Mon, Sep 19 2011
Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.
EVAL 178
Inventor: Ryan Campagna
Selected: Adjustable Baking Pan
Community: 6
D: 5
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 16
Total: 39
Design liked the space saving aspect of this product and that it could be an interesting modular solution for an all-in-one baking pan. Market said that depending on Design’s solutions that we would have the correct distribution outlets. They also said that this idea had great wow factor. Viability noted that we already have vendors familiar with making bakeware, but could not elaborate further on manufacturing because they were unsure about the mechanisms of this product.
Inventor: Angelo Cacchione
Selected: Cupboard Storage Unit
Community: 32
D: 3
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 46
Design felt that this solution to the lack of kitchen storage was on the right track, however they did say that many simpler solutions already exist. Market remarked that this idea did not excite them and that it would not be possible to make a universal version of this product. Viability reiterated Market’s comment on the inability to make this product universal. They also said that manufacturing could present some challenges.
Inventor: Becki Rundels
Selected: Non-Slip Bathmat
Community: 22
D: 6
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 2
Total: 42
Design liked the ability to solve everyday safety issues of children and elderly falling in the bathtub. They also liked the simplicity of this solution. Market wondered if this was a good brand fit, but they were also enthusiastic about it. They did mention, however, that cleaning of the mat would be hard and it would be tricky to make this universal for all bathtubs. Viability said we would need to find a vendor familiar with making bathmats.
Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
Selected: Multi-Measuring Tape
Community: 20
D: 5
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 36
Design felt that this idea could be an interesting look at the traditional measuring tape. Market liked this idea, but said in order to sell it would really need to be wow and it would have to have a low price point in order to compete. Viability noted that any protection would be narrow because there are some expired patents surrounding measuring tapes. They also said that we may have vendors who could potentially manufacture this.
Inventor: Joe Flatley
Selected: Beverage Carton Tap
Community: 20
D: 5
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 35
Design said that the problem presented is an issue that many people associate with, but they were not sure if the tap would be able to get all the liquid from the carton. Market pointed out that a $6 solution already exists, but said if we made disposable versions it could be an interesting solution to this problem. Viability said that the only manufacturing challenge would be the seal around the mouth of the carton to prevent leaking. Also, there would need to be some careful designing due to the patent landscape.
Inventor: John Wiegert
Selected: Portable Hanger/Holder
Community: 20
D: 3
M: 2
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 33
Design was not convinced that this product would be genuinely useful. Market reiterated design’s point. Viability said that manufacturing would be pretty straightforward and that this product would most likely lie in the public domain.
Inventor: Kim Sprattley
Selected: Kitchen Scrapper
Community: 2
D: 4
M: 4
V: 8
Staff: 2
Total: 19
Design questioned the true uniqueness of this product, but said that incorporating a sponge/rag along with product could be a good solution to cleaning up the kitchen. Market said that similar products already exist and the price point would have to be low in order to compete. Viability was unsure about materials; depending on the final design, manufacturing might pose problems.
EVAL 179
Inventor: David Cole
Selected: Reusable Spray Bottle
Community: 12
D: 6
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 10
Total: 41
Design said that there was a lot of potential for this product. They liked the “green” and socially responsible aspect of this project. Market liked what design liked and said they could make this a higher end item. Viability said that we would need to find a vendor who makes these kinds of bottles. Because the submission is abstract, the patent landscape would have to be explored at a later stage of development.
Inventor: David Quirky
Selected: Silicon Saddle Bag
Community: 33
D: 4
M: 4
V: 8
Staff: 2
Total: 51
Design said that this was a simple storage solution for keeping cleaning supplies together. They pointed out that it would need to be easy to clean so they might have to explore different materials. Market felt that this was not a big enough problem, but did say that we did have the proper distribution channels. Viability said that if it were made out of plastic, manufacturing would not pose a problem.
Inventor: David Suh
Selected: Dust Monster
Community: 25
D: 3
M: 5
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 41
Design was worried about the ergonomics of the product as presented, but liked the overall idea of having the dustpan and brush lay flat. Market said that this product could have major wow factor depending on the final design, which would be necessary to be competitive. Viability said that we have a number of vendors that deal with plastic who would be able to do this, but ensuring proper strength on the hinges for continual use would be a challenge.
Inventor: Paul Schmitzer
Selected: Expandable Arm Storage Rack
Community: 24
D: 3
M: 2
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 36
Design said that this idea had minimal wow factor and that many simpler solutions already existed. Market repeated Design’s point about the competitive landscape. Viability pointed out that manufacturing would be an issue with the number of hinges and controlling the production cost with all the different materials would be difficult.
Inventor: Eric Bashkoff
Selected: Collapsible Tool Handle
Community: 23
D: 4
M: 7
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 41
Design was intrigued with this idea, but said they would need to do more research on the proposed material to make sure it would be stiff enough to guarantee usability. They also added that they were unsure if customers would be drawn to attachable/detachable cleaning tools. Market said that if the product would as proposed it would have major wow factor and said it would be a great TV item. Viability also said that it depended on whether the material proposed worked as submitted, then they would need to source for the material and find vendors who could work with that material. The rolling feature of the handle might provide a novel alternative to the telescoping handle which is a heavily patented feature.
Inventor: Joe Ernst
Selected: Electric Dustpan
Community: 23
D: 3
M: 3
V: 3
Staff: 0
Total: 32
Design noted that the Dust Buster already solved this problem and added that this item seemed more like a Brookstone/Sharper Image type of product. Market did not foresee significant consumer interest for this product. Viability said that we would need a vendor who already makes vacuums and that there would need to have a lot of testing to make ETL standards.
Inventor: Johnnie Stewart
Selected: Trunk Organizer and Storage
Community: 1
D: 4
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 18
Design liked the idea of redesigning an old system and said that even though solutions already exist, there is still room for improvement. Market said that the Design team would have to redesign this really well in order to appeal to consumers. They said that we have the appropriate retailers for this product. Viability pointed out that manufacturing complexity would depend on the materials chosen, and that this should be designed to be collapsible to control shipping costs.
Inventor: George Patterson
Selected: Diaper Disposal Unit
Community: 5
D: 6
M: 8
V: 6
Staff: 3
Total: 28
Design felt that this category of products has lots of room for innovation. Market was really enthusiastic about this idea and said that it would have great wow factor if done correctly. They added that this problem was widespread and relatable, which could lead Quirky into creating a baby oriented line of products with a higher price point. Viability noted that sourcing and manufacturing was dependent on materials and features within final design. One potential issue would be it would be large and bulky to ship and they added that the Diaper Genie was heavily patented.