Mon, May 30 2011
Eval 137
Inventor: Brandon Craven
Selected: Solar Powered Blinds
Community: 29
D:05
M:02
V:03
Staff:14
TOTAL:53
This stimulated a lot of debate. This submission had a very low DMV going into eval. Our discussion centered on expanding the scope of the submission to become more mobile; something that could be used for charging in places where there is no electricity available e.g. camping, in a parked car, etc. The possibilities caught the imagination of the staff and we are relishing the chance to explore a new area of manufacturing.
Inventor: Robin Huberty
WILD CARD Selected: Improved Toilet Bowl Brush
Community:09
D:07
M:08
V:06
Staff:09
TOTAL:39
Very healthy DMV scores for this one. While the solution presented needs more innovation to make it sing, the problem area highlighted is ripe for exploration. There has been little innovation in this category for the last decade or so. Add to that strong retail interest in our plunger Nautilus, and you have the beginnings of a potentially successful line extension.
The rest of the field
Inventor: Jared Joyce
Submission: Magnetic Light Switch Plate
Community: 34
D: 05
M: 05
V: 08
Staff: 00
TOTAL: 52
Design felt that this had a ‘quiet innovation’ to it, but were concerned about impeding the functionality of a light switch by hanging keys from it. Market felt that it didn’t really solve a problem but that it had mass appeal. Viability commented that this was easy to make, but patent protection was unlikely.
Inventor: Jared Joyce
Submission: Flip-out Shelf Outlet Plate
Community: 32
D: 03
M: 03
V: 06
Staff:00
TOTAL:44
Design felt that this was not unique and that similar items exist on the market. Viability showed close commercial products and patents exist.
Inventor: Bill Ward
Submission: Culinary Bowl Stand
Community: 31
D: 04
M: 05
V: 07
Staff:00
TOTAL:47
This submission stimulated some debate, again centered around who would use this, and how it would offer more function than simple nesting bowls. Viability felt there was only a narrow chance for any patent protection and were concerned over piece-count and how ‘component-y’ the submission felt.
Inventor: J. Andre
Submission: The Banana Clip
Community: 28
D: 04
M: 04
V: 08
Staff:00
TOTAL:44
There was interest in the simplicity of this from some members of the design team, but overall we felt this was too much of an impulse buy. No likelihood of patent protection.
Inventor: David Blaisdell
WILD CARD Submission: Safe All-in-one Utensil Cleaner
Community: 16
D: 05
M: 04
V: 06
Staff:00
TOTAL:31
Some interest in the problem area. While many people use a dishwasher, there are always some items, especially sharp knives, that are not intended to be washed in the dishwasher. Viability were concerned over doing a battery-powered version due to food ingress, but patent protection could be available for a unique approach.
Eval 138
Inventor: Jin Chai
Selected: Collapsible Drying Rack
Community: 32
D:03
M:05
V:07
Staff:16
TOTAL:66
Members of staff reacted favorably to the unique construction and careful placement of horizontal drying mesh and negative space for hanging. There is a narrow patent opportunity for a non-obvious approach and we will be working closely with our lawyers from the get-go on this one.
The rest of the field
Inventor: Steve Crockett
Submission: Drying Rack With Fan
Community: 34
D:05
M:04
V:06
Staff:00
TOTAL:49
Design were concerned about having to position this near an outlet, or worse still, having it battery operated (annoyance of switching out batteries). Market felt that it could be good for apartments/small homes, but that the market was limited.
Inventor: Charles Bailey
Submission: Ultimate Laundry Butler
Community: 34
D:05
M:06
V:07
Staff:00
TOTAL:52
This had a multi-functional appeal, and an interesting challenge in material manipulation to hit a good price point.
Inventor: Andrea Zabinski
Submission: Collapsing Magnetic Drying Rack
Community: 31
D:05
M:05
V:07
Staff:00
TOTAL:48
The comp shop showed items that were far too similar to this submission. Market commented that it did seem to make sense for larger homes with laundry rooms. Our lawyer surfaced a number of patents and commercial products that were very similar to this submission.
Inventor: Marc Zech
Submission: The Quad Rack
Community: 29
D:04
M:04
V:08
Staff:00
TOTAL:45
Marc’s submission makes use of the same folding method as Jin Chai’s submission. However, Marc’s approach for making use of the space created between the unfolded poles was not as inspired as Jin’s solution.
Inventor: Dave Fulton
WILD CARD Submission: Swimsuit/Gym Clothes Drying Rack
Community: 11
D:05
M:03
V:06
Staff:05
TOTAL:30
Positive response for Dave’s alternative approach to drying racks here. There was much discussion over who would be using this, and how big an opportunity it would be at retail. We certainly felt that for post-exercise and family outings it could be a useful addition to the car.
Inventor: Marko Pavlovic
WILD CARD Submission: Transformable Drying Rack
Community: 27
D:06
M:04
V:08
Staff:04
TOTAL:49
Marko’s submission resonated with the design department due to being simple, configurable and having something of a sculptural quality. Market felt that it would be good for first apartment, while viability were balancing their lack of concern sourcing with concerns over hitting a good price point.