Mon, Apr 4 2011

EVAL 118:

Inventor: Jim Hacsi
Selected: Collapsible Mop Bucket

Community: 18
D: 6
M: 7
V: 6
Staff: 20
Total: 57

Design liked the space saving functionality of this idea, along with the many options for use (gardening, bathing pets, etc.) Market thought it was a good solution to a common problem that absolutely has market demand. COuld be the Unhampered of mop buckets! Viability could see no problems with manufacturing, but noted that it could be a challenge to make it rigid, flexible, and watertight. Also noted that there may be a tiny chance for a patent. In the end, we decided to bring this submission into the development phase; it’s a clever solution to a common problem and we could potentially sell a lot of units.

The Rest of the Field…

Inventor: Michael Liu
Submission: Plastic Wrap Dispenser

Community: 34
D: 4
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 51

Design felt that many people could relate to the problem and that the design process could result in a more aesthetically pleasing version than the current available options. Market noted that this sort of product would be an impulse buy. It would work well as a line extension to current kitchen products. However, it asdds another step to the process and though it may look good, you don’t really need it. Viability felt that it would be very easy to make if it was just simple plastic parts. There would be nearly zero chance to get this product patented.

Inventor: Joseph McMillan
Submission: Multi Toilet Paper Adapter

Community: 30
D: 5
M: 4
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 47

Design thought that the problem being solved was more of an “annoyance” then a true problem. However, they liked the idea of bringing a normally industrial product to a consumer level. Could be made especially for families with young kids or really anyone in a shared living space. Market didn’t think it would be a must-have ite and noted that it would be very hard to make this universal. Viability had no problems on the manufacturing front but noted that there would be a tiny chance for patentability.

Inventor: Mike Elliot
Submission: Ice Bore

Community: 24
D: 2
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 37

Design thought that in addition being a tough engineering challenge, as proposed, the product would be messy to clean and in general was not a much better solution than just running a scooper under hot water. Market didn’t feel like this was an area that really needed innovation – scoopers do the job just fine. Viability noted that although it would be easy to manufacture, engineering would be significantly difficult. Most likely no chance for patent protection.

Inventor: Marnie Perri
Submission: Zip Loc Bag Rolodex

Community: 21
D: 4
M: 3
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 34

Design felt that this idea seemed very versatile in that many different types of people would use it. Though they noted that there was a limited degree of wow factor, they thought that it could be seen as a solution to the “junk drawer” problem. Market thought that the product wouldn’t necesarily fit into Quirky distribution or branding very well and that the problem was not especially large. Viability put the pricing at anywhere between $3 and $20. The softgoods parts would be hard to make, but the plastic ones would be very simple. There would be very little chance of getting patent protection for this product.

Inventor: David Quirk
Submission: Mixing Bowl with Control Spout

Community: 20
D: 5
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 36

Design noted that though this solution reduces mess and the need for extra spoons, the potential for leaking and cleaning challenges was not to be disregarded. Perhaps a simpler design would fare better. Market saw this as a possible line extension, noting that there was mass market opportunity if the feature alone could make it stand up to competitors. Viability noted that making the spout mechanism could be difficult. There may be a small chance for patent protection.

EVAL 119:

Inventor: YC Chan
Selected: Tripod Case

Community: 37
D: 3
M: 6
V: 6
Staff: 18
Total: 70

Though design thought that there was a viable problem being addressed, they also pointed out that there were nearly identical products on the market and that conceptually, the product might be a competitor to DigiDudes. Market thought the feature was an interesting, innovative addition to the camera case market, which is very large. Viability noted that the softgoods could be an issue and that there’s potential both for patet infringement and patent protection. The manufacturing challenge would come in making it “universal” to all cameras. In the end we decided that this product could do very well in the market – there are many situations where it could come in handy and the feature is unique enough to stand out against competition.

The Rest of the Field…

Inventor: Denny Fong
Submission: Flash Enhancer

Community: 26
D: 5
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 5
Total: 47

Design liked the idea of bringing professional tools to mass market and thought that the challenge of making this product universal without adding too much bulk would be interesting and engaging. Compatibility with the iPhone camera was noted. Market thought that though the solution made sense, there is a lack of market opportunity, as it would only do well in specialty stores. Viability stated that it would be easy to make, as it would just be molded plastic. This product would most likely not be patentable.

Inventor: Ryan Kent
Submission: Photo Download Hub

Community: 23
D: 5
M: 7
V: 5
Staff: 5
Total: 34

Design felt that the world of photo-sharing is currently extremely easy and that this idea, though clever on its own, doesn’t seem to measure up to current models. Market noted the same thing, stating that many similar items exist, along with social media sites that perform similar function. Viability thought that it could sell for $15 or $20. We have suppliers for USBs, but we would need to find someone for the card reader. There seems to be a high risk for patent infringement.

Inventor: Eric Shore
Submission: Photostreamer

Community: 22
D: 4
M: 3
V: 4
Staff: 0
Total: 33

Design thought this product was much too “novelty”. Also, it would most likely be expensive to manufacture – hooking an ipad up to a tv would be a cheaper, easier alternative. We would need a software engineer. Market noted that the market for digital photo frames is very competitive – retail prices are continually dropping and shelves are dominated by top-notch companies like Pandigital, Sony, and HP. Viability said that this idea could very well need to be sold at a price point of $300, would require a software engineer, and would need to be put through ETL testing. There is a risk of patent infringement and a moderate chance of patent protection.

Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
Submission: E-Grips

Community: 20
D: 4
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 35

Design noted that the chance to explore iPad-as-camcorder use could be an interesting task. However, many iPad cases already offer much of the proposed functionality. Market didn’t think the problem was large enough to warrant such a solution and it wasn’t necessarily a “must-have”. Also, not very portable in its current design. Viability could foresee no problems with manufacturing. The patent landscape is complex, but there may be a possibility for protection.

Inventor: Tyrel Hatfield
Submission: Battery Charging Camera Case

Community: 5
D: 5
M: 6
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 21

Design liked the way that it solves the problem of messy camera bags with tangled cords and missing batteries – this could be a good product for use before a big outing or trip. Not much wow factor, however. Market favored this type of charging over solar powered cases and thought that it fit our distribution channels. Viability thought that there would be a definite challenge in manufacturing a joint softgoods and electronics product. Seems like there would be very little, if not zero chance of patent protection.

Inventor: Joshua Beckstrom
Submission: Steadicam Camera Holder

Community: 6
D: 3
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 21

Design commented on the way that this product would bring professional equipment to a consumer market. They would have to explore ways of keeping this as an “on hand” compact product. Market sees very little mass appeal – it’s a specialty item. The only way this could be viable on store shelves would be if it were compact and telescoping. Viability could see no difficulties in manufacturing (since it is just metal and plastic) other than making sure it worked universally. Price range could be as low as $30 or as high as $100 depending on quality of build.

Inventor: Claire Davis
Submission: Sliding Camera Bag

Community: 4
D: 4
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 19

Design didn’t see the wowfactor of this product. It would be useful for keeping fresh batteries on hand, though this functionality is already available in many other bags (though not camera bags). Market didn’t think this was a “must-have” product – it only solves a small problem and is quite specialty-oriented. Viability noted that softgoods is still a category we have issues with. There seems to be a high chance of patentability.