Congratulations to Steve Crockett’s wild card entry for being selected to move into the design phases!
Eval 131
WINNER
Inventor: Steve Crockett
Selected: Flexible Garden Hose Wand
Community: 26
D: 07
M: 08
V: 05
Staff: 18
Total: 64
Design saw potential here for the solution to be achieved by making an attachment for any hose that added positionable functionality. Market loved this attachment approach because it means we can execute on the submission without getting into the hose business. The patent landscape for flexible hoses is complex, so we will be working very closely with our patent lawyers during the design phases on this product.
REST OF THE FIELD
Inventor: Seun Ajanwachuku
Submission: The All-Star Stand
Community: 35
D: 04
M: 05
V: 07
Staff: 00
Total: 51
Our competitive research revealed that there is a glut of similar products on the market. However, market felt that it being universal made it unique to market. Viability recognized that this uniqueness could help navigate the many patents that exist for electronics stands.
Inventor: James Breaux
Submission: Mighty Toothbrush Holder
Community: 33
D: 03
M: 04
V: 08
Staff: 00
Total: 48
Design had seen this all before: check out Koziol and Alessi’s more playful end of their product lines. We also felt that the small problem being solved has already been tackled by our existing product, Bobble Brush. We pride ourselves on creating solution-based products, and this didn’t fit the bill.
Inventor: Bill Ward
Submission: Prep Bowls
Community: 32
D: 04
M: 04
V: 06
Staff: 05
Total: 51
Lots of discussion around this one, with strong arguments being made for its use of vertical space while preparing food. Competitive research showed plenty of existing nesting prep bowls, but nothing quite like this. Market were still not sure this was unique enough to truly stand out in a crowded market place. Chance of patent protection was unlikely, and upfront cost would probably be on the high side due to multiple pieces.
Inventor: Daniel Somech
Submission: The Lock Sleeve
Community: 32
D: 04
M: 05
V: 06
Staff: 00
Total: 47
While we appreciate that the problem being highlighted affects a lot of people, we could not see any benefit to this solution after eval discussion. The sleeve only offers a reminder immediately after the door is locked. It would have to fit all key sizes, and we’d have to ensure that it did not impede use of the key in the first place.
Inventor: Marc Rumaner
Submission: Food Storage Container with Plate Included
Community: 26
D: 03
M: 03
V: 07
Staff: 00
Total: 39
Essentially very similar to several other food storage devices on the market, and therefore very low wow factor potential. Viability acknowledged that they would be easy to make, but that there would be no potential for patent protection.
Wild Card Inventor: Bob Fuller
Submission: Lotion Applicator
Community: 10
D: 04
M: 02
V: 05
Staff: 00
Total: 21
When picking the wild cards this appeared to have potential. However, after competitive research was performed, it quickly became apparent that this problem/solution area has been widely explored. Our head of sales pitched this idea to several retailers back in 2007 and it was not well received, and the viability score was impacted by the existence of a number of very close patents.
Eval 132
We did not select a submission to move forward into the design phases. This was for a number of reasons. Firstly, the feedback from our retail partners for this retail-led brief was not positive. This alone was not a reason to not make a selection, but after discussions about potential sales channels and our competitive research, nothing was rising to the top. After the staff soaked up all the DMV, competitive research, and retail feedback, the picture was very clear and the decision was unanimous to not make a selection.
REST OF THE FIELD
Inventor: Denny Fong
Submission: Eco Dryer Balls
Community: 36
D: 05
M: 06
V: 06
Staff: 00
Total: 53
We were interested in the use of Sodium Polyacrylate, but were concerned over the effectiveness of using it in ball form due to lack of contact surface area. We expanded on the idea during discussion: what if it was in the form of a sheet, and you used it for quick drying while camping, etc? Market felt that it had potential (despite a lack of positive feedback from retail partners) but viability was uncertain about sourcing Sodium Polyacrylate and associated regulatory requirements.
Inventor: William Fine
Submission: Garment Roll Up
Community: 34
D: 03
M: 02
V: 08*
Staff: 00
Total: 47
This doesn’t really solve a garment upkeep problem, unless you truly believe that rolling shirts reduces wrinkles/damage to clothes. There was some interest in the idea for storage, especially from our lawyer*. Certainly, as submitted, this takes up more room due to the wasted space in the tubes.
*Our lawyer’s positive reaction to this idea is probably due to the fact that he joined just weeks ago from a large banking institution, and is still drunk on the fact that he can now roll into work in hip hop t-shirts and jeans.
Inventor: Patricia DiBart
Submission: The Collar Iron
Community: 33
D: 06
M: 04
V: 05
Staff: 00
Total: 48
The competitive research showed a number of mini irons, but none that utilized a double surface. We weren’t sure if the double clamping surface offered enough wow factor or functionality to be disruptively innovative in its category.
