Mon, Aug 15 2011
Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.
EVAL 165:
Inventor: Jon Owejan
Selected: Folding Bike Basket
Community: 6
D: 7
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 16
Total: 40
Design felt that this solves a common problem for urban bikers while promoting a healthy lifestyle. We would look to create a bag that’s useful both while shopping and riding. The submitted product sketch could definitely benefit from running through design phases. There was some discussion as to how exactly this would fold, how long it would take to do so, and whether it would be too much of a hassle. Market initially thought that there would be limited market opportunity here, as we don’t have relationships with specialized bike vendors. However, other modes of distribution were brainstormed. Viability noted that though we still don’t have a softgoods vendor, it shouldn’t be a limiting factor. The design submission was too conceptual to provide any conclusive patent analysis, but it seems to lie within the realm of public domain.
The Rest of the Field…
Inventor: Louis Lara
Submission: Non-Slip Silicone Trivets
Community: 34
D: 3
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 48
Design felt that this could have the potential to be something universal and iconic. Modular trivets do already exist in various forms, so we would need to incorporate additional functionality to create something truly unique. Some concern was expressed regarding pieces fetting lost. Market felt that though the concept was interesting, the differentiation from other products on the market was unclear. There would be a small market opportunity within the kitchen tools market. Viability noted that it would be simple to source and manufacture this product. We would want to eliminate the stainless steel insert without sacrificing the protection. There are a few patents registered for adjustable trivets but none that cover the submission’s design, so narrow protection could potentially be available.
Inventor: Michael Taylor
Submission: Dryer Shoe Grips
Community: 23
D: 3
M: 2
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 34
Design felt that because not all dryers have internal fins, and the ones that do aren’t all the same, this product would be hard to make universal. They also expressed some concern over whether this would hinder the drying process. Market felt that the mass-market opportunity was quite limited, especially given the difficulty in making it universal. This might be a bit too novelty for the Quirky brand. Viability noted that the biggest challenge would be engineering and manufacturing a clip that could hold on too the dryer fins for long enough. There are a few patents for approaches to solving the same problem, but they don’t seem to cover the submission. In the end, the risks involved with creating this product outweigh the possible benefits.
Inventor: Jaak Parik
Submission: Easy Docking Macbook Device Station
Community: 18
D: 3
M: 4
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 30
Design felt that this would create additional work when travelling with only 1 or 2 peripherals. There was some questioning as to whether this would really be any more useful than already-existing docking stations. There also was some concern over the fact that it would need to be computer specific. Market had similar concerns regarding non-universality and also didn’t quite understand the benefit of this design over existing solutions. Viability noted that we would have to change the design every time Apple changes their computer line-up. This product might have to go through regulatory testing. There is currently a recently allowed patent application patent for a very similar product by Henge Books, so design options and patentability would both be constrained.
Inventor: Louis Lara
Submission: Ultima Food Steamer
Community: 18
D: 4
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 7
Total: 40
Design thought that this sort of product would probably be more useful on a stovetop rather than in a microwave. Although this would fit well in our product portfolio and promotes a healthy lifestyle, the wow factor is minimal and its not entirely unique. Market didn’t feel that this solution made much sense for microwaves, as you would have to open up the door every time you want to remove one of the sections. The clear incremental need for something like this in the kitchen was unclear. Viability noted that we do have vendors lined up who can do this. We would look into designing it to fit multiple sizes, thus avoiding tons of SKUs. Patentwise, it would most likely be public domain on the utility side, though a design patent could potentially be an option.
Inventor: Chris Barnes
Submission: Sun-Shield Solar Charger for Cars
Community: 17
D: 4
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 31
Design, though approving of the green-benefits of this idea, found it to be too similar to the direction that QDS will be going with for product 137. Also, theft may be a cause for concern, as having an expensive piece of electronics obviously displayed in your car is very risky. Market was unsure about how much appeal this product would be able to create, especially given theft concerns. Also, doesn’t fit with existing distribution channels. Viability noted that we would probably be able to double up on the same vendor we’re using for p137, though we would need to make sure they are extremely competent, as we would be relying heavily on their expertise. There are patents for solar phone chargers and for windshield sun reflectors but none that combine the two, so patent protection could potentially be available.
Inventor: Jim Siegrist
Submission: BBQ Water Blaster
Community: 12
D: 5
M: 6
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 29
Design felt that this does solve a common problem and definitely works well with our current line of BBQ, cleaning, and outdoor products. We would explore the possibility of include non-hose functionality for quick clean scenarios. Discussion during eval centered around whether water would rust the grill. Market liked the problem being addressed, but there was some questioning as to whether this solution was optimal. However, there definitely exists a considerable market. Viability noted that we are already working on sourcing vendors with similar expertise. Engineering this to make the water spray out the way it’s supposed to could be a challenge. The “Grill Daddy” holds patents that are very similar to this submission (7632033 and 7909526) and thus would limit our design and patent possibilities, but protection could be available for an innovative approach.
