Mon, Jul 4 2011
Eval Recap 149
Inventor: Jay Kim
Selected: Retractable Whisk
Community: 34
D: 6
M: 7
V: 6
Staff: 14
TOTAL: 67
Design thought this had some good wow factor and presented an interesting challenge. Market felt it solved a good problem and reached out to a large group. Viability was very concerned about an existing broad patent; however, Design and Viability felt they could work together to avoid running into any major problems.
The rest of the field
Inventor: Tim Hayes
Submission: Collapsible Watering Can
Community: 36
D: 5
M: 7
V: 7
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 55
Design thought this was a good space saving solution for storage and shipping. Market has the right distribution and viability felt it would be fairly easy to produce.
Inventor: Jared Joyce
Submission: Personal Ice Cube Tray
Community: 31
D: 2
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 46
As submitted, the ice tray would not be universal, beyond that Design felt that wow factor was low as there are a number of silicone ice trays that solve for a similar problem. Market was unsure if people would spend extra on an ice tray for one, however noted that ice trays are a big market in general. Viability saw no major red flags.
Inventor: Michelle B.
Submission: Spoon with Thermometer and Straw
Community: 24
D: 3
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 37
Design was not convinced this was truly an on-the-go product people would carry around. Market felt it was a bit off-brand and would not present well at mass retail. Viability saw no major red flags, and felt it would be pretty simple to manufacture.
Inventor: Brandon Craven
Submission: Cooling Stir Stick with Thermometer
Community: 24
D: 3
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 38
Design understood the problem, but was unsure about the proposed solution. Market did not think many people would actually buy this product. Viability felt there might be some patent protection available.
Inventor: Edward Wright
Submission: Multipurpose Gardening Tool
Community: 18
D: 5
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 6
TOTAL: 41
Design thought this was a good space saving solution and was inspired by the prospect of designing for different age groups. Market noted that many similar items exist already. Viability felt cost reduction would be an engineering challenge.
Inventor: Thomas Hyland
Submission: Reinvented Matches
Community: 4
D: 6
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 5
TOTAL: 27
Design thought this had high wow factor and was inspired by the prospect of creating a new icon for the matchbook. Market liked the idea of solving the problem of lighting matches in tricky scenarios, but was not convinced this was the solution. Viability felt there would be some tricky engineering but otherwise had no major concerns.
EVAL 150
Inventor: Nathan German
Selected: Refrigerator Suction Container
Community: 6
D: 7
M: 7
V: 7
Staff: 17
TOTAL: 44
Design thought this was a good problem solving solution, and liked the prospect of getting full use of fridge space. Market saw huge potential for sales and for a number of SKUs. Viability thought both infringement and protection were unlikely.
The rest of the field
Inventor: Angelo Cacchione
Submission: Portable Gadget Cradle System
Community: 36
D: 5
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 52
Design liked the universal aspect of the submission. Market said they have distribution but it’s very competitive, and this may not be the right place for suction. Viability thought it would be a challenge to ensure the suction cup would hold, and found some similar patents.
Inventor: Brian Shy
Submission: Suction Cup Magnets
Community: 24
D: 4
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 3
TOTAL: 43
Design thought this could have some interesting applications. Market liked the simplicity of the solution but was unsure of its usage. Viability felt the main challenge would be determining the ideal force of suction and magnets. There are also some existing patents that would require our attention.
Inventor: Robert Pontius
Submission: Flexible Suction Cup Arms
Community: 22
D: 4
M: 5
V: 8
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 39
Design thought this had some unusual wow factor, but questioned the true usefulness of the product. Market has seen similar tripods succeed, but they are typically knocked off very quickly. Viability saw no major red flags.
Inventor: Imants Caklais
Submission: Travel/Dorm Shower Bag
Community: 22
D: 6
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 41
Design thought this offered an interesting soft goods twist on existing shower products. Market saw this as a good line extension and back to college product. Viability is still looking for soft goods vendors and saw some overlapping patents.
Inventor: Adam
Submission: Shower Splats
Community: 20
D: 3
M: 3
V: 8
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 34
Design and Market both felt this was a bit gimmicky and saw similar items on the market. Viability saw no major challenges ahead.
Inventor: Bradly Huether
Submission: Wall Suction Speakers
Community: 20
D: 7
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 5
TOTAL: 44
Design liked the idea of getting speakers in the shower and on other non-porous surfaces. Market thought it spoke to a bit of a niche market. Viability foresaw some engineering challenges and waterproof tech patent issues, but was not overly concerned.
Inventor: Dond
Submission: Suction Shower Head Rope
Community: 7
D: 5
M: 3
V: 1
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 16
Design liked the potential for this to simulate high-end multi-shower systems and offer kids a ‘mini shower’ height. Market thought it would land at a much higher price point and did not think it offered enough to warrant pursuit. Viability was concerned about the engineering around the water-pressure issue and found some VERY close patents.
Inventor: Philip Tribe
Submission: LED+Suction Cup
Community: 10
D: 5
M: 5
V: 8
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 28
Design felt this problem has been solved, but liked the idea of playing with the interaction between the light and suction cup. Market thought this was a good impulse item, but not a game changer. Viability had no major concerns.