Tue, Jul 19 2011
Hey Quirks, sorry to keep you waiting for this recap! We’ve worked hard to incorporate more info as requested (and had to get the nod from lawyer-man). Let us know what you think. We’ll continue to do this as long as it benefits the community.
Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.
EVAL 153
Inventor: W Bond
Selected: Nonslip Pot/Pan Leverage Grip
Community: 11
D: 5
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 14
Total: 42
Design would investigate ways of making this product truly universal and was most excited by the possibility of helping the growing older population continue to work in the kitchen. Market felt it may be a novel solution for arthritis suffers. There was some debate about creating a line of pots with a new handle design vs. creating a low price point accessory that could get lost on retail shelves. Viability said we already have suppliers to make this product well. Legal felt there might be narrow patent potential for an innovative design, but would need more detail during development to judge against existing patents. The engineering challenge would be to determine effective placement/holding. We found the challenge worthwhile based on the opportunity to create a unique product that would help people.
The rest of the field
Inventor: Tim Hayes
Submission: Fondue, Grill and Skillet combo
Community: 35
D: 3
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 48
Design felt this could turn any room into a mini-kitchen, but had concerns about the usability of all the interchangeable parts. They questioned whether this would be a smart solution to just using different appliances. Market felt that it may not appeal to the broad market, but could be well positioned as the modern alternative to a hot-pot for college students. The product would likely have good shelf appeal and work with existing distribution. Sourcing would need to find vendors specializing in small appliances. Manufacturing and engineering noted that the electronic assembly and multiple parts would pose additional challenges. Legal found a patent (US 7530302) that may require design around.
Inventor: Jared Joyce
Submission: Digital Measuring Cup
Community: 34
D: 3
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 48
Design felt that a small digital scale would be more useful and universal, but was interested in investigating the workflow of measuring volumes and weights while cooking to find room for innovation. Market pointed out that while measuring cups are key items within the kitchen gadgets and tools space, digital scales are considerably less important. It might decrease the market potential to combine these items. Sourcing would need to find a vendor to make small scales, and Manufacturing noted that assembly of scales and need for batteries would also add intricacy. Engineering foresaw no major challenges. We were concerned about meeting FDA regulations for materials that would come into contact with food. Legal felt there was very narrow opportunity for patent protection.
Inventor: Michael Taylor
Submission: Bike Pedal-Driven Power Charger
Community: 31
D: 4
M: 3
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 44
Design would explore harnessing the human body to power other things, especially the ideal charging interface and how to maintain safety. Market felt there was a limited consumer base for the idea, and that it was not aligned with our current distribution channels (fit for bike speciality shops). There was an opportunity to position it as an emergency solution similar to the wind up radios. If we took that route, we’d need to add functionality to compete with existing concepts. Sourcing would have to find a vendor experienced at making charging electronics, and willing to tackle the challenge of creating a bike charger. They pointed out that we would also need to update this product every time major companies changed their charging wires. Manufacturing noted that the electronic assembly required added more complexity. Engineering would have a major challenge in making the mechanics work as described. Existing patents (US 6765362, 6940258, 5857762, 7042123) may require design around.
Inventor: Marc Rumaner
Submission: Gift Wrap Prep Station
Community: 30
D: 3
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 46
Design pointed out similar items on the market that we would need to differentiate ourselves from, and would focus on the efficient use of space to keep this product from being too large. They would investigate the workflow of gift wrapping, to see how this product could help. Market really liked the solution to improve the quality of wrapping and store paper neatly. There is a predictable window of opportunity to sell the product every year, but it is a very short period of time. This would fit nicely with some existing distribution partners, but would be best positioned for mass merchandisers. Sourcing and manufacturing would not be a problem, but shipping air on such a large product is a concern. Existing patents (US 7424843, 7134583) for combo gift wrapping paper cutter and storage designs may require design around, but narrow patent protection may be available for an innovative design.
Inventor: Andrea Zabinski
Submission: Flexible Anything Holder
Community: 30
D: 2
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 43
Design said this item could potentially be useful, but questioned whether the solution described would be functional. Market felt this would have limited shelf appeal and would likely retail at a very low price point. While Sourcing would have to find a vendor that makes grippy legs, Manufacturing noted that pre-made grippy legs could lead to easier assembly. Although there are similar products on the market to model after, Engineering would have a challenge ensuring stability in the range of places this product would be used. Legal would need more detail regarding the flexible support arms before providing full analysis.
Inventor: Rene Diaz
Submission: EZ Pants Hanger
Community: 29
D: 6
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 47
Design did not feel there was much innovation presented, but felt it could be a great product combination with SOLO, our new shirt hanger. Market said that the lack of a differentiating factor may lead to limited shelf appeal, and may even detract from the uniqueness of our hangers. Manufacturing said this would be easy to make with minimal assembly. Legal informed us that the crowded patent space may necessitate design around, but there may be narrow potential to patent an innovative design.
