The best idea in the world will stay just that – an idea – if you can’t figure out how to make it. Understanding manufacturing methods helps you see how difficult it will be to make a design (which, of course, usually relates to the bottom line).
Although pasta is also an example of something that’s made through extrusion, the first thing I think of when I hear “extrusion” is always the Play Doh Fun Factory.
Extruding material is a way to make something with a uniform cross section. Material is pushed through a tool called a die that has the desired cross section cut out, and comes out as a continuous piece that has the same shape all along its length. A wide variety of materials can be extruded, but the process for extruding plastic is a little different than the process for extruding metal, so we’ll start with metal.
For metal extrusion, you start out with round bar stock, so the size (and therefore cost) of the die depends on how big the smallest circle you can draw around your desired profile is. That circle is called the circumscribing circle. Sometimes the metal is heated, which lowers the forces involved, but changes the properties of the metal. (Like when you leave chocolate in the car, and it melts and then resolidifies. It is still chocolate, but it tastes a little bit different and has those white specks.)
If you have ever used the Play Doh Fun Factory, you might remember that, for example, when you tried to make the asterisk profile, the plastic bowed out a lot. So when you thought you were going to get this skinny little profile, you got this big fat one instead. That demonstrates the reason behind a few of the things that go into design for extrusion.
-The dies aren’t thin, and they don’t have the same profile all of the way through. The profile on the side of the die where the material enters is bigger, and sometimes less detailed, than the profile on the exiting side. This reduces the stress on the die because it sort of eases the material into the final shape, and (as with people) reducing stress extends life.
- You want your profile “wall thickness” to be somewhat uniform. The thinner a gap you’re trying to push the material through, the less it’s going to want to go. If you have a big fat section section next to a skinny section, the same amount of force is going to push the material through faster in the fat section.
-There’s only so thin you can go. That limit mostly depends on the material you’re trying to extrude, though the size of the circumscribing circle also comes into play. The absolute smallest for steel would be around .15″, but aluminum would be more like .05″.
The body of the Split Stick is made out of an aluminum extrusion. But it’s a hollow extrusion. So you might think that would be a problem. How would you support the center of the die? If you think about extruding a metal pipe, you would actually start with a “C” shaped die, and then move the center of the C over into the middle of the circle as you get closer to where the material exits.
Another thing you might notice about the Split Stick is that there’s a slot on the top face. One of the limiting things about extrusions is that you often have to machine parts afterward to add features, like we have to do to make that hole.
That should be a little glimpse into how extrusion works – again, if you want to know more, the Internet is your oyster!




7 Comments
Stephen | 04/05/2010 1:59 PM
Thanks for this, I didn’t realize all that was involved in extruding metal and the like and how it relates to the price point. Still not sure I understand completely… other than, keep the circumscribing circle small to keep the price down.
So you guys are tooled up to work with metal and plastic in production right? What about other materials like leather, fabric, and rubber? Is that already in place, or would that be more difficult to make happen?
janet | 04/05/2010 2:12 PM
@ Stephen – People write entire books about design for extrusion, so that’s about all I can hope that you take away from a post like this. I’m just trying to give people the gist of how these processes work and their limitations (if you haven’t read it yet, you should go back and read Part 1).
Quirky is not a manufacturer – we don’t make the tooling ourselves. So we contract with different manufacturers on a product by product basis. Several of our products already include rubber pieces. When a product requires other materials like leather and fabric, we’ll find manufacturers for those products. Since we’re not the manufacturer, we have the flexibility to work in the material we think is best.
Brian | 04/05/2010 8:35 PM
Another great read, thanks Janet!
Marc Zech | 04/06/2010 8:28 AM
janet,
thanks for this! really love to read this. keep em coming.
Extrusion | 08/16/2010 7:41 AM
SPM CONTROLS is the leading manufacturers of Presses, Extrusion Press, Hydraulic Presses and Extrusion Presses in India.for more details visit http://www.spmcontrols.com
Sidhanath | 02/18/2011 2:28 AM
SIDHANATH HYDRAULICS, WE USE CUTTING EDGE TECHNOLOGY TO MANUFACTURE ALL THE AFORESAID PRODUCTS SUCH AS ALLUMINIUM EXTRUSION, BRASS, COPPER EXTRUSION, LPG PRESS IN INDIA.
ALUMINIUM EXTRUSION PRESS MANUFACTURERS
Hydraulic Press Manufacturers | 05/19/2011 8:09 AM
Perfect Machine Fabric leading manufacturer of a slew of Hydraulic Cylinders, Hydraulic Power Pack Manufacturers, Hydraulic Equipments Manufacturers both standards as well as per custom built specification in India.