Mon, Aug 22 2011
Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.
EVAL 168
Inventor: Fred Bartel
Selected: Modern Building Toy
Community: 10
D: 6
M: 6
V: 6
Staff: 19
Total: 47
Design felt that this was a very interesting concept – it is true that architectural technology has advanced a lot without any true evolution in the way that it is mimicked by toy companies. Definitely a fun opportunity to explore different joints and materials. Market thought this was interesting and differentiated. If advertised correctly, this could grow virally and have mass distribution across toy stores everywhere. Would need to be addictively fun to play with. Viability noted that sourcing would depend on what materials were chosen – we don’t currently have a wood vendor lined up. We would want to partner up with a vendor with experience in the children’s toy category to make sure that we meet all regulatory requirements. Various patents for “complex” building toys do exist, but a detailed design would be required in order to determine patent opportunities.
The Rest of the Field…
Inventor: Shah Chowdhury
Submission: Key Holder
Community: 33
D: 5
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 48
Design, calling this “Switch for keys”, felt that this was a good solution to discomfort and clothing damage. We would need to ensure that it is made with enough quality that keys never fall out. Also, would need to make universal by allowing for all sizes of keys. Market didn’t find the problem to be especially large and felt that it is a bit of a novelty item. They noted that the retail price would be so low that volume would have to be massive – something that they didn’t feel comfortable with. Viability felt that we might need to partner up with a vendor with experience with these kinds of rotating mechanisms. The company “Keyport” already holds several design and pending utility patents for this commercial solution, so protection would be unlikely.
Inventor: Marc Zayas
Submission: Hanging Pot Rack
Community: 29
D: 5
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 47
Design thought this was a interesting idea, though the need for install would perhaps be a put-off to consumers. We would have to explore how to store the pot lids as well. Some similar products do exist on the market. Market thought that since this is DIY, consumer demand would be low. It would be easy to communicate this product at retail, especially stores like Home Depot and Loews. Viability noted that it would need to either be universal to all cabinets or made in different sizes, two unideal options. Making this strong enough to hold many pots and pans would be a significant engineering challenge. Since this submission is a merging of “slide out” and “hanging kitchen storage”, both of which are public domain, patent protection would be highly unlikely. Though everyone sympathized with the problem and felt that this solution would work, it would be too hard to sell and doesn’t work 100% with the Quirky product line.
Inventor: Jared Joyce
Submission: 360 Degree Scissors
Community: 27
D: 6
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 44
Design felt that this could be useful for cutting linear foods, such as celery, carrots, sausage, etc. It could be potentially tricky to clean. The use of 2 blades rather than the proposed 3 was brought into the discussion, since getting a clean cut from 3 overlapping blades can be difficult. Applications outside of the kitchen (pipe cutting, for example) were noted as a possible angle for this product. Market felt that this was differentiated and conceptually interesting, but it might not sell very well when put into competition with paring knives. Viability noted that we would need to find a vendor with a lot of blade experience to make sure that this product could indeed be useful (sharp, correctly sized, etc.). The submission is very close to the “Cuban Crafters Revolucion” cigar cutter, but the patent application was abandoned, thus narrow protection could be an available option, given an innovative approach. Many people mentioned safety concerns (fingers getting cut) and also the fact that it would only be useful for a handful of food items.
Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
Submission: Tablet Mini-Office
Community: 26
D: 3
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 40
Design felt that this could end up being a very bulky product, difficult for shipping, use, and sales. Also, similar items already exist on the market and this is not really any more innovative. In general, a slim bag would probably be more useful in most use cases. Market agreed that this would be bulky and not especially unique. However, we do have the distribution to get this into retail. Viability felt that though we have vendors, we may want to look for more. There wouldn’t be much engineering work to do since its just a combination of existing products. Patents and pending applications exist for various design approaches to this problem, so design-around might be necessary.
