Posts Tagged ‘p183’

  • Mon, Sep 26 2011

    Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.


    EVAL 182

    Inventor: Marylene Gauthier
    Selected: Miracle Bib

    Community: 18
    D: 5
    M: 2
    V: 7
    Staff: 5

    Total: 37

    Design was interested in this idea because it solves a problem with which many patents relate. Market expressed that similar options were available on the market, but were open to the idea of extending out line of baby oriented products.  Viability  said we would have to find a soft goods vendor and that this idea did not seem to have any issues with any currents patents.

    Inventor: Chaim Rubin
    Selected: Improved Earbuds

    Community: 6
    D: 5
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 5

    Total: 25

    Design liked the idea of interchangeable parts for a set of headphones, that way one does not have to replace the entire set if a part malfunctions.  They also said this interchangeable idea could enable people to change between earbuds for different scenarios (like walking down the street vs going to the gym). Market noted that it would be difficult to complete with other brands of headphones on the market.  Viability said that we would need to acquire a supplier for this and that this product would require a fair amount of engineering.  They could not comment on the patent landscape at this early stage.

    Inventor: Michael Yoch
    Selected: Collapsible Bike Helmet

    Community: 2
    D: 6
    M: 2
    V: 5
    Staff: 5

    Total: 20

    Design expressed interest into this idea because they believed that there is a lot of potential for a collapsible helmet especially since the rise of commuter biking in cities, people will want a helmet that will take up less space.  Market reiterated Design’s comment on the potential market, but were concerned with liability.  Viability noted that because this is a safety product we would need to find a supplier with very dependable materials, which may present some manufacturing problems.  They could not comment on a patent analysis at the time of evaluation.

    Inventor: Paulette Jaques
    Selected: Silicone Wristband Pager

    Community: 32
    D: 4
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 47

    Design felt that this was a novel idea, but were unsure whether kids would react to a bracelet.  They also debated which age group this product would be best suited for.  Market said that depending on the final design this could be very unique to the market place.  They added that we would need to find new retail channels for this product. Viability pointed out that we would need a supplier familiar with small vibrating mechanisms.  They also said that the small electrical parts of this product could pose an engineering problem and that it would need to pass special child safety tests.

    Inventor: Ronald Dajoh
    Selected: Self-Lay Kitchen Knife

    Community: 28
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 41

    Design did not feel that this idea had much room for innovation give the motion necessary to chop things.  They added that food sticks to the blade of the knife due to water/juices, thus a bump in the middle of the blade would not have a large effect in solving this problem.  Market said the knife market is very competitive, so it would be difficult to get a foothold. Viability said that we would need to look for high grade steel supplier and the design team might need to do some “designing-around” because of the patent landscape.

    Inventor: Jaryn Miller
    Selected: Bike Lock Handle Bars

    Community: 25
    D: 5
    M: 2
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 39

    Design liked the idea of people not having to carry heavy bike locks, but didn’t know if the process of changing your handlebars into a bike lock would be beneficial for people running errands.  Market said that we have no retail channels for this product and felt that this product would be more of a specialty item.  Viability communicated that we would have to find a good metal supplier and ensure during the manufacturing process that the metal would not rust, be strong enough, and be able to smoothly transition between the different positions.  They also added that protection might be available through the innovation of the final design.

    Inventor: J. Wiegert
    Selected: Partitioned Gym Bag

    Community: 24
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 8
    Staff: 0

    Total: 40

    Design expressed that this idea was not very unique.  They felt the garment bag would set this product apart, but thought that the multiple velcro attachments would overcomplicate the bag.  Market wondered if the bag would change people’s habits of hanging up their nice clothes once they get to the gym. They did say, however, that if chosen and designed well it could open doors for Quirky into the world of sports products.  Viability said they would need to find a soft goods vendor and that there might be potential patent protection through innovation.

    Inventor: Chris Corrigan
    Selected: Improved Knife Block

    Community: 24
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 8
    Staff: 0

    Total: 39

    Design thought this idea could potentially solve the problem presented, but did not feel that this problem was wide spread enough especially since clean knives usually reside in the knife block. Market reiterated Design’s comment about clean knives in the knife block.  Viability said that the shipping cost could be high depending on the weight of the final product.  They said that there exist patents on detachable knife blocks, but there could be some room for patent protection through innovation.

    Inventor: Doug Potts
    Selected: Measuring Spout

    Community: 15
    D: 5
    M: 3
    V: 4
    Staff: 0

    Total: 27

    Design said that this was a novel idea, but felt that this did not solve an issue with which many people would relate and this product may or may not help people’s work flow while cooking.  Market did not foresee consumer intrest in this product. Viability said that we would need to find a supplier with advanced engineering capabilities for the measuring mechanism which could be difficult. They also indicated that this product would require food safety testing.

