Product 82, Brian Wethington’s Fast-Boiling Kettle submission, has presented us with a wonderful engineering and prototyping challenge over the past couple of months. We strive to make a certain amount of selections at eval that really push us out of our comfort zone, but with the knowledge that if we get it right it will be a killer product. With this approach, you expect that there will be times that we fail.
We have approached the kettle submission from a variety of directions. Early on in the process, we expected that Brian’s clever core concept of an internal chimney was a strong direction for open flame heating, but inherently inefficient for electric stoves. Shutting out a huge proportion of the market was unacceptable, so this concept was out of the window. We began to work our way through a variety of options, including introducing internal heat sinks, various insulating methods, internal copper heat-distribution piping. Prototyping these concepts led to some fairly creative use of copper heat pipes, computer heat sinks, and even copper deck screws!
Alas, after much testing on the stoves of the Quirky workshop, we got no closer to finding a disruptively innovative solution (i.e. a significantly faster boiling time).
After spending many hours prototyping, our gut feeling was that, even with continued testing and mock-ups, we would get no closer to our elusive goal. It was time to make a tough decision. We felt that it was a simple choice between two outcomes: Option 1: kill the project. Option 2: go ahead with a Quirky-branded kettle and open it up to the community to ideate on what the core concept could be, with Brian taking a reduced influence. We felt it incredibly important that the final decision came from Mr. Wethington himself, so early this morning (even earlier for Portland-based Brian), we called him up to explain the situation and get his decision.
Brian has decided that he would like the project to be opened up to the community and has graciously accepted a reduced influence percentage. So, very soon we will be launching the concept phase for this product, and will be hoping the community can help us to come up with a core concept that is ‘disruptively innovative’ and cause a genuine paradigm shift in the kettle market.



26 Comments
dan | 04/27/2011 10:24 PM
Very interesting…So, we’re to think up a game-changing kettle then, right? Because, my parents use an electric kettle. That thing works much faster than any typical kettle-gas or electric range. So, wouldn’t that be a better direction to take?
Brian Wethington | 04/27/2011 11:13 PM
Thanks Gaz, and Quirky, for involving me in the decision. You could have easily just made the decision yourself and moved on.
This was born from a desire to have this work better for me, and I’ve always used gas, hence the design. But, I totally agree that if this is to move forward it has to work either for both gas and electric, or at least for a wider audience.
I am happy this is going to move forward and I am perfectly happy to give a big chunk of the influence back to community to see what great ideas they can come up with. Hopefully I’ll come up with something else and get some of it back
.
I think the only way this becomes something more than a typical stove-top kettle, or another electric kettle, is to find a way to allow it to work in both conditions (hopefully) or expand what it can do as an electric device; something more than just heating water for tea.
Also, it is great opportunity to really dip the big, purple Quirky toe in an innovate green product; materials, low energy (compared to a standard stove or microwave product), etc.
Anyway, I look forward to some awesome solutions. Thanks again.
jess | 04/27/2011 11:21 PM
(Thumbs up)
Jason Hennessy | 04/27/2011 11:21 PM
Thanks for trying Quirky!
We will do our best to rock out something cool nonetheless! Kettles have worked pretty darned well for decades. And they manage to sell as is just fine too. Sometimes there’s just no reason to re-invent the wheel. Let’s just make one that looks hotter than the rest!
anonymous user | 04/27/2011 11:22 PM
Did you change the external shape – like an energy efficient coiled light bulb? Or shape it like a racing bike helmet, to increase surface area?
Daniel | 04/28/2011 2:33 AM
Jason, my thoughts exactly! Otherwise, if it’s speedy boiling, I think a plug in kettle is a better option. Speaking of conundrums, what else could a kettle be used for Brian?-You stumped me!
John Morrison | 04/28/2011 7:07 AM
Does it have to be an on stove? Would a hybride be acceptable?
billward11 | 04/28/2011 9:32 AM
Thanks for sharing your ingenious attempts to set the kettle bar higher! An impressive and fairly exhaustive attempt, followed by a fair solution involving the ideator, tell me that Quirky is serious about community involvement, as well as making the most innovative products in the market. Well done all around!
PeterG | 04/28/2011 9:36 AM
Gaz, could you please clarify if on any up coming concept rounds…
Are you looking for a small electric appliance that is a fast-boil kettle? …or simply a molded stove top kettle?
You imply above that from the get go, a gas kettle approach was out… due to huge market exclusion of electric range users… So, an electric kettle is the way to go?? Please clarify if and when you announce any concept round.
By the way, I don’t think Brian influence percentage should be reduced! Seems unfair since it didn’t happen for Verseur or Nautilus.
UNLESS… there been a new policy change enacted at Quirky on assigning Ideator influence based on the final design direction? An official change in policy on this point I would support, but even so, this should be for projects going forward, and NOT Brian’s kettle concept.( that came way before the plunger who also suffered a major shift in execution)
PeterG | 04/28/2011 9:43 AM
I was , and still am, a fan of this idea for a unique fast boil kettle, and so I too set out to do a little testing of my own very early on after Brian’s win was announce. I very quickly realized that the center stack approach would not work as expected on a gas range due to a burner’s flame being directed outwards and not inwards. Any attempt to better focus or capture heat energy should be done as the heat travels outward and along the outer wall — only if the flame was directed immediately upwards as the gas exits the burner would a center stack be better for capturing heat energy.
