Mon, Apr 18 2011
EVAL 121
Inventor: Minka Mlakar
Selected: Roll-n-Go Yoga Mat
Community: 19
D: 6
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 18
Total: 54
Design liked that magnets could double as weights to keep the mat flat. The visibility of yoga mats would be great for the Quirky brand name in terms of exposure. Also, it would be an opportunity to explore the challenges of traveling to and from a yoga class. Market felt that the solution, though unique, might be something that anyone could make. And though the yoga mat market is huge, it is extremely competitive. Viability said they saw no problems with manufacturing the item as described. In the end, the possibility for simple yet noteworthy innovation in a new category of products led us to choosing to proceed to development with this idea.
The Rest of the Field:
Inventor: Miha Mlakar
Submission: Smartbells
Community: 37
D: 4
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 51
Design thought there might be some room for interesting work, but any design would require the interface to be visible mid-workout. Market liked the simplicity and uniqueness of the product but didn’t think the problem was big enough to warrant a product. Viability felt that making an accelerometer could be a challenge and a design-around might be necessary to avoid existing patents. Overall, a clever idea but not something that solved a big enough problem to create mass appeal.
Inventor: Tim Hayes
Submission: Workout Ball
Community: 36
D: 5
M: 7
V: 5
Staff: 5
Total: 58
Design thought that it would be a challenge to get the halves to connect easily, securely, and cheaply, but that if done successfully, the product would be a good addition to any home gym. Market loved the idea, as long as it provides the user with the same quality workout as any other workout ball. Viability felt that there would be a significant challenge in manufacturing and shipping multiple pieces. Patenting might be available if design was different enough from that of the Bosu Ball.
Inventor: Eric Shore
Submission: Gym Bag with Clean & Dirty Pockets
Community: 30
D: 4
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 44
Design liked the idea of exploring ventilation for wet and dirty clothes. Also liked the opportunity to follow different stories (gym to work, gym to class, etc.) in researching design possibilities. Market found the idea to be a good selling point but not unique, better-made by other brands, and not a must-have product. Viability noted that soft goods manufacturing is still a challenge for us but that otherwise it would be easy to make. There was low risk for patent infringement but also very low potential for patent protection.
Inventor: Michael McCoy
Submission: Deskerciser
Community: 23
D: 3
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 37
Design felt that “working out at work” had already been explored in the design field in the last year and that the product would need to be ultra sleek for anyone to feel comfortable using it at work, especially with its potential to annoy nearby co-workers. Market thought that the problem was small as was the distribution opportunity due to the product being a bit off-brand. Viability had no real problems with manufacturing but noted a high price point and some patent concerns, which could likely be designed around.
Inventor: Michael Liu
Submission: Retractable Jump Rope
Community: 4
D: 5
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 19
Design liked the non-tangle feature and the compactibility but stated that the jump rope would most likely be the focus, rather than the push up bar. Market recognized the problem and thought that the solution has mass appeal especially for adults who don’t want to use kid’s products. Had some hesitation about market size. Viability thought the retractibility might provide a challenge. An existing patent might prove problematic and there was potential for product liability issues.
Inventor: Mikee Shattuck
Submission: Clean Feet Mat
Community: 2
D: 5
M: 3
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 16
Design liked this idea for people who can’t bend and balance easily, people who want a “spa feeling” while at home, and people who don’t have slip mats. Market thought that there would be limited demand, the solution seems too novelty, distribution would be minimal, and the problem described does not have a wide audience. Viability found no major problems here – some patents exist for shower foot cleaning and massing mats but could likely be designed around.
EVAL 120:
Inventor: Charles Bailey
Selected: Collapsible Wine Rack
Community: 25
D: 6
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 17
Total: 61
Design thought the collapsing mechanism was unique to the market and a very good solution that makes your wine rack never look empty. Exploring interesting materials for functionality and aesthetics would be a interesting challenge. Market thought even thought the wine rack market is extremely competitive, that it would be fairly easy to get retail placement for a product like this – it is unique and solves the problem that the ideator has taken note of. Viability thought this would sell for anywhere between $20 and $100 depending on the construction quality. Though we have suppliers that can make this, there’s some concern over high unit cost. There was some possibility for patent protection. All in all, we chose to move this idea into the development stage with this product because it is a clever solution to a clearly stated problem that we can see ourselves making well and selling a lot of.
The Rest of the Field:
Inventor: Joe Ernst
Submission: Electric Dustpan
Community: 35
D: 4
M: 3
V: 4
Staff: 0
Total: 46
Design felt that this idea was very similar to the “Eye-vac” product, but with the addition of mobility. The usefulness of this idea for wood flooring was noted, but there was a question of why someone wouldn’t just use a mobile vacuum cleaner. Market didn’t think the idea was very unique but there definitely exists a good sized market if we could make a better product than competitors. Viability saw no manufacturing problems, but a close patent made this a risky idea to take on.
Inventor: Marc Rumaner
Submission: Laptop Drawer
Community: 31
D: 5
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 46
Design liked that it solves the problem of organizing the small items that you need to carry with your laptop but found several flaws in the idea as proposed, including a need for heat ventilation, not being able to fit all laptop sizes, and the fact that the drawer would only be able to hold skinny accessories. Market didn’t think the proposed problem was big enough to create demand. It seems a bit too specialty and not really a must-have. Viability wrote that it would be easy to make, but hard to adapt to different sized laptops. There was slight potential for patent protection.
Inventor: Rene Diaz
Submission: Water Gun
Community: 30
D: 4
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 44
Design commented on the lack of a true problem being solved by this idea – at best, it would be a fun new addition to water fights. The design process would consist mostly of looking at fun ways of carrying the gun and squeezing the water out. Market found the idea to be way off brand and not solving any problem. However, good market size exists for water balloons and if we made it really unique, there might be room for retail placement. Viability felt it would be easy to make as it is just plastic, but was confused by how a water balloon could even function as a water gun. There was slight potential for patent protection.
Inventor: Susan Reed
Submission: Skillet with Spout and Removable Strainer
Community: 22
D: 4
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 36
Although the proposed problem was interesting, Design thought the solution offered was not. Rather than making the task easier, it made it more complicated (it would be just as easy to soak up oil with newspaper or to use an empty can). Market found that it would be hard to sell because of the difficulty in demonstrating its usefulness. They did propose that it could be double as an attachment to put onto other skillets. Viability noted that though we have suppliers for this product, the multiple parts would require high unit costs. Patentwise, there were several close patents. In the end, not something that presented an exciting opportunity for us.
Inventor: Bill Ward
Submission: Produce Storage Rack
Community: 18
D: 5
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 6
Total: 42
Design liked the solution and felt that there would be room for exploring ripeness and damage prevention. The fact that it could be a line extension for the Farmer’s Market Bag was a positive. Market thought it would have mass appeal but that it isn’t really solving a space problem. Viability stated that we have suppliers to make this, but that it could get pricey. There are no existing patents on the design, but patent protection would be highly unlikely.
Inventor: Heather Coggins
Submission: Word Cards for Kids
Community: 7
D: 6
M: 4
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 22
Design liked this idea – it would be a great teaching tool for anyone from autistic children to college students and it could make studying much more fun. If it truly aids learning, then a high wow factor. Market thought that though the concept has appeal, it’s off-brand for Quirky and thus we have limited distribution opportunities. Though the card would not be a manufacturing challenge for Viability, making or finding a speaker that slim absolutely would be. There was very slim potential for patent protection.