Eval 145
After much deliberation, we felt that there was no core concept with the mixture of strong solution and uniqueness to market to pursue. Feedback from our retailers was not positive for this batch of submissions, and in some cases IP concerns out-weighed any interest design and market had in the submission.
Inventor: David Quirk
Submission: Storage Hanger
Community: 38
D: 4
M: 5
V: 8
Staff: 0
Total: 55
Design felt this was potentially useful for travel, and concealment of some valuables. Market were not sure that this was a great solution, especially given that clothing reduces convenience of frequent access. Patent protection is unlikely as the core concept is in the public domain.
Inventor: Jared Joyce
Submission: Screw-holding bit
Community: 22
D: 3
M: 3
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 35
Design felt that the core concept made it more difficult to view the bit and align the screw; also that the lifespan of the cowl would most likely be shorter than the bit itself. Similar product that goes between the bit and the drill exist on the market (indeed come with many drill bit sets). Most bits are magnetic and already address the issue of holding the screw at that first instance.
Inventor: Brandon Craven
Submission: Combo blow dryer etc.
Community: 20
D: 3
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 33
Combination hair iron/curlers already exist, and blow dryer mechanism is a different mechanism entirely which would present an interesting engineering challenge. If one breaks, you have to buy all three again. Could be potentially useful for travel. Market were concerned over performance of all three items compared to strong market competition, but felt that the all-in-one would appeal to consumers. Viability highlighted the engineering challenge but also pointed out that there are no patents or commercial products for a three-way combo.
Inventor: Scott Mallard
Submission: Soda Gun Dispenser
Community: 14
D: 3
M: 3
V: 5
Staff: 3
Total: 28
Design felt this was completely off-brand and very novelty. A quirky product, not the product of Quirky process.
Inventor: Dave Sultana
Submission: Gadget Hand Grips
Community: 14
D: 4
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
Total: 29
While design commented that this would be potential useful while typing and walking, both design and market agreed that there were several other items on the market solving similar problems. Viability felt it would be easy to manufacture but that we would have to produce a variety of versions to make it universal. The IP verdict was that the concept and implementation are public domain, but narrow protection could be available for an innovative approach
Inventor: Grayson Koonce
Submission: Wireless Charging Mouse/Mouse Pad
Community: 11
D: 4
M: 5
V: 1
Staff: 0
Total: 21
While design and market noted the uniqueness of this submission, the IP research came back with patents and commercial products in existence for inductive charging mouse pads, immediately counting the submission out.
Inventor: Josh Moffatt
Submission: In-Room Humidifier
Community: 2
D: 6
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 10
Total: 28
Design felt that there was opportunity here to re-skin humidifiers/dehumidifiers as pieces of furniture. Engineering highlighted the complexities of the systems involved and that we would have to invest a lot of time and money into creating a truly disruptively innovative product. Viability conceded that we would have to partner with and OEM that already manufactures humidifiers and dehumidifiers to keep pricing and engineering R&D reasonable.
Eval 146: App-Enabled Hardware
Inventor: J. Andre
Selected: The Quirky Plug on/off switch
Community: 28
D: 5
M: 4
V: 6
Staff: 15
Total: 58
Design responded to the ability to program times and monitor power usage. Our tech department had strong arguments for a large component of the app being about setting and controlling mood or convenience lighting. The staff in general responded strongly to the universality of the item and that it could be used to control any electronic item: lighting, air conditioners, consumer electronics etc. Out of all the submissions, this one fit the idea of the app itself being the driving force for the product.
The rest of the field
Inventor: Simon Mlakar
Submission: Medical Alert Bracelet
Community: 35
D: 5
M: 4
V: 5
Staff: 0
Total: 49
Design were concerned that false positives could be a huge issue when remotely monitoring people’s health. Market were not sure exactly what it would monitor. Viability did not see this as a huge challenge and, in the initial shallow dive, found no apparent patents or commercial products for app-enabled implementation.
Inventor: Joshua Wright
Submission: Baby Monitor
Community: 29
D: 4
M: 5
V: 5
Staff: 8
Total: 51
Design felt that there were similar items on the market, but the general feedback at eval from those who had kids was that the app-enabled aspect made it unique and desirable. Market acknowledged that it is a big opportunity; the percentage of tech-savvy mothers in the smart phone market continues to grow. Viability voiced concern over regulatory issues for baby-related electronics of this kind. Our legal counsel noted various patents and commercial products for video audio and sensor triggered baby monitors exist. However, while some that use apps, no app-enabled products are patented.
Inventor: Marc Zech
Submission: Wireless iPhone Camera
Community: 28
D: 4
M: 6
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 44
Design felt that, while aimed at a broader target end-user than Josh Wright’s submission, there were many similar items on the market. Market felt that this was more of a gift item and potentially not a want for the retail partner sponsoring this brief. Viability noted that patents and commercial products exist for various approaches to remote video and audio transmission systems… while the app-enabled solutions that exist are not patented.
Inventor: Georg Broxtermann
Submission: Find My Cat Collar
Community: 28
D: 3
M: 3
V: 1
Staff: 0
Total: 35
Everyone felt that this was too narrowly focused and that the core concept exists in the market place. There are very similar patented and commercial products, and therefore is a very challenging patent landscape.
Inventor: Nomad
Submission: App-enabled scents
Community: 7
D: 6
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 24
Design were leading the interpretation on this one; there was as much interest in air purity monitoring as controlling scents. This would make the product truly unique in the market place. Viability noted that there would be some interesting engineering/manufacturing/sourcing challenges inherent to this category. Patents and commercial products exist for various approaches to remote controlled air fresheners, but there don’t appear to be any app enabled solutions on the market.
Inventor: Eric Shore
Submission: App-enabled weight management scale
Community: 15
D: 5
M: 6
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 32
Similar products exist on the market. To make it more unique to the market, we would look at the potential for partnering with other 3rd party platforms. From a tech perspective, this has been done before and is relatively straightforward; partnering with a scale manufacturer would be key to the success of the hardware component.
Inventor: Ian Patrick Co
Submission: Smartphone lock device
Community: 14
D: 6
M: 6
V: 1
Staff: 0
Total: 27
Design were interested in the submission’s usefulness in situations where your phone is more accessible than keys. The idea of ‘social locks’ was surfaced by the tech team, i.e. the idea of sharing codes with your friends and families for common lockable items. Viability score was low due to patents and commercial products exist for the same idea.
Inventor: Chris Kouba
Submission: App-enabled fridge notes
Community: 8
D: 3
M: 3
V: 6
Staff: 0
Total: 20
When picked as a wild card, the discussion centered around this potentially becoming the hub of family life. However, cellular phones already create a decentralized communications hub for most families. Market felt that it would be a higher price with little added value, as did viability. From a patent perspective, this was a straightforward application of a wireless sync between devices, deeming meaningful protection unlikely.


