Mon, Jun 13 2011
Inventor: Daniel Foster
Selected: Portable Baby-changing Pad
Community: 13
D: 6
M: 6
V: 7
Staff: 18
TOTAL: 50
Design thought this was a great problem-solving product, and saw many opportunities for wow factor in the way the changing pad could fold up and deploy. Market saw good potential for sales and opening new retail channels. Soft goods are still somewhat of a sourcing challenge, but Viability was happy to take it on, and found good possibility for patent protection.
The rest of the field.
Inventor: Inventzilla
Submission: Step on Light Mat
Community: 35
D: 5
M: 5
V: 6
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 51
Design felt there were other products out there that solve this problem well, but saw some possible areas for improvement. Market saw potential, especially in the children’s market, and viability was not overly concerned with manufacturing, but felt patent protection was unlikely. Similar products reduced the overall wow factor.
Inventor: Rob Hendrickson
Submission: Beverage and Coaster Coozie
Community: 28
D: 4
M: 3
V: 1
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 36
This invention is already patented and the patent owner is the one commercializing it. Viability called this a “definite legal no no.”
Inventor: Angelo Cacchione
Submission: Sharpening Knife Rack
Community:23
D: 5
M: 3
V: 6
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 37
Design was interested in the child safety feature and saw some wow factor potential. Everyone was a little concerned with the “pop up” feature. Market responded to this problem, but noted that it would be challenging to sell a knife rack without knives.
Inventor: Gyro
Submission: Shoehorn with Hanging Hook
Community: 21
D: 4
M: 3
V: 3
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 36
Not convinced there is a huge market for a kids’ shoehorn. The added hook does not offer much improvement on existing shoehorns. From a viability perspective it would be pretty easy to make and manufacture.
Inventor: Gerardo Rojas
Submission: Kitchen Ladle and Thermometer
Community: 20
D: 4
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 35
Fits well with our other kitchen products, but falls into somewhat of a niche market. Some concerns were raised regarding the heat from the stove skewing the temperature.
Inventor: Allison Jones
Submission: Miniature, Mobile Greenhouse
Community: 5
D: 5
M: 5
V: 7
Staff: 5
TOTAL: 27
Design thought this could be a great way to turn a “DIY” product mass market. However, was not sure if there was a true need for it. Market was happy with the sales potential, and viability saw some red flags in the patent area but felt we could design around them if necessary.
Inventor: Ormati
Submission: Wireless Sleep Switch for Children
Community: 11
D: 6
M: 6
V: 5
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 28
Design was inspired by the problem/solution of the design story that surrounds bedtime. Market thought this was a good product for Quirky overall. Viability foresaw a few sourcing and regulatory requirement hurdles and thought patent protection was fairly unlikely.
EVAL 142
Inventor: Marc Rumaner
Selected: Luggage Lifting Handle
Community: 15
D: 7
M: 5
V: 8
Staff: 16
TOTAL: 51
Design and Market felt this was truly a problem solving solution. Design saw this as a great entrance into travel design. Market liked the universal fit for all types of luggage and felt distribution was okay. Viability saw no red flags, and felt the biggest challenge would be determining the proper dimensions and proportions to create a solution with true universal appeal.
The rest of the field.
Inventor: Marc Zech
Submission: Convertible Backpack/Messenger Bag
Community: 34
D: 4
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 49
Design liked the simplicity of the bag, however both Design and Market felt it had low wow factor, as many similar bags exist. From a Viability standpoint there are already many patents and commercial products for approaches to this idea, so meaningful patent protection is unlikely.
Inventor: Tim Hayes
Submission: Wet/Dry Travel Grooming Case
Community: 32
D: 5
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 7
TOTAL: 55
Design felt this solved a problem, seemed to offer a useful improvement on traditional toiletries sets, and could tie into the story of shower station. From a Market perspective, toiletry bags make up a pretty crowded space and the wow factor is fairly low. Viability thought patent protection was unlikely, and sourcing would have some challenges in soft goods, but nothing we couldn’t overcome.
Inventor: Evonne Wilks
Submission: Folding Drink Holder and Mirror
Community: 27
D: 2
M: 3
V: 8
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 40
Overall, not sure this is a problem people will go out of their way, or pay, to solve. Design saw little reason for a cup-holder and mirror to come as one unit. Market felt price point would have to be too low. Viability was confident they could make this product and saw no major conflicting patent issues.
Inventor: William Fine
Submission: Garment Roll-Up Tubes
Community: 27
D: 3
M: 3
V: 8
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 41
Design thought standardizing the rolling process seemed potentially interesting, but did not think it was the most space effective solution. Market felt this added an additional step and was not convinced of the need for this type of device. Viability saw no problems with the manufacturing or execution, but was concerned about shipping air space.
Inventor: Miha Mlakar
Submission: Multiple Adaptor Travel Outlet
Community: 27
D: 4
M: 3
V: 6
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 40
Similar products exist. Market felt it was OK as an overseas travel adapter and Viability felt this posed an engineering challenge, but nothing we could not manage.
Inventor: Emmett
Submission: Unrollable Suitcase
Community: 16
D: 5
M: 4
V: 7
Staff: 0
TOTAL: 32
Design felt this was an interesting concept, but was concerned it may be too bulky. Market felt this was a tough area to enter, as luggage is very brand dominated. Viability found some patents and commercial products with similar functionality, but felt narrow protection could be available for an innovative approach.