Inventor: Jeff Castel
Submission: Sticky Earbud Organizer
Community: 25
D: 2
M: 5
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 40
Design didn’t see any true innovation in this submission – similar items exist on the market, many of them using the same winding method. In addition, the problem isn’t very noteworthy, as you can just wrap your cable around your device. Market stated that we definitely have the distribution and it would fit well into our cord organization line-up. It could also be a good Back to College item and might be useful for promotional marketing opportunities. Viability noted that we have suppliers for this type of product. No concerns over updates in device hardware, as it would attach to any screen. Meaningful patent protection would be highly unlikely, considering that many commercial products are available. A patent for a similar design solution is in the works, so a design-around might be required. Most people didn’t think this was something that people really want nor need. It also adds bulk to a very streamlined device.
Inventor: Craig Brown
Submission: Perforated Bowl
Community: 11
D: 6
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 29
Design felt that this does solve a small problem that is pretty universal. However, similar solutions are on the market (it even seems quite similar to Ventu). This might be a good opportunity to look into layered materials and aesthetics. Market saw this idea as just a strainer berry bowl scaled up for larger quantities. There was some questioning as to whether elimination of juice would indeed lengthen the life of a fruit salad. Viability noted that sourcing, manufacturing, and engineering challenges were all heavily dependent on what materials were chosen for this design. The design, as submitted, seems unlikely to be patentable. Design-around may be necessary.
Inventor: Angelo Cacchione
Submission: Never-Dull Knife Set
Community: 17
D: 6
M: 3
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 32
Design felt that sharpening knives is indeed a common problem. This could be an opportunity to do some rigorous testing and consulting with professional knife manufacturers and sharpeners. Market noted that this category of products is extremely competitive and highly concentrated within a small number of brands. Also, the problem doesn’t really shout out to consumers. Viability said that we would want to partner with people who really, really know what they’re doing with knives. There would be significant engineering challenges in making this product, as sharpening can be a real art form when done right. The submission is too conceptual to determine anything about patentability.
EVAL 169
Inventor: Seun Ajanwachuku
Selected: Easy Pour Teapot
Community: 18
D: 6
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 16
Total: 53
Design liked this concept, noting that it would have to be elegant and aesthetically pleasing in order to be conmpatible with the ritual of tea drinking. Similar hand-operated pumps are used for kerosene heaters, but this is new to the teapot category. The downside of this submission is that it would need to be battery operated. Market also approved of this product – it would fit into our distribution channels and could be priced at a reasonable yet marginally-responsible price. Viability noted that we would probably want to partner with either a teakettle or pump manufacturer. Making this product work as described (and safely!) will definitely be an engineering challenge, but we believe our staff is up to it. No patents exist for this exact product idea, so patent protection might be available.
The rest of the field
Inventor: Khames
Submission: Rolling Laundry Basket
Community: 36
D: 5
M: 6
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 53
Design felt that although the form factor with integrated wheels is visually interesting, it will probably cost a lot to manufacture and isn’t necessarily a unique idea. There’s also the concern of “runaway laundry” when you put a hamper on wheels. Market thought that this was an interesting product, especially for apartment/urban environments. It does fit our current prouct line-up and it solves a notable probelem, but it may be too big to ship and keep on retail shelves. Viability noted that we do have plastics vendors, but they may not be able to make something this large. Giant injection molds make the operations team crawl under their desks, as they don’t bring big profit margins, are hard to ship, and generally need to be superb products to have a chance on the market. The design concept appears to be public domain but narrow protection might be available for an innovative approach.
Inventor: Art Bauza
Submission: Vibrating Bracelet
Community: 23
D: 4
M: 3
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 36
Design felt that this was an interesting application that could potentially be bexpanded to handle other used scenarious, such as telephone ringing, medication time, or bedtime. The major problem with this submission is that you would have to retrofit it to whatever existing doorbell the buyer has in their home. Market called this a “unique solution” but they did have some concerns over where this could be sold and how we can make people understand exactly what it does. Viability noted that we don’t have a specialized vendor for this but that we could potentially double up on the vendors of the pillowcase alarm product. Patents and pending applications as well as some commercial products in the “bracelet alert” category do exist, so design around might be necessary.
