repurposes an outside product for discreet use indoors. There could be a problem with getting the stick foam backs not to fall under the force of inserting and removing plugs. This would be a natural line extension to Pivot Power. Market thought this could be a very marketable idea – it solves a great problem, is unique to the indoor market, and is a perfect fit for Quirky brand. Viability noted that we have sourcing for this type of product. It would most likely not be patentable and would need ETL approval.

    Inventor: Susan Lovagio
    Submission: Water Purifier

    Community: 30
    D:  5
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 46

    Design felt that though this could truly be a life-saving product, there are already products like this on the market that have better ways of getting their products to people in need. In addition, it could be difficult to make the pump mechanism produce enough energy. Market, though happy to add some good to the world, did doubt whether this product could sell in mass-market situations. Viability put the price tag of this one at above $150. We would need to find a supplier who specializes in reverse osmosis stuff. Patent protection could potentially be an option.

    Inventor: Andrea Zabinski
    Submission: Shrink-Wrapped Eco Friendly Blankets

    Community: 27
    D:  3
    M: 6
    V: 7
    Staff: 0
    Total: 43

    Design felt that this would be a good way to transport multiple blankets at a time for larger groups. However, once released from the shrink-wrap, this is essentially just a blanket. We would have to explore how this could be used in mainstream situations (cars, babies, etc.) Market thought the solution was very unique but doubted whether it would be a good retail item, especially given our distribution. Viability thought that this could sell for $20 in general, but could be discounted for real emergency personnel. And though we don’t have any softgoods people, this really is just a blanket. Patentwise, this seems to fall under the category of public domain, thus unpatentable.

    Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
    Submission: Magic BBQ


    Community: 27
    D:  5
    M: 4
    V: 5
    Staff: 0
    Total: 41

    Design didn’t think this was a very notable problem – opening a lid is not very difficult. Also, fog would most likely still form on the lid while cooking. However, this could be a good opportunity to explore the workflow involved with BBQ lids. Market felt that the mini-BBQ marketplace is super-saturated and the included features might not create quite enough appeal. Viability felt that the actual engineering and manufacturing of this product could be a real challenge. This would also be difficult, if not impossible, to get this patented.

    Inventor: D. Sells
    Submission: Light-Up Whistle

    Community: 25
    D:  4
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 39

    Design found several similar products on the market. They also showed some hesitation in assuming that people will casrry this at all times in an easily accessible place. However, it could be designed and marketed as a “must have” safety precaution for hikers, bikers, skiers, etc. Market didn’t think this was a huge sales opportunity, though there would be a chance of success in the outdoors market. It also doesn’t really fit Quirky’s brand or retail channels. Viability didn’t think this product could be sold for more than $8 or so, making the profit margin minimal. It would be easy to make and we have the people to do it. Most likely not a patent opportunity.

  • Mon, Mar 14 2011

    Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.


    Inventor: Jin Chai
    Selected: iDuckling Dock

    Community: 14
    D: 6
    M: 7
    V: 6
    Staff: 15
    Total: 48

    Design felt this could be a good way to reconcile all your charging devices into one unit, while allowing you to display them as home decor. We would look to get out of the “Apple aesthetic”. Market felt that it definitely fits our brand, is a sensible line extension to Space Bar and cord management products. It solves a common problem, has surefire mass appeal, and is a great opportunity for repeat purchasers or bundles. Viability noted that this would have to sell for $60 or more depending on included features. We have factories who could make this. The patent space surrounding this idea is crowded, but nothing specifically for a modular charging station. Would require ETL regulatory testing. In the end, a potential for a great, iconic product that makes charging easy to do and easy on the eyes.

    The Rest of the Field:

    Inventor: Anthony Riggle
    Submission: Fold-Away Bathroom Scale

    Community: 36
    D:  6
    M: 6
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 54

    Design felt that this was a good space saving solution. The hinge might be overkill but it does have wow factor. The second teardrop idea is flawed – we would look at shapes that allow horizontal use and vertical storage. Market felt that this solves a common problem and distribution would be pretty easy, considering that scales can be sold just about anywhere. The solution presented is unique and people very well might find it to be worth a purchase. Viability noted that we don’t currently have a sourcer for scaled parts and that engineering and manufacturing scales are generally hard processes. This submission seems to fall under public domain, making it unlikely that any patent could be secured.

    Inventor: Derek Bess
    Submission: Wireless Optical Mouse Tips

    Community: 32
    D:  5
    M: 7
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 50

    Design liked the potential for this idea – it could eliminate wrist pain, has genuine wow factor, obvious innovation, and would be a great electronics challenge for Quirky. Market thought that this could fit well with our distribution channels, but it may be hard to sell unless we figure out how to make customers immediately understand what it does. Viability noted that there would be tons of engineering and electronics work, much of it exceedingly difficult. The patent space is crowded but there could be a potential for protection if features were differentiated enough. In the end, consumers might not be pulled to this product in the way we would need them to to warrant the risk involved with taking on such a complex idea.

    Inventor: Cody Stowers
    Submission: All-in-One Jar Opener & Snack Bowl

    Community: 24
    D:  3
    M: 3
    V: 8
    Staff: 0
    Total: 38

    Design felt that this submission lacked true innovation – existing jar openers already solve the stated problem. Bowls are a common household product, making a combination of these two products unnecessary. Market did not think this solution was the best option for solving this problem. The features are not especially new or unique and not enough wow factor to overcome that. Viability put the pricing of this at $10 for a multi-pack – this would not be a big product for Quirky. It would be extremely simple to manufacture. Very minimal chance of patent protection.

    Inventor: Garden Hose Wrap & Storage Unit
    Submission: Hose Wrap

    Community: 24
    D:  4
    M: 5
    V: 3
    Staff: 8
    Total: 44

    Design thought this idea was a logical solution to the problem. However, they felt that the storage space would have limited use. Not necessarily the best product with which to branch into the garden-accessory industry. Market thought this did have some wow factor but the problem just simply isn’t big enough. Similar products exist that you can fit your attachments in. Viability noted that this would be made of simple plastic parts. This would most likely be public domain (aside from some old and near-expiring patents). Would be really bulky to ship. Overall, though most everyone believed this was a good idea, it isn’t necessarily the best fit for Quirky at the time.

    Inventor: Aaron Bryant Jr.
    Submission: Qwerty Mouse

    Community: 23
    D:  4
    M: 5
    V: 5
    Staff: 0
    Total: 37

    Design questioned why anyone would really need or want this product as submitted. However, it could have some potential if we look at this as a remote keyboard for viewing internet media from the couch. Market thought that though this is kinda “geeky”, it is definitely unique. Not really a mass-market item, as it only solves a minor problem. Viability noted that we have plastic and USB factories that we could work with. Some similar patents exist which might require a design-around meaningful patent protection would be unlikely.

    Inventor: Simon Shih
    Submission: Misting Lounge Chair

    Community: 5
    D:  5
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0
    Total: 20

    Design felt that this does solve the problem of cooling off on hot summer days and would work as a gimmick for those that want “cooling off in the pool” feel. However, that same gimmicky cheesiness is slightly off-brand. Market agreed, stating that although it solves a small problem well, it would be sold through novelty appeal, thus working as little more than a catalog item. Viability noted that we have sourcers for the frame part but the softgoods would be a problem. Patentwise, this is most likely public domain, making meaningful protection unlikely.