    EVAL 183

    Inventor: Betty Kim
    Selected: Convertible Beach Blanket

    Community: 32
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 8
    Staff: 0

    Total: 48

    Design thought this idea had potential, but were unsure how labor intensive it would be to change the product from a horizontal position to a chair position.  Market thought that it had decent market potential, but felt that if the product would be useful on the water as well as on the beach it would have more.  Viability said depending on the material used we would have to find a vendor.

    Inventor: Jeff Castel
    Selected: Beach Umbrella Stand

    Community: 31
    D: 5
    M: 5
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 47

    Design liked the idea of being able to hind your valuables at the beach, but were not sure that this was the right solution.  Market had questions about the universality of umbrella stands and they indicated that this could be hard to merchandise.  Viability said that manufacturing would not be an issue, but noted a similar patent exits that the design team would need to be aware of.

    Inventor: Jin Chai
    Selected: One-Wheeled Cooler

    Community: 28
    D: 6 
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 43

    Design thought this was a cool idea, but noted that this product already exists.  Market thought that this was a bit overkill as a solution to the problem and said there is a lot of competition in the market for beach products.  Viability said that manufacturing would not be too much of an issue, but this would have a higher shipping cost due to its size.

    Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
    Selected: Drink Coolers

    Community: 27
    D: 2
    M: 2
    V: 5
    Staff: 0

    Total: 36

    Design felt that this was an inefficient way to keep drinks cool in the heat and noted that there already exist many other solutions to this problem.  Market reiterated Design’s point of multiple products on the market that solve this issue and the price point for this would be very low.  Viability said that this would be difficult to manufacture due to the use of chemicals and the required engineering for the stability of the product.

    Inventor: Cynthia Talbot
    Selected: Freezer Gel Beverage Bottle

    Community: 26
    D: 3
    M: 2
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 37

    Design said that there were multiple other, more efficient products that solve this issue.  Market reiterated Design’s point and questioned how sanitary the nozzle would be at the beach.  Viability said that we would need to find an appropriate supplier and that this product would need food safety testing.  They also mentioned that there is an existing patent that the design team would need to be aware of before determining the final design.

    Inventor: Heather Liebensohn
    Selected: Adult Lounger

    Community: 5
    D: 4
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 19

    Design felt that this chair would be great for the beach especially if it came with an over the should carrying case.  They, however, saw engineering challenges:  if lightweight it would need to support an adult’s weight.  Market said that this chair would need to be collapsible for people to buy to take it to the beach. Viability reiterated Design’s concern about the engineering challenges and continued with how that could potentially effect manufacturing.  They also noted that the patent landscape is crowded, so the design team might need to design around these existing patents.

    Inventor: Domingo Cardona
    Selected: Umbrella Extenders

    Community: 1
    D: 4
    M: 2
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 14

    Design felt that this was a common problem, but were unsure if this was the best solution to the problem.  Market did not foresee consumer interest in this product. Viability said that the idea was too abstract to complete a full assessment, but noted there would need to be some engineering involved so the umbrella and the potential attachment could withstand wind.

  • Fri, Sep 23 2011

    Since I was out at a Bed Bath & Beyond call center last Friday, and then immediately whisked away to San Francisco for The Quirky Moneyball Project, I didn’t have the opportunity to post the results of last week’s brainstorm, so, without further ado…

    After the live brainstorms the past two Wednesdays, QDS intern Gary transcribed the mind maps co-created by QDS and the Quirky Community.

    Here’s what last week’s brainstorms look like (click image to enlarge):

    Product 176: Collapsible Watering Can


    Product 183: 3D Measuring Box


    The entire brainstorm is embedded below (in two parts):


    And here’s what this week’s brainstorms look like (click images to enlarge):

    Product 178: Adjustable Baking Pan


    Product 179: Reusable Spray Bottle


    The entire brainstorm is embedded below (in two parts):

  • Mon, Sep 19 2011

    Prophecy has foretold that on Monday afternoon the top five voted submissions from the previous week’s Community Evaluation would reveal themselves in the form of a blog post. If not listed, submissions in these rounds may still be chosen as Wildcard selections.

    Congratulations to this week’s contenders:

    Product Round 182

    Paulette Jaques – Silicone Wristband Pager
    Ronald Dajoh – Self-lay Kitchen Knife
    Jaryn Miller – Bike Lock Handle Bars
    J. Wiegert – Partitioned Gym Bag
    Chris Corrigan – Improved Knife Block

    Pool & Beach Accessories (Product Round 183)

    Betty Kim – Convertible Beach Blanket
    Jeff Castel – Beach Umbrella Stand
    Jin Chai – One-Wheeled Cooler
    Peter Wachtel – Drink Coolers
    Cynthia Talbot – Freezer Gel Beverage Bottle

    These brave submissions have conquered the hearts and votes of the Quirky Community, but their arduous journey from sketch to store has only just begun. They must now now test their might against the brutal truth of DMV as well as unforeseen challenges from the enigmatic Wildcards.