EVAL 166:
Inventor: Adam Rehak
Selected: Attachable Scrub Brush
Community: 25
D: 5
M: 5
V: 8
Staff: 17
Total: 60
Design felt that this was a unique solution to a small problem. Though there was some debate regarding whether the problem was large enough to warrant a solution, the submitted design won over a bunch of people. The final design may beed to incorporate an included cloth to ensure clarity and usefulness. Market thought that it was interesting conceptually, but its strength as a stand-alone item was unclear. There was some concern over whether consumers would understand the product on store shelves – merchandising would be a challenge. Viability noted that we definitely have vendors who can make this and it looks like a very simple-to-make product. There were no patents directly on-point, but the simplicity of the concept may make protection opportunities quite narrow.
The Rest of the Field…
Inventor: Anant Gilra
Submission: Multi-Purpose Electric Brush
Community: 34
D: 5
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 48
Design felt that it may be tricky to successfully incorporate all the features described in the submission. This could work as a mini-Sudsi but it doesn’t have a whole lot of wow factor. Market thought that this submission had one too many features – it would be hard to make and even harder to sell. In addition, the innovation involved here was unclear. Viability noted that we might be able to double up on the Sudsi vendor. A lot of engineering and testing would have to be done with this product to make sure it works with different surfaces. Patent field for motorized brushes is pretty crowded so design-around may be necessary and innovation will likely be constrained by the abundance of prior patents. Overall, too bloated to be commercially viable and would be a difficult product to design and engineer.
Inventor: Seun Ajanwachuku
Submission: Brush/Dustpan/Duster Combo
Community: 33
D: 5
M: 3
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 47
Design felt that the compact size and portability of this submission would be quite handy. All-in-one aspect is very “feature creep” and QDS is currently developing similar products within our own product line. Market thought this is too similar to Broom Groomer to go to market with – cannibalization would be a major concern. Viability noted that we have vendors lined up but it would be difficult to get all these features into the final product while keeping costs down. Patents exist for dustpan and broom kits so the scope of any possible protection is narrow and some design-around may be necessary.
Inventor: Lani Montalvo
Submission: Bendable Brush
Community: 32
D: 5
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 6
Total: 55
Design felt that this could potentially be useful for cleaning vessels of carying profiles, especially bottles, flutes, kettles, etc. The “uncoiling” feature of this would make it easy to clean the brush. We would definitely want to explore different use cases to ensure that it is indeed useful with all situations. Market thought that this was a very innovative idea, the “snake with a brush” concept is fun and useful. That said, this might only sell to a limited market within the cleaning space. Viability noted that we would need to find a new vendor for this – someone who has expertise in embedding brushes. Material engineering would need to make sure that the bristles can be securely held. Patents exist for many approaches to flexible brushes, so the scope of protection will most likely be narrow and design-around would be necessary.
Inventor: Tim Hayes
Submission: Adapting Duster
Community: 29
D: 4
M: 4
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 45
Design didn’t find this idea to be particularly unique – there are several similar dusters on the market. We would need to make sure that this could bend without physically touching the duster end. The amount of pressure needed to bend the duster may be a concern for delicate goods. Market didn’t think this had much of an advantage over existing solutions. However, it would fit well with currrent distribution channels. Viability noted that we are currently working on building relationships with cleaning product vendors, so we would be able to double up on that. This would be very easy to manufacture and no existing patents describe this submission, so narrow protection could be available for an innovative approach.
Inventor: Adam Aglietti
Submission: Sponge Top Attachment
Community: 6
D: 5
M: 4
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 23
Design liked that this solution would allow you to have a better grip when cleaning while keeping your hands away from the mess. However, this arguably achieves the same thing as a scrub brush with replaceable ends. Market found several existing solutions that already exist. It would definitely fit with our distribution, but the lack of innovation is worrisome. Viability noted that we do have vendors for something like this and it would be super simple to manufacture. As submitted, the design is likely public domain.
Inventor: Nasser Mahamadeen
Submission: Vacuum Hose Duster
Community: 5
D: 6
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 22
Design thought that the telescoping arm feature makes this submission pretty unique. We would explore different static materials for attracting the dust, as well as ways to make this as a stand-alone handheld device (separate from a vacuum). Market disagreed with the design team, stating that telescoping dusters do exist in the marketplace. Viability noted that we might want to partner up with a vendor that makes vacuum attachments. Regardless, it would be a challenge to keep the duster bristles from getting sucked into the wand part. There are patents for various approaches to this solution so design-around may be necessary.
Inventor: Robert Kincade
Submission: Trash Bag Attaching Dustpan
Community: 3
D: 5
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 19
Design felt that this was innovative in that it moved an outdoors product inside the home. It would fit well with out current product lineup. However, there was some debate as to whether this would actually help or hinder workflow – would it remove steps or create more? Market felt that it was a bit farfetched to think that people would buy new bags specifically for this purpose and you can’t depend on everyone having plastic grocery bags around. Similar items exist but are not in mass-retail. Viability noted that we are currently working with a c0mpetitive dustpan vendor, which would help keep the cost down. It would be simple to manufacture and assemble. Many patents exist for various relevant solutions to holding open a garbage bag, so design around may still be necessary.