EVAL 154
Inventor: Michelle Drake
Selected: Refillable Baking Soda Holder with Sticky Back
Community: 11
D: 6
M: 8
V: 8
Staff: 14
Total: 47
Design liked that it would make use of a widely available, cheap deodorizer. They would explore ways of increasing the surface contact area of the baking soda and how best to position the product in the home (i.e. hang, suction cup etc). Creating a slim form factor and refilling mechanism were appealing challenges. Market informed us that the air freshening market was huge and that a reusable solution that could be filled inexpensively could have mass appeal. There is also growing interest in products which focus on removal of odor over masking smells with chemicals. On the downside, shelf appeal could be challenging unless we sold kits with small, medium, and large holders for different rooms and or environments. Sourcing said we have factories to make the case as described, and manufacturing and engineering teams did not foresee any difficulties. Because the use of baking soda to remove odor and adhesive back air fresheners are widely known concepts, meaningful patent protection would be unlikely. We jumped at the chance to make an environmentally-friendly product while entering the air freshening market.
The rest of the field
Inventor: Marjune Bagadiong
Submission: Air Freshening Tape and Dispenser
Community: 35
D: 3
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 49
Design found this to be an interesting vehicle for dispensing odor control, but questioned how effective the tape method would be. There was some discussion about creating visually appealing designs on the tape. Market said this would have very limited shelf appeal, and the unexpected use for tape could work against it by limiting consumer demand. Sourcing would have to find an inventive vendor to make the scented tape, and ensure the tape would leave no sticky residue. Tooling would only be needed for the dispenser, so it’d be relatively inexpensive. Engineering might face challenges in making the product work effectively and, depending on thickness of the tape, dispense smoothly. There appear to be no current patents which cover the tape/film implementation. If this moved into development, design approaches would require patent clearance for the adhesive material and scent agent.
Inventor: Miha Mlakar
Submission: Baking Soda Balls
Community: 35
D: 4
M: 7
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 53
Design liked that this idea made use of a widely available cheap deodorizer, and would explore ways of increasing the surface contact area of the baking soda. However, the proposed shape of the product would reduce possibilities for exploration. Market said that shelf appeal could be challenging, but it did fit with current distribution partners. A reusable solution that could be filled inexpensively could have mass appeal. There is also growing interest in products which focus on removal of odor over masking smells with chemicals. Sourcing and manufacturing felt this idea would be fairly simple to make. A relevant patent (US 6213409) may require design around, but narrow patent protection may be available for an innovative approach.
Inventor: Maria Morrill
Submission: Scented Ceiling Fan Rings
Community: 32
D: 3
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 45
Design felt that ceiling fan blades were not easily accessible for all people, and worried about going off-brand with this idea. They would look at ways to fully integrate designs with home decor. Market felt this was an interesting idea but too hard for the average consumer to use given the requirement to climb up a ladder or chair to install. Sourcing and manufacturing did not foresee a problem, pending requirements from the engineering and design teams. Engineering challenges would include finding the right material and form factor to fit various fan blades safely. The patent landscape is crowded around this concept and would likely require significant design around. Meaningful patent protection is highly unlikely.
Inventor: Jim Siegrist
Submission: Toilet Paper Loader & Air Freshener
Community: 32
D: 2
M: 5
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 47
Design felt this product would come across as a novelty, no matter how well designed. Because it would require people to replace their existing toilet paper holder, which typically requires installation, this seems an overly complicated solution. Market found this to be an interesting solution targeting odor at a genesis point, but questioned the efficacy of a constant air freshening solution vs. a burst solution, and was consequently uncertain of market demand. There may be an opportunity to position this as a grocery product, but it may be difficult to lead with this product. Sourcing may be able to find vendors who have worked on similar items, and no real engineering or manufacturing challenges were anticipated. Patent protection appears possible for this approach.
Inventor: Minka Mlakar
Submission: Deodorizing Mats
Community: 31
D: 4
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 45
Design wondered if this would cause more problems than it solved when the deodorizing ability ran out and the mat had to be replaced, especially under larger items like rugs. In their research, they found no evidence of the effectiveness of this solution. Market saw opportunities for this as a pet product or for use in rooms where shoes are stored often, but the concerns about effectiveness limited market appeal. Sourcing would need a better understanding of the material to find suitable vendor. Manufacturing and Engineering were unsure how to make this product. Legal felt meaningful patent protection was unlikely.
Inventor: Alex Bordewyk
Submission: Cedar Insert Shoe Tree
Community: 8
D: 7
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 9
Total: 37
Design would explore space efficiency, ease-of-use, and direction of airflow to increase efficacy of odor removal. They would also experiment with conservative use of cedar to keep price point reasonable without sacrificing the benefits of that material. Market found this to be an interesting combination of shoe storage and odor removal. This would be a good fit with existing distribution channels, but the possible assembly required could be problematic. Sourcing would need to obtain cedar and a vendor suited for big items. The Engineering challenge would be to ensure the product is balanced. The large size of this product would likely make shipping expensive. Meaningful patent protection is unlikely.