Mon, Mar 14 2011
Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.
Inventor: Jin Chai
Selected: iDuckling Dock
Community: 14
D: 6
M: 7
V: 6
Staff: 15
Total: 48
Design felt this could be a good way to reconcile all your charging devices into one unit, while allowing you to display them as home decor. We would look to get out of the “Apple aesthetic”. Market felt that it definitely fits our brand, is a sensible line extension to Space Bar and cord management products. It solves a common problem, has surefire mass appeal, and is a great opportunity for repeat purchasers or bundles. Viability noted that this would have to sell for $60 or more depending on included features. We have factories who could make this. The patent space surrounding this idea is crowded, but nothing specifically for a modular charging station. Would require ETL regulatory testing. In the end, a potential for a great, iconic product that makes charging easy to do and easy on the eyes.
The Rest of the Field:
Inventor: Anthony Riggle
Submission: Fold-Away Bathroom Scale
Community: 36
D: 6
M: 6
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 54
Design felt that this was a good space saving solution. The hinge might be overkill but it does have wow factor. The second teardrop idea is flawed – we would look at shapes that allow horizontal use and vertical storage. Market felt that this solves a common problem and distribution would be pretty easy, considering that scales can be sold just about anywhere. The solution presented is unique and people very well might find it to be worth a purchase. Viability noted that we don’t currently have a sourcer for scaled parts and that engineering and manufacturing scales are generally hard processes. This submission seems to fall under public domain, making it unlikely that any patent could be secured.
Inventor: Derek Bess
Submission: Wireless Optical Mouse Tips
Community: 32
D: 5
M: 7
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 50
Design liked the potential for this idea – it could eliminate wrist pain, has genuine wow factor, obvious innovation, and would be a great electronics challenge for Quirky. Market thought that this could fit well with our distribution channels, but it may be hard to sell unless we figure out how to make customers immediately understand what it does. Viability noted that there would be tons of engineering and electronics work, much of it exceedingly difficult. The patent space is crowded but there could be a potential for protection if features were differentiated enough. In the end, consumers might not be pulled to this product in the way we would need them to to warrant the risk involved with taking on such a complex idea.
Inventor: Cody Stowers
Submission: All-in-One Jar Opener & Snack Bowl
Community: 24
D: 3
M: 3
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 38
Design felt that this submission lacked true innovation – existing jar openers already solve the stated problem. Bowls are a common household product, making a combination of these two products unnecessary. Market did not think this solution was the best option for solving this problem. The features are not especially new or unique and not enough wow factor to overcome that. Viability put the pricing of this at $10 for a multi-pack – this would not be a big product for Quirky. It would be extremely simple to manufacture. Very minimal chance of patent protection.
Inventor: Garden Hose Wrap & Storage Unit
Submission: Hose Wrap
Community: 24
D: 4
M: 5
V: 3
Staff: 8
Total: 44
Design thought this idea was a logical solution to the problem. However, they felt that the storage space would have limited use. Not necessarily the best product with which to branch into the garden-accessory industry. Market thought this did have some wow factor but the problem just simply isn’t big enough. Similar products exist that you can fit your attachments in. Viability noted that this would be made of simple plastic parts. This would most likely be public domain (aside from some old and near-expiring patents). Would be really bulky to ship. Overall, though most everyone believed this was a good idea, it isn’t necessarily the best fit for Quirky at the time.
Inventor: Aaron Bryant Jr.
Submission: Qwerty Mouse
Community: 23
D: 4
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 37
Design questioned why anyone would really need or want this product as submitted. However, it could have some potential if we look at this as a remote keyboard for viewing internet media from the couch. Market thought that though this is kinda “geeky”, it is definitely unique. Not really a mass-market item, as it only solves a minor problem. Viability noted that we have plastic and USB factories that we could work with. Some similar patents exist which might require a design-around meaningful patent protection would be unlikely.
Inventor: Simon Shih
Submission: Misting Lounge Chair
Community: 5
D: 5
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 20
Design felt that this does solve the problem of cooling off on hot summer days and would work as a gimmick for those that want “cooling off in the pool” feel. However, that same gimmicky cheesiness is slightly off-brand. Market agreed, stating that although it solves a small problem well, it would be sold through novelty appeal, thus working as little more than a catalog item. Viability noted that we have sourcers for the frame part but the softgoods would be a problem. Patentwise, this is most likely public domain, making meaningful protection unlikely.