Inventor: Tim Hayes
Submission: Portable and Cordless Handheld Steamer
Community: 22
D: 06
M: 04
V: 04
Staff: 00
Total: 36
A number of handheld steamers exist on the market and we weren’t convinced that the added dock and possible cordless feature would be enough to make it unique. Market felt that while there was a lot of competition, there was potential opportunity in the market for the right idea. There is a lot of IP surrounding this product category, so patent protection was deemed unlikely.
Inventor: Samuel Rivera
Submission: Lint Removing Glove
Community: 20
D: 03
M: 05
V: 08
Staff: 00
Total: 36
Design felt that while the inversion of glove for storage was interesting, the basic concept was gimmicky and lacking potential for improving on the convenience of a traditional lint brush. Our head of sales previously sold a disposable version of this that bombed at retail, but stated that he thought that there was a good opportunity here if priced and designed right. Surprisingly, there is potential for patent protection here, hence a strong viability score.
Wild Card Inventor: David Kowal
Submission: Portable Lint Remover
Community: 16
D: 03
M: 03
V: 08
Staff: 00
Total: 30
Design liked the unique portability of this item as first, but the competitive research revealed a few very similar items on the market. Market was very concerned about price point, in a market where you can buy disposable travel lint rollers for 49c. No potential for patent protection but also no challenge for manufacturing.
Wild Card Inventor: Gary Lindsley
Submission: Stain Soaking Sponge
Community: 17
D: 06
M: 05
V: 07
Staff: 00
Total: 35
This struck us as unique, and potentially a good solution if it worked. After discussion though, we weren’t convinced it was something that we would be interested in moving ahead with, and concerns over potential damage to clothing due to over-exposure to chemicals were raised. As presented, it was deemed that there was little chance for patent protection.


5 Comments
Clinton | 05/16/2011 5:56 PM
Sometimes it’s good to stop the development process really early
d | 05/16/2011 6:45 PM
What
ev
er.
billward11 | 05/17/2011 10:49 AM
Congratulations Steve!
Each and every evaluation seems to have been taken seriously, with savvy consideration from every angle. Please keep communicating the eval results!
And yes, it will be interesting to see how the concept phase maneuvers around flexible hose prior art.
Denny Fong | 05/17/2011 10:14 PM
Wow. Thanks guys for your continued support on my idea. I keep bringing my “A” game and try to submit something out of the box and innovative every time. But I still don’t get it really. I’ve been in the Top 5 a number of times and the results for me seem to be the same. Either came in second or so without any eval the week I’m in the Top 5 or the brief had been thrown out because Quirky felt that there wasn’t anything that somehow sparked their interest to move on.
I was very positive going into this last garment uptake brief from all the enthusiasm other members had given me. And this isn’t just your standard “great idea” comment. Very genuine comments and contributions. Also I was pretty sure my idea is a feasible one or at least one that Quirky can test easily without much cost as others had suggested. Put the sodium polyacrylate into a few socks and throw into the dryer. And hey if they felt there wasn’t significant reduction in the drying time on the cold cycle or even the hot cycle, then toss out the idea. But it seems that Quirky staff is more taking an uncertain guess that it won’t work to me.
concerned over the effectiveness of using it in ball form due to lack of contact surface area. We expanded on the idea during discussion: what if it was in the form of a sheet, and you used it for quick drying while camping, etc? Market felt that it had potential (despite a lack of positive feedback from retail partners) but viability was uncertain about sourcing Sodium Polyacrylate and associated regulatory requirements.
Uncertain about sourcing and regulatory requirements? What’s that all about? Can’t they just find out and say whether or not sourcing is a problem or not or regulatory requirements are a problem or not? I just seems like a few phone calls would confirm their hunches or not. It just seems like there isn’t enough effort by their part because of their statements in the blog.
I agree with Andrea that they don’t need to pick any winners. After all it’s their company. But I also agree with Daniel that a company that is essentially built on the philosophy and methodology base around community contributions, I would hope that if they were not choosing any ideas at all, I think the community deserves a better explanation.
As too Daniel’s comment of possibly me no longer contributing. That is definitely something I’ve been seriously considering. And this final brief loss and the lack of real explanation is really having me lose faith in the system. But more so, I feel I have disappointed all the members that have genuinely supported all my ideas and believed truly in my ideas. It seems to me from my past ideas, I get a sense that it really doesn’t matter what the community says or supports, ultimately it’s up to the Quirky Staff to make the final decision be it good or bad. That is Quirky’s choice but ultimately means the community really has no power or say. And for that reason I feel that for the last 6 months, I have wasted my time and effort. So no more cheers from me.
Steve Crockett | 05/18/2011 1:09 AM
Thanks gaz, Quirky and to everyone who voted. I appreciate your support and look forward to seeing the finished product! Very exciting, thank you so much!
P.S. thanks billward11!