    Who will emerge victorious? Only time (and a future blog post) will tell.

  • Mon, Sep 12 2011

    Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.


    EVAL 175

    Inventor: Louis Lara
    Selected: Sili Trivets

    Community: 34
    D: 3
    M: 6
    V: 8
    Staff: 10

    Total: 61

    Design was concerned with the many similar options on the market and debated whether this idea had enough wow factor to be selected. Market liked the idea because of the “kit” aspect of the submission and the fact that this product would solve an actual problem.  The only foreseeable problem would be price point, but market was weighing that with the possibility extending Quirky’s kitchen line.  Viability stated that manufacturing would be very easy, however, they said there might be some patents to look out for during design.


    Inventor: Raja Rao DV
    Selected: Furniture Measuring Box

    Community: 1
    D: 6
    M: 4
    V: 6
    Staff: 13

    Total: 30

    Design was intrigued by this idea.  Due to the base problem presented in this submission, the design team was “wowed” by the potential wow factor of redesigning/reinventing the standard tape measure. Market initially had some trouble understanding this idea, but once the design team got down to the essence of the problem Market augmented their score.  Viability saw challenges in manufacturing from the idea presented. Protection might be available.


    Inventor: Derek Wakeen
    Submission: Tape/Scissor Combo

    Community: 14
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 3
    Staff: 0

    Total: 24

    Design thought that this idea was a compelling solution to a problem, however they were primarily concerned with the ergonomics of the final product with combining a roll of tape with a pair of scissors.  Market worried about whether this solution would accommodate regular sized tape rolls and felt that the problem presented was not wide spread enough.  Also, they said similar products do exist on the market.  Viability said that there are several existing patents that could require a design around, but said that they could partner with current vendors so manufacturing would not be too much of a challenge.

    Inventor: Clinton Fleenor
    Submission: K-Cup Spice Containers

    Community: 10
    D: 3
    M: 3
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 23

    Design communicated that they did not believe that there was not enough of a problem for people to need this product.  They noted that spices used for coffee, such as cinnamon, nutmeg, and vanilla powder already come in small containers with shakers. Market pointed out that if one decides to use this product they do not get rid of their original spice container, thus you have two items for a single spice.  Viability said that we have many plastic vendors that can make this product and that this concept lies in the public domain.

    Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
    Submission: Kitchen Utility Scissors

    Community: 10
    D: 3
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 22

    Design’s view point on this product was that is was trying to do too many things and with this number of added features ergonomics would just be thrown out the window.  Market reiterated design’s hesitation to the idea because of this idea being a “feature creep”.  Market also noted that with so many features dealing with scissors/knives, this item could be dangerous.  Viability said they would need to find a vendor familiar with making scissors and that one of the biggest challenges to this idea would be to ensure that all the features on a single unit functioned properly.

    Inventor: BlueAvo
    Submission: Dog Bathing Glove

    Community: 9
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 22

    Design’s main concern with this idea was not being able to have a universal faucet attachment, which would allow water to flow through the glove.  Also, the idea of hooking the glove up to a faucet would limit dog owners to only bathing their pets inside.  Market felt that this product did not solve much of a problem. Viability noted that we would need a soft goods vendor as well as finding appropriate tooling for the rest of the glove’s features.  The incorporation of these features into the glove might increase the need for designing around patents.

    Inventor: Janine Holc
    Submission: Plastic Eye Glass Case

    Community: 1
    D: 6
    M: 2
    V: 8
    Staff: 0

    Total: 17

    Design thought that this product was a solution to a problem and thought that this product could have other uses aside from just in the shower.  Market noted that existing products already solve this problem. Also, due to the limited spread of this problem Market questioned if something could be created to set itself apart from things currently on the market.  Viability said that they have a number of suppliers that would be able to make this without difficulty.

    Inventor: Jared Joyce
    Submission: Framing Hammer

    Community: 6
    D: 6
    M: 5
    V: 5
    Staff: 0

    Total: 22

    Design was intrigued by the lever and magnetic head features of the submission, however, during comparison it was discovered that hammers with these features already exists.  Market liked the idea of unique features on the hammer, but price point would be an issue.  Viability noted some manufacturing issues of producing a hammer such as extensive tooling, design, and engineering. The majority of features in this submission are patented features in existing products, but patent protection could potentially be available for the swing out lever mechanism.


    EVAL 176: Outdoor gardening brief.

