Mon, Mar 28 2011
Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.
EVAL 116:
Inventor: Marc Rumaner
Selected: Dog Bowl
Community: 23
D: 4
M: 3
V: 8
Staff: 14
Total: 52
Design felt that this solution could potentially get in the dog’s way. However, exploring “doggy meal time” could be a worthwhile endeavor, as there are many difficulties associated with preparation and clean-up. Market didn’t think this was a very big problem, and our market would be essentially limited to old people and people with bad backs. The market for dog bowls is very competitive and it might be a bit off-brand for Quirky. Viability said that this product would be super simple to make. They noted that though patents exist for pet bowls with upright handles, none exist for telescoping handles, thus there would be a possible chance for patent protection. In the end, we decided to go with this product because there is definitely a lot of room for improving the entire process of feeding your dog, the market is potentially very large, and this sort of product is something we can make very well.
Inventor: Gary Rose
Selected: Stemware Saver
Community: 16
D: 4
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 9
Total: 41
Design recognized the stated problem as something that indeed does need to be addressed. Solutions on the market are generally not very aesthetically pleasing. Market felt that this could be a good problem-solving product for impulse buyers. However, it already exists and there would be a concern about taking up too much space in the dishwasher. Viability felt that these would need to be sold in packs, perhaps 4 for $20. It would be simple to make and though some similar patents exist, nothing describes the cage idea so there could be protection possibility. All in all, we decided to push this product into development because this is a real problem and a market that needs some forward thinking design, something we do very well.
The Rest of the Field:
Inventor: Ryan Kent
Submission: Emergency Light
Community: 38
D: 6
M: 7
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 57
Design felt that this was a good solution to a real problem. There would be an interesting engineering challenge in exploring how the product distinguishes between lights turned off and a power cut. Potentially a must-have product in schools, family homes, etc. Market thought there definitely exists sufficient demand for a solution like this and distribution potential is quite large. We would have to make sure it is a universally usable product. There could be a problem with competing against respected, dependable brand names. Viability noted that we would have to find a supplier for the sensor part. There didn’t seem to be any patents out there for this specific design, so protection could be available.
Inventor: Marvin Blaine
Submission: Utensil Storage
Community: 26
D: 4
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 41
Design agreed that storing large utensils is definitely a difficulty. However, we already have a rail system in development. Perhaps this could be a line extension. Market thought that perhaps a simpler solution would fare better with consumers, especially since the market is extremely crowded with both kitchen drawers and utensil holders. Viability had no manufacturing difficulties, but did not not think it was very likely to be patentable, as it is very much public domain.
Inventor: Michelle Brewster
Submission: Homework Station
Community: 18
D: 4
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 32
Desing didn’t think that many students would want to trade their backpacks for this product, regardless of how useful or well made it was. We would look to incorporate mobile work stations for commuters and business travelers. Market thought this solution does solve a common problem. We have the distribution for this through Back to College. We would be competing in a fashion/trendy space. There was some questioning of whether the combination of these features make sense. Viability noted that softgoods are still not “our thing”. Though we could possibiy get this patented, it wouldn’t be very meaningful.
Inventor: Davide Ferrari
Submission: Spray Bottle
Community: 18
D: 3
M: 2
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 29
Design found several similar solutions already on the market and the proposed design would most likely be not much better than those. Though it solves a common problem, it’s not necessarily a problem that people will spend extra cash on. Market thought that though it solves the problem well, no one really wants to buy empty spray bottles. Seems more like a patent licensing opportunity, which isn’t a direction Quirky is taking at this point. Viability felt that this would need to have an extremely low price point (less than $2), thus margins would be way too low. It would be very easy to make. Patent landscape is crowded, but if there was an innovative design approach, there could be a protection possibility.
EVAL 117:
Inventor: Andrea Zabinski
Selected: Hand Juicer
Community: 28
D: 4
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 12
Total: 55
Design thought that this was a well thought out, original idea. They noted that it would need to be cleaned between different fruits or have multiple devices included. Market didn’t think that the noted problem was really a very big problem and that even if it were, combining a muddler and a juicer seems like “too much”. Viability noted that the plastic parts would be simple to make, and that the only difficult part might be making it sealed so that juice only comes out where you want it. In addition, though many patents exist for juicers and muddlers, none exist for a combination of the two, thus making patent protection a viable possibility. This product was the best of the bunch, combining simple, original design with specialized problem solving.
The Rest of the Field:
Inventor: Tammy Turner
Submission: 3 in 1 Bottle Stopper
Community: 35
D: 4
M: 6
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 53
Design noted that although the concept of adding optional flavors was novel and fun, the general design was very similar to existing shot measure pourers. Market felt that there is definitely a sizable market for this type of item, especially when sold as a 3-in-1. However, explaining exactly what the product is on the packaging could prove to be very difficult. Viability thought that this would be easy to manufacture, with the only challenge being engineering it to seal tightly around the bottle. High patentability score. In the end, not enough of an innovation to warrant the money and effort necessary.
Inventor: Vincent Vitali
Submission: Swivel Shake
Community: 32
D: 4
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 47
Design liked this idea – it makes shakers and strainers easier to use while preventing the lid from getting list. Potentially a strong update to a classic piece of equipment. Market, on the other hand, didn’t think this was solving any real problem. In addition, this product lacks a certain degree of wow factor and isn’t nexessarily any better than just having separate products. Viability noted that though easy to make, design-around would probably be needed to avoid patent infringement. Also, it would be an engineering challenge to make sure it closes tightly.
Inventor: Florian Hoeper
Submission: All in 1 Bar Set
Community: 31
D: 2
M: 3
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 45
Design thought this idea fell short of true innovation – it’s really just a bunch of tools in a shaker. Market didn’t see the problem being and noted that it’s “just a storage device”. Viability said it would be extremely easy to make, but there was little to no chance of patent protection. In the end, the probelm was too undefined and the solution was too simple for us to go through with it.
Inventor: Jared Joyce
Submission: Liquor Infuser
Community: 30
D: 5
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 1
Total: 46
Design thought that his product would fit nicely into the “show” that surrounds bar tending, whilst allowing for flavor experimentation. An original idea in a niche market. Market found this idea to be a unique idea that could potentially stand alone on a retail shelf. The market size is not bad, but not great either. Not a must-have. Viability noted that if made of plastic, manufacturing would easy. If made of glass, not so easy. There exist many patents for liquid infusers so there would probably be very little chance at patent protection.
Inventor: Iowa Brad
Submission: Party Tumbler
Community: 16
D: 5
M: 6
V: 6
Staff: 8
Total: 41
Design thought this could be a fun, new take on mixed drinks. It could be great for parties, BBQs, etc. The main problem with the idea as presented is that it is very kitschy. However, that could be diffused during the design phases. Market thought this could do well in catalogs and on TV as it solves a small problem that occurs during parties. There was a question over whether customers would buy this over a regular shaker. Viability found no manufacturing problems and noted that there are no existing patents for this exact design so it could be patentable. There would be a problem with shipping such a large product.