An image search for quick-boil gas kettle results in some old technology that I thought worth exploring and modernizing as far as gas ranges. A copper base with internal coils used to capture heat energy more efficiently. A better view found: HERE. I also did a bit of research on kettle manufacturing, and picked up on terms such as split-mold turning, air spinning, necking in, mandrels and blanks — some very neat methods going into making a kettle.
FYI: I tested boiling times with 4 covered containers — A glass pot, stainless steel pot, copper plated kettle, and a copper plated bunt-cake pan ( with rippled surface and center ‘chimney’ and foil cover)
All were roughly 5.25 inches at their base… heated on a 3.75 inch burner… tested twice with carefully measured 32oz and16oz. water amounts… I measured and noted both first-bubble point and full-boil point. (about 20sec difference)
Results for boiling 16oz of water: Glass pot was by far slower(4:45)… the stainless(4:30) was only slightly slower than copper kettle(4:20), and the bunt-cake pan w/larger surface area was quickest.(3:55)
Again, this was only for a gas range which is what I have.
justin | 04/28/2011 10:46 AM
This one is pretty confusing to me. What percentage of the target demographic uses a gas stove? Is it really that small (Survey said 46% but I just don’t know)? For instance, we don’t make the cloak to fit all tablet devices and many Quirky products are not “for” everyone.
Seems like if the concept was valid (which you are confirming (I think)), targeting that market with a true innovation that could win design awards could be lucrative. Why not finish it up as quickly as possible, with no more influence awarded until presale, and then run a new brief on kettles?
gaz | 04/28/2011 11:00 AM
@PeterG
The concept round will launch early next week, will a full and clear description of the scope of the project.
@Justin
Our prototyping showed that we weren’t getting improved boiling times on either gas or electric stoves. The original submission only had potential for open flame stoves.
denny | 04/28/2011 11:31 AM
I watched pot never boils so stop watching the pot. ;P I must commend you guys for admitting the challenges and not just simply pushing ahead with another kettle. Whether or not the community can figure this problem out at least you guys are reaching out for help. Cheers.
Popeye | 04/28/2011 11:59 AM
Hey Mates IMO: Agree with PeterG. No reduction in Brian’s influence. It is not his fault. The reduction could come from Quirky’s percentage of influence as Quirky asks us for more time to spent on the product that was chosen by them. After all, wouldn’t most of the presale items that aren’t moving a testament to what could be done to improve the ideas, thus the sales?
Clinton | 04/28/2011 1:18 PM
physics is like karma – you can’t fool mother nature.
NYU is just across the street. Next time, first give the physics department a call and maybe save a ton of prototyping time and money.
Or just believe me.
Clinton | 04/28/2011 1:31 PM
Influence sharing.
Genius is 1% inspiration and 99% perspiration.
An ideator gets the 35% for giving their inspiration (the 1%) to Quirky.
What did Quirky see as Brian’s inspiration? What attracted Quirky to Brian’s idea?
If Quirky saw the inspiration as “let’s make a faster boiling tea kettle”, and selected it because of that, then IMO Brian gets full % for having that inspiration.
If Quirky saw the inspiration as “here’s how to make a faster boiling tea kettle”, and selected it because of that, then IMO Brian’s % gets cut (IMO down to 5%) since somebody else will now have to come up with the inspiration (the “how”) that normally gets 35%.
(Or, Quirky drops the product since Brian’s inspiration turned out to be wrong.)
Restlessgypsy | 04/28/2011 1:36 PM
Amaging! I was thinking about a solution to make boiling liquid much for efficient while travelling to office and now I see this blog on the exactly the same topic.
Daniel | 04/28/2011 2:25 PM
Some great points. I’m torn. But, essentially agree with Peter G., Clinton, and Popeye. If it’s a policy change, then I agree it should start now and not be retroactive. I also appreciate BillWard11′s statement. But, the way this was handled should have been status quo from day one. So, it’s reassuring but nothing to praise. I’m still a little confused too. I think Justin made a good point about viability and this rationale being inconsistent. How come Brian tested that the chimney concept was proven, and QDS didn’t have that same finding? On that grounds, I think it’s okay to reduce his influence. But, not because of a change in direction which happens more than 50% of the time here.
nstlkr4 | 04/28/2011 2:40 PM
Will any engineering data be provided on based research and tests done, beyond the simple pictures above? Surely you’ve gathered some useful data that might assist the community. (Although boiling water is used in a vast amount of industrial processes so there is a lot of data out there)
PeterG | 04/29/2011 6:05 AM
(repost since message missing from yesterday)
@Gaz… thanks for the reply!
