Mon, May 23 2011

Congrats David!

By rob at 5:11 pm

Congratulations to David Quirk for his selected submission being moved into the Quirky Design Phases!

Eval 134

After much discussion, we felt there wasn’t anything in this eval round that we would want to proceed with into the design phases. Again, the feedback from our retail partners was not positive. Competitive research and sales channels concerns were again bringing up red flags. It’s a hard decision to make, but we feel it’s an important option to have to ensure that we are creating the best product line possible.

Inventor: Peter A. Watchel
Submission: Garden Desk

COMMUNITY:36
D:04
M:05
V:08
STAFF:00

TOTAL:53

Design were concerned over potentially introducing a large lump of plastic into a very organic hobby. Market felt that other solutions would work better at retail, but that it was a good-sized market. Viability felt this would be easier enough to produce, but shipping could be a problem for good margins.

Inventor: Marc Zech
Submission: The Cord Ball

COMMUNITY:05
D:05
M:06
V:09
STAFF:00

TOTAL:51

Design felt that this was a simple improvement but not truly innovative. Also, in order to have a UL-listed 3-prong plug it would be very difficult to manage a meaningful length of cord. Market felt we had the sales channels, and viability felt it would be easy to produce.

Inventor: Marnie Perri
Submission: Zip Loc Bag Holder

COMMUNITY:27
D:03
M:04
V:09
STAFF:00

TOTAL:43

Design felt that the problem did not warrant the solution. Market discounted for novelty. Viability said this would be easy to make although there were some existing patents for bag holders of this kind.

Inventor: Vincent Vedie
Submission: Smart Slicer

COMMUNITY:25
D:03
M:04
V:05
STAFF:00

TOTAL:37

Design felt that this was not a problem that warrented the solution. Market felt it was too novelty, more a gift item than mass market. Viability had some concerns over finding a great knife vendor, and the restrictions around shipping knives.

Inventor: Jared Joyce
Submission: Couch Cozy

COMMUNITY:24
D:01
M:03
V:09
STAFF:00

TOTAL:37

Design heavily discounted this as it exists as the ‘Couch Coozy’ (www.couchcoozy.com). Market were down on it for the same reason, and viability felt it would be easy enough to manufacture, despite patents existing.

Inventor: Davide Ferrari
Submission: Multi-shape paint roller

COMMUNITY:19
D:05
M:04
V:08
STAFF:00

TOTAL:36

Design felt that while this could improve workflow, there was a lot of concern as to how this would usefully flex and also how it would be cleaned. The solution needs a lot of work. Market felt that it was a tough market to compete in given that you can buy very cheap rollers at Home Depot. Viability noted that we have the suppliers to make the parts, and that patent protection was possible for a unique approach.


Eval 135

Inventor: David Quirk
Selected: Hooks On A Roll

Tough round, the end vote was between choosing nothing and David’s Hooks On A Roll. There was enough interest among QDS for David’s idea that we have moved it into the design phases.

COMMUNITY:03
D:05
M:06
V:07
STAFF:13

TOTAL:34

The rest of the field:

Inventor: Marko Pavlovic
Submission: Retractable Hooks

COMMUNITY:35
D:02
M:03
V:08
STAFF:00

TOTAL:48

Exists on market as submitted. Viability score was high due to ease of manufacture.

Inventor: Joseph Hummel
Submission: Pop Out Wall Hooks

COMMUNITY:30
D:03
M:03
V:07
STAFF:00

TOTAL:43

Design discounted this due to installation concerns and the fact that you would have to make a sizable hole in the wall. Market felt that it was not solving a problem they could sell. Viability felt that a non-obvious approach could be patentable.

Inventor: Andrea Zabinski
Submission: Swivel Hook

COMMUNITY:29
D:04
M:03
V:07
STAFF:00

TOTAL:43

Design felt this would be useful for organizing closets. Market did not understand what problem this was solving. Viability felt that there could be patent protection here for a unique engineering approach.

Inventor: David Sultana
Submission: Multi-use Carry Hook

COMMUNITY:28
D:04
M:03
V:08
STAFF:00

TOTAL:43

Design and market felt there were very similar items on the market. Viability score was high due to it not being too much of a sourcing challenge and narrow patent protection potential.

Inventor: Stacy Prince
Submission: Go-anywhere Hook

COMMUNITY:27
D:05
M:04
V:09
STAFF:00

TOTAL:45

Before the final choice of nothing or David Quirk’s submission, this was still in the running. Design felt it was useful and versatile. Market were unclear of the universal usage. Viability gave this a high score as they had no concerns over manufacturing. There were some existing patents.

Inventor: Robert Pontius
Submission: Halo Ring Hook

COMMUNITY:19
D:06
M:05
V:01
STAFF:00

TOTAL:31

Huge red flag in the patent area, so a viability score of 1.