Inventor: Michelle Drake
Submission: Doorknob Lever
Community: 22
D: 5
M: 2
V: 1
Staff: 0
Total: 30
Design felt that this was a simple solution to a noteworthy problem for elderly people. This could potentially be a great opportunity for the design team to really strut their stuff and show what brilliant solutions we cnc come up with. The design challenge here would be in making this a universal product that still requires now installation. Market synmpathized with the problem stated in this submission. However, they doubted the viability of making a product that can be as universal as would be required for this type of market. In addition, they believed that there are products already on the market that solve this problem better than this idea does. Viability noted that we would have to make various desings for different home decors and different types of knobs – this is unreasonable and not something worth spending a ton of resources on. In addition, the patent landscape for this type of product is crowded and might possibly require a design-around with minimal chance of protection
Inventor: Angelo Cacchione
Submission: Backsaving Bin
Community: 20
D: 4
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 35
Design didn’t feel that this submission had much wow factor – similar configurations exist in the municipal sector and the added functionality of having a dustpan and brush are characteristic feature creeping. Market thought that the problem was universal and noteworthy, but that we have already seen this type of product with Stash-Can. We would have the appropriate distribution for this, but making this at a competitive price point will be difficult, if not impossible. Viability expressed concerns over shipping difficulties, as this would be a pretty large product. In terms of patenting, this idea probably falls under public domain, making it unpatentable. However, narrow legal protection might be available if we were to include innovative implementation or integration of new functions.
Inventor: Adam Cser
Submission: Granny Radio
Community: 14
D: 4
M: 2
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 26
Design saw this as a unique opportunity to design a universal, perhaps iconic, new radio. It could be a nice counterpoint to high-end minimalist options such as Tivoli. Market was scared away from this product due to the highly competitive radio marketplace – there’s a lot of suppliers and an extraordinarily small amount of demand. It would have to sell for a very low price, making this a hardly worthwhile investment. Viability noted that we would need to find a radio manufacturer to help us out with this one – there will be many regulatory tests required that we can’t handle on our own. Depending on the final design, there may or may not be patent opportunities.
Inventor: Denny Fong
Submission: Mobility Walker
Community: 13
D: 5
M: 5
V: 4
Staff: 7
Total: 34
Design felt that this category of products was starved and truly under-designed. It would be a challenge to make this product safe, portable, and useful, but it could also be a unique opportunity for Quirky. Success for this product would follow the path of the UMHO Cane. Market noted that this would be a huge, time consuming product for everyone involved, though that means that getting it right would be a huge win for our design team, opening up doors for the Quirky brand. Viability noted that there are many regulatory concerns that may be best taken over by a medical device sourcer. Engineering-wise, creating a safe walker that can manuever stairs will take a lot of time and effort and may even be un-doable. Patents exist in this category, so the design process might be constrained by the scope of available protection.
Inventor: Scott Lunsford
Submission: Leveraged Kitchen Knife
Community: 7
D: 6
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 24
Desing felt that this could potentially be a great opportunity for universal design and a good opportunity for Quirky to move itself into the “knives” category. This definitely works with out current product line. Market liked the concept as well, but was highly concerned about whether this could compete with existing players in this highly concentrated field. There could be a legal risk involved with the dangers of this product – what if a consumer’s hand slips and cuts themselves? In general, this product is not much better than stuff that is currently on the market. Viability noted that we would need a great knife vendor in order to secure our spot in this retail space. There would most definitely be engiennering challenges along the way with regards to making the knifes sharp, useful, and ergonomic. The design submission is very conceptual, thus any patent analysis at this time would be premature and unhelpful.