    Inventor: Marc Rumaner
    Selected: Expandable Watering Can

    Community: 30
    D: 6
    M: 7
    V: 7
    Staff: 9

    Total: 59

    Design like the idea because the submission presented a unique solution to storage problems faced by many people.  Also, a collapsible watering can would make it easier for people to fill it with water in a sink.  Market said that this idea had wow factor and that it would fit well in our “space saving” line of products.  Viability indicated that there are a number of expired and unexpired patents that design would need to be aware of.  They also noted that we already have vendors that could manufacture this, however, making sure that the product is leak-proof might be a challenge.

    Inventor: Peter A. Wachtel
    Submission: Garden Utility Scissors

    Community: 33
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 46

    Design remarked that this idea seemed a bit “feature creepy” in that it was trying to add too many things onto one device.  They also noted that the wide sheers would inhibit the user from snipping in dense plants and that there would be a problem with ergonomics. Market explained that we do not have retailers that this item would interest and that the proposed materials would put the price point out of our current market.  Viability said they would need to find a vendor familiar with making scissors and that one of the biggest challenges to this idea would be to ensure that all the features on a single unit functioned properly.

    Inventor: Betty Kim
    Submission: Modular Rain Box

    Community: 33
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 6
    Staff: 0

    Total: 46

    Design enjoyed the idea of redesigning the rain barrel and liked the “green” aspect of this idea.  However, they were not sure about the “urban living” and seating application of the idea presented.  Market said that we did not have the appropriate retailers for this kind of item, but it could potentially open doors to home improvement stores.  Viability was concerned with the logistics of making this product.  Finding a vendor that is able to make things this big and figuring out a way to ship this product at a reasonable price could be difficult.

    Inventor: Radam
    Submission: Water Pressure Lawn Mower

    Community: 26
    D: 5
    M: 3
    V: 5
    Staff: 0

    Total: 39

    Design was interested in exploring how to provide enough water pressure to make the mower run, however, they were quick to point out that the limiting factor to this item was that it would be dependent on hose length.  Market was concerned about the actual amount of water necessary to make this item function and they agreed with Design’s issue with dependency on garden hoses. Viability wasn’t sure what kind of materials this item would be made of, so their score was largely influenced by potential engineering challenges.

    Inventor: David Quirk
    Submission: Planter Pot With Storage

    Community: 23
    D: 4
    M: 3
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 37

    Design said that this product would have to be large enough to be able to store gardening tools and seeds. From this they questioned if people would want such a large planter.  Market commented that the storage area would not be wasted space because this could actually keep the plant and roots in place in the planter. Viability said that if made of plastic we have vendors that could make this, but we would have to source for different materials.  Also, they noted that shipping would be expensive, but protection could be available for a unique design.

    Inventor: GiGi Go
    Submission: Mini Sprinklers

    Community: 10
    D: 5
    M: 2
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 24

    Design had numerous ideas surrounding this product.  They liked the fact that these would be easier to install than traditional sprinklers.  Market said that there are already exist irrigation hoses that solve the problem.  Viability said that they would want to find a vendor that had experience with hose attachments and guaranteeing each water outlet released the same amount of water would be tricky.

    Inventor: Lam Hoang
    Submission: Collapsing Planting Pot

    Community: 9
    D: 5
    M: 4
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 25

    Design observed that this product would increase efficiency and decrease mess in the garden, but said the shape of the pot would need to be redesigned.  Market questioned the need for a planter like this in light of the numerous types of flower pots there are on the market, but liked the uniqueness of the idea. Viability indicated that if this product were to be made out of plastic that we have the vendors for it and that manufacturing would not be difficult as submitted.

    Inventor: Trudi Gibson-Nelms
    Submission: Expandable Flower Pot

    Community: 11
    D: 6
    M: 7
    V: 7
    Staff: 0

    Total: 31

    Design liked the idea of being able to incorporate all levels of plant growth in a single pot.  Market said that this idea had unique wow factor and liked the space saving aspect of this product.  Viability noted that there exist patents that deal with expanding flower post so designing around would be needed.  Other issues would be shipping as well as finding materials that would be strong enough to hold the dirt in the expandable portion of the pot.


  • Mon, Sep 12 2011

    Hey Quirks, we’re discussing three topics in Wednesday’s live brainstorm.

    From 12:00 – (approx.) 1:15, the Quirky Community, will have the opportunity to participate in this week’s brainstorm through our Quirky Design Staff + Quirky Community Brainstorm Livestream channel on Ustream.

    This week’s topics are:

    1) Product 175: Silicone Trivets

    2) Outdoor Gardening Brief (Product 176): Collapsible Watering Can

    3) Product 183: 3D Measuring Box

    To get the most community participation, we’re going to start it right here, in the comments of this blog post. Think about all of the different aspects that go into mindmapping, i.e. exploring all opportunities in terms of design, market, end user, user scenarios, modes/habits, current/future trends in food service or space saving products, materials etc. Start throwing out ideas and remember, this is a brainstorm so anything goes.