I did a little testing of my own a long while back after Brian’s win was announce. I came to the quick realization that the center stack approach would not work as expected on a gas range due to a burner’s flame being directed outwards and not inwards. Only if the flame was directed immediately upwards as the gas exits the burner may a center stack be better for capturing heat energy. Attempts to better capture heat energy needs to be done as the heat travels outward, and up along the outer wall. (with a bit of added surface area)
An image search for ‘quick-boil gas kettle’ brings up some old-style quick-boil kettle technology that I thought worth adapting and modernizing as far as gas ranges. A copper base with internal coils in addition to a thin rippled surface to increase surface area could be used to capture heat energy more effectively. A copper-coil base kettle image here: http://i.imgur.com/9Pzxa.jpg
PeterG | 04/29/2011 6:19 AM
(cont.)
For anyone interested…
My testing involved measuring boiling point times with 4 covered containers — A glass kettle, stainless steel pot, copper plated kettle, and a copper plated bunt-cake pan ( with rippled surface plus center ‘chimney’ and I added a foil cover)
All were roughly 5.25 inches at their base… heated on a 3.75 inch gas burner… tested twice w/ measured 32oz and 16oz water amounts… I noted both first-bubble point and then full-boil point. (about 15/20sec between)
Results for full boil point on 16oz of water: (on a gas range)
• Glass Kettle: 4:45
• Stainless pot: 4:30
• Copper kettle: 4:20
• Copper bunt-cake pan w/rippled surface: 3:55
I think the key (for a gas range at least) is to expose more surface area of a highly conductive metal to the flame while keeping that metal mass/thickness as thin as possible. The very thin but ridged surface of the bunt-cake pan provided this.
I believe the heat sinks used in the staff’s testing absorbed much of the heat energy. Any heat sinks should be on the outside to capture heat energy vs. using them inside to transfer heat energy.
(btw, I can provide pictures of my very unscientific heating instruments if anyone’s interested)
Time for tea.
PeterG | 04/29/2011 6:45 AM
Sorry… just realized it’s spelled B-U-N-D-T cake.
What a silly bunt.
Daniel | 05/01/2011 4:08 AM
Thanks Peter. I think that kind of proves the efficacy of the chimney effect. If they want an innovative kettle, I think it must have that chimney. Here is a small sampling of the variety of competing designer kettles: http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_zqFoq3qej2c/STMVXXmlNOI/AAAAAAAAgkY/wqrd_SvSLdQ/s1600-h/kettlesganged.jpg. I think it’s far too competitive for Quirky to make a mark solely on nice design. Copper is obviously the best material for heating. But, it’s expensive. I’m surprised that steel out-performed glass. I would have thought that glass would win.
PeterG | 05/01/2011 8:28 AM
@Daniel… I was surprised at how much slower glass was as well.
According to: http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/thermal-conductivity-d_429.html …Silver takes top honors for heat conductivity, then copper, and then gold. Aluminum rates high, and it’s my understanding that (all??) stainless steel pots are actually a sandwich of an aluminum core between two stainless steel layers. Stainless pots/pans start off as a flat layered disks (a.k.a. ‘blank’) that’s stamped into shape or spun on a lathe.
To be clear on my findings… I think the chimney effect is valid, but I wouldn’t place it in the center of the kettle… only through a concept illustration could I better describe.
PeterG | 05/01/2011 8:42 AM
I noticed one of the commentators above is quite outspoken in the forums on casting as much doubt as he could in Brian’s concept. I believe this person wrong in a key assumption of his — which is that it doesn’t matter what the shape or surface area is because the kettle receives x amount of energy. He’s correct on the point of the energy at the source being constant, but he assumes no improvement could be made to the capture and transfer of heat energy at it’s source.
Source = constant, but its capture is less than optimal.
(I make a distinction between a gas vs. electric range because source and transmission of energy is different.)
It’s my belief if you improve upon the capture and transfer of energy at the stove’s flame… your boiling times improve. By how much is the real debate… or perhaps the real debate should be… how marketable might a 25% reduction in boil times plus a very unique kettle design be? (That, I don’t really know)
(Again… heat-sinks inside the kettle do little to capture the energy at the source — inside they only serve to absorb energy themselves, and disperse the rest of the less than optimum energy captured by the kettle walls)
Dunyas | 05/06/2011 4:29 PM
The prototypes show seem to be a step in the right direction in principal, but seem to ignore science. It’s very similar to the whole high end video cable dispute. Yeah electronic signals will travel faster in a gold cable, but if you use tin solder, it doesn’t matter. You can glue a copper heat sink to the bottom of a steel kettle, but the heat can only transfer into the copper as fast as the steel will allow it.
I also figured on other things like a design on the heat sink and kettle body to create flow, insulation, and a non-open vessel. I find it funny that every prototype picture with some sort of insulation on it has a whistle or open spout. A lot of heat escapes in the form of steam. That is why a pot with a lid on it will boil quicker than an open pot.
The problem, like it has been said, is that it’s expensive to really just prove a point. Who is gonna buy a $150 kettle that improves boil time by a minute or two.