Mon, Mar 21 2011
Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.
EVAL 114:
Inventor: Rene Diaz
Selected: Smart Corners
Community: 25
D: 5
M: 5
V: 8
Staff: 20
Total: 63
Design felt that this is a very simple solution to the problem of damaging your iPad and furniture. It addresses the short-comings of Apple’s Smart Cover. However, it would hinder user’s ability to put iPad in a case or sleeve without taking corners off. Market wasn’t positive on whether this solution had enough appeal to get it off shelves. A good idea, but not too innovative. Viability noted that it would be easy to manufacture. Similar items exist but infringement is not a real risk since this idea most likely falls under the category of public domain. We chose to move this product into development because it is a clever solution, perhaps an iconic product, and it wouldn’t take much time to make an awesome design.
The Rest of the Field:
Inventor: Marvin Blaine
Submission: Kitchen iPad Mount
Community: 34
D: 2
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 48
Design found this exact product made by several different companies, some are even sold in the Apple Store. Market noted that this would have to fit all iPads. And though it has mass appeal, it does exist. Viability found this to be an easy product to make and patents wouldn’t be a problem, as it would probably be public domain. That would also mean no protection, however.
Inventor: Mike Giepert
Submission: Solar Charging Case
Community: 31
D: 2
M: 3
V: 4
Staff: 0
Total: 40
Design thought this could be a good solution to low-battery life. However, it is essentially a case and this brief was targeted towards being non-case accessories. Potentially cost-prohibitive. No true innovation here – it already exists on the market for the iPad 1. Market thought that the problem being solved was solved by numerous other charging systems already. They also doubted the feasibility of keeping your iPad out in the sun. Market would not be very large. Viability felt that this would be a challenge on multiple fronts: sourcing, manufacturing, and engineering. The patent space is also notably crowded so any design would require active avoidance of current solutions.
Inventor: Michael Liu
Submission: Earbud Cord Management
Community: 31
D: 5
M: 8
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 51
Design like the simplicity and wow factor of this idea – it sets it apart from other products. Logical line extension to Wrapster. Concern was expressed regarding the fact that you would need to remove this to put your iPad in a case or sleeve. Market felt that this product would definitely work with our current distribution. It solves a good problem, is simple and eady to understand, and is pretty unique Viability noted that it would be very easy to manufacture. The patent landscape does have many solutions already, but none that clip to a corner, thus there could potentially be opportunity for patent protection.
Inventor: Jeff Tromp
Submission: 360 Degree Stand
Community: 28
D: 3
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 41
Design simply pointed out that we would be way too late to the market if we were to make this product. Many solutions exist. Market said the same thing, adding that the problem is small and solutions are numerous. Viability had no qualms with manufacturing this and it would most likely fall into public domain patent territory. It would have to sell for at least $40 so we would have to make it look really nice..
Inventor: Adam Cser
Submission: Clip on Speakers
Community: 11
D: 5
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 26
Design thought this would be a good product for while viewing iPad in bed. We would design to clip-on horizontally and vertically. We would need to look into making this double as a dock, as the market is competitive with such products. Market didn’t see how this could compete with normal speakers on the market, though it does seem to solve a problem. Viability thought we could sell this fore $80 or so. A problem comes up in sourcing, as we don’t have any experience with speakers nor do we have any relationships with suppliers who do. This idea would probably be public domain, so patenting opportunity unlikely.
EVAL 115:
Inventor: Jason Hennessy
Selected: Vase
Community: 16
D: 6
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 15
Total: 50
Design felt that this product does indeed solve a problem with a simple solution that is unique to the market. We would explore further simplifying the solution by eliminating plugs and mechanisms. Market also liked the idea, noting that it is a unique spin on a classic product. There could even be opportunity for a wide range of different vases. Only concern is that it may be a little cheesy. Viability found that manufacturing would be simple, but shipping such a large product would be somewhat of a problem. It would be difficult to get a patent for this product. In the end, we decided that we would regret not going with this product – it is innovative, well-designed, and has definite market opportunities.
The Rest of the Field:
Inventor: Kate Vallon
Submission: Extension Cord
Community: 34
D: 5
M: 8
V: 7
Staff: 5
Total: 59
Design liked the way that this repurposes an outside product for discreet use indoors. There could be a problem with getting the stick foam backs not to fall under the force of inserting and removing plugs. This would be a natural line extension to Pivot Power. Market thought this could be a very marketable idea – it solves a great problem, is unique to the indoor market, and is a perfect fit for Quirky brand. Viability noted that we have sourcing for this type of product. It would most likely not be patentable and would need ETL approval.
Inventor: Susan Lovagio
Submission: Water Purifier
Community: 30
D: 5
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 46
Design felt that though this could truly be a life-saving product, there are already products like this on the market that have better ways of getting their products to people in need. In addition, it could be difficult to make the pump mechanism produce enough energy. Market, though happy to add some good to the world, did doubt whether this product could sell in mass-market situations. Viability put the price tag of this one at above $150. We would need to find a supplier who specializes in reverse osmosis stuff. Patent protection could potentially be an option.
Inventor: Andrea Zabinski
Submission: Shrink-Wrapped Eco Friendly Blankets
Community: 27
D: 3
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 43
Design felt that this would be a good way to transport multiple blankets at a time for larger groups. However, once released from the shrink-wrap, this is essentially just a blanket. We would have to explore how this could be used in mainstream situations (cars, babies, etc.) Market thought the solution was very unique but doubted whether it would be a good retail item, especially given our distribution. Viability thought that this could sell for $20 in general, but could be discounted for real emergency personnel. And though we don’t have any softgoods people, this really is just a blanket. Patentwise, this seems to fall under the category of public domain, thus unpatentable.
Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
Submission: Magic BBQ
Community: 27
D: 5
M: 4
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 41
Design didn’t think this was a very notable problem – opening a lid is not very difficult. Also, fog would most likely still form on the lid while cooking. However, this could be a good opportunity to explore the workflow involved with BBQ lids. Market felt that the mini-BBQ marketplace is super-saturated and the included features might not create quite enough appeal. Viability felt that the actual engineering and manufacturing of this product could be a real challenge. This would also be difficult, if not impossible, to get this patented.
Inventor: D. Sells
Submission: Light-Up Whistle
Community: 25
D: 4
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 39
Design found several similar products on the market. They also showed some hesitation in assuming that people will casrry this at all times in an easily accessible place. However, it could be designed and marketed as a “must have” safety precaution for hikers, bikers, skiers, etc. Market didn’t think this was a huge sales opportunity, though there would be a chance of success in the outdoors market. It also doesn’t really fit Quirky’s brand or retail channels. Viability didn’t think this product could be sold for more than $8 or so, making the profit margin minimal. It would be easy to make and we have the people to do it. Most likely not a patent opportunity.