Mon, Jun 27 2011
We did not make a selection for 148. In some cases we felt that the submissions were off-brand and too novelty. In other cases we were attracted to the concept, but did not feel that it had been at all proven in the real world and we did not want to pursue. The retail partner for this brief did not supply positive feedback for this round of submissions, and therefore we took the decision to pass on moving a submission into the design phases.
Eval 147
Inventor: Robert Francois
Selected: Three-sided Mop
Community: 7
D: 6
M: 7
V: 5
Staff: 20
Total: 45
Design noted that this would be a great line extension to our range of stick goods and cleaning tools. Great opportunity during design phases to explore what the 3 cleaning surfaces should be and how you switch between them. Beyond that, exploring new modes in cleaning (‘deep cleaning’ vs ‘quick cleaning’) is an interesting challenge. Market agreed that the line extension aspect was appealing, and at the right price this would be a huge opportunity. Viability were concerned over hitting a good price point, and navigating a complex patent landscape.
The rest of the field
Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
Submission: Portable Garden Desk
Community: 35
D: 5
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 52
Design was interested in designing and testing for various user scenarios, but weren’t sure that a desk was the right organizational platform for gardening. Market felt that the wow factor was missing when compared to the competition.
Inventor: Angelo Cacchione
Submission: Sharpening Knife Rack
Community: 33
D: 6
M: 4
V: 4
Staff: 0
Total: 47
Design was drawn to this resubmission as there was a lot of talk in the comments about including knives, and therefore we would be designing a complete knife system. The challenge of controlling when/how knives were sharpened was of interest. Market felt that without the inclusion of knives this would not be a big seller. There is some patenting around the concept but the closest patent is expired so protection could be available for an innovative approach.
Inventor: Andrea Zabinski
Submission: Perfect Cookie Sheet
Community: 25
D: 5
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 41
Design felt that the interchangeable inserts potentially had some wow factor to bakers/families. Market felt that there are many silicone baking trays solving for the problem of burnt edges. Viability noted that this ideas would be very easy to manufacture, however there are existing patents for silicone baking sheets with cookie compartments.
Inventor: Dave Fulton
Submission: Pitcher with frozen mixer
Community: 23
D: 4
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 38
Design felt that this was tackling small problems for seasonal iced drinks. Market felt that while it would be good for bbqs and summer parties, it didn’t scream ‘I must have’. Commercial products exist for non-dilutive cooling, so patent protection would probably not be available.
Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
Submission: Dual Blade Wheel Cutter
Community: 22
D: 3
M: 3
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 33
Design penalized this for not being user-friendly: to get a true triangular slice, the blades would have to move apart at a certain rate in relation to the speed of the cut. The discussion during eval also surfaced the fact that you would only need two blades for the first cut. Our legal counsel commented that there is a close approach being commercialized and currently seeking patent protection but it only cuts one line at a time.
Eval 148: Spa Products
Inventor: Emmanuel Maia
Submission: Hot Spine Massager
Community: 36
D: 5
M: 6
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 52
Design was interested in the idea of making this treatment more accessible, but that we would have to solve for making it user-friendly. Design also felt it was a little off-brand and gimmicky. Market were attracted to its uniqueness in the market place and that it can easily be demonstrated on the packaging at point-of-sale. Viability noted that it would certainly require strict regulatory approval and that there don’t appear to be any patents or commercial products that mimic hot stone massage in this fashion.
Inventor: Miha Mlakar
Submission: 5-head Wet Scrubber
Community: 29
D: 5
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 44
Design felt that the only challenge here was making the heads fir over your existing shower head. Market felt the interchangeable heads made the product unique to market. Viability noted that similar material items exist and therefore it should be easy to source.
Inventor: Steve Crockett
Submission: Bathtub scent machine and speaker
Community: 27
D: 4
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 41
Some interest in this one, especially from those who appreciate taking regular baths. Design felt that is was somewhat gimmicky. Market did not see a huge problem being solved. Viability felt that it was a combination of common functions, and therefore easy enough to manufacture but getting patent protection was unlikely.
Inventor: Jun Simmons
Submission: Perfect Temperature Bathmat
Community: 26
D: 5
M: 8
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 44
Lots of discussion over this one, but in the end the list of problems outweighed the unique inventiveness of the submission: weight, material-to-water ratio, and lack of proof of the thermodynamics involved were red flags.
Inventor: Jim Siegrist
Submission: Skin exfoliator machine
Community: 25
D: 5
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 40
While we liked that this distinguished itself from competitors by not requiring batteries, we had some concerns over how much scrubbing torque would be provided by water-power alone. Market were concerned that, as submitted, it required a diverter piece for installation. Our legal counsel highlighted a complex patent landscape, with meaningful protection unlikely.
Inventor: Elfin Magic
Submission: All-in-one spa Massage Experience
Community: 15
D: 5
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 30
Design felt that the submission was fun but off-brand. We would tweak it to be a universal massaging sleeve to be used on any part of the body. Market penalized due to the submission’s novelty feel, while viability felt that the challenge would be to ensure a great massage experience at the right price point.
Inventor: Abdullah Al-Harbi
Submission: Headrest Pillow and Sunshade
Community: 23
D: 4
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 38
As submitted this feels off-brand, and challenge would be to tweak materials and functionality to elevate it to be a compelling product. Market felt it was not suited to the brief, while viability felt this would be easy to execute on with the correct soft goods vendor.