Thu, Oct 13 2011

Hey guys, our Rachael Ray episode is coming up soon and we hope you are as excited as we are!  As you know, the top three ideas  for this round have been announced on the blog. This post is to provide the DMV scores and comments for the top 5 voted and staff wildcard ideas, so that everyone can continue to learn and grow from this info.  However, since we do not have a winner just yet, this info contains just the DMV analysis, not final scores. The inventors of the top three ideas will be going to the Rachael Ray show and the winner for this round will be announced on the show.  We’ll be announcing the air date as soon as we know, so you can tune in and find out which new cleaning product Quirky will be developing.

Eval recaps sum up the research and discussion that go into selecting winning submissions at Quirky. The info in recaps focuses on general landscape, opportunities and concerns, with a strong bias for Quirky’s business interests. We will not tell people what to do with their ideas if we do not choose it, but this info should give general guidance to submitters and other inventors who want to understand our decision-making process.


EVAL 191

Inventor: Joshua Wright
Submission: Hand Held Cleaning Multi-Tool

Community: 34

D: 3
M: 3
V:7

Design felt that this product was overkill with trying to preform too many tasks.  They wondered if exploring a multi tool solution focused a smaller number of jobs would be a better approach.  Market noted that it would be difficult to merchandise and show all the benefits of this product.  Viability said that the final design would have to be very unique in order to obtain any patent protection and that lots of similar patents exist.

Inventor: Michael Taylor
Submission: Spraying Window Washer

Community: 30 
D: 4
M: 5
V:7

Design questioned if this was a common enough problem to warent this product, but they were open to the idea of exploring different ways of washing windows to discover the best method.  Market like the uniqueness of the idea and felt that it could be more useful than other common ways of washing windows.  Viability noted that this concept mostly lies with in the public domain.

Inventor: Sandra Lehr
Submission: Baseboard Cleaner

Community: 29
D: 4
M: 4
V:7

Design thought that this these were difficult areas to clean and felt it could be interesting to address the issue, but they were not convinced this was the best solution to the problem.  Market, on the other hand, liked this solution to the problem and felt it would sell well, however they were not sure if it would be more effective than existing products. Viability noted that there was not a lot of intellectual property risk, but there is also little for protection on this idea.

Inventor: Jared Joyce
Submission: Soap Dispensing Sponge

Community: 27
D: 2
M: 2
V:7

Design said this not an innovative idea.  Market noted that this was an over saturated market.  Viability said the submission was mostly in the public domain and that there was very little potential to get protection.

Inventor: Patricia Bendick
Submission: Panini Machine Cleaner

Community: 26
D: 3
M: 4
V: 8

Design thought the problem presented was fairly relatable, but said the solution had little wow factor.  Market felt that this product would not work well with our line of cleaning products, but said with the correct distributors this product had the potential to sell well.  Viability again said  a thorough review of the patent landscape could not be completed at this early stage.

Inventor: Kim Sprattley
Submission: Scraping Cleaning Tool

Community: 24
D: 3
M: 4
V: 8

Design felt that this was not a very interesting solution to a common problem and that it would need to be re-thought.  Market did not foresee consumer interest in this product. Viability said that as submitted this product’s concept primarily lies within the public domain.

Inventor: Justin Giannone
Submission: Splatter Guard

Community: 21

D: 6
M: 5
V: 8

Design liked the simplicity and multi-functionality of this idea and they felt that this would be a good solution to this problem. Market said that we have the appropriate distribution channels for this type of product and they added that it would be an easily explain to potential customers.  Viability noted that we would need to pair up with a vendor familiar with heat resistant materials and from a patent perspective there did not seem to be any infringement issues.

Inventor: Jenny Drinkard
Submission: Crevice Cleaner

Community: 17
D: 5
M: 5
V: 8

Design said that as submitted the idea did not present much wow factor, but they added since this product could be used for a variety of applications this idea had a good amount of potential.  Market again liked the idea of a set of attachments and how it could fit alongside with our current line of cleaning items.  Viability noted that the idea is too general at this point to complete a thorough patent analysis, however, indicated that this idea would probably lie in the public domain.

Inventor: Josheph Treter
Submission: Adjustable Cleaning Handle

Community: 11
D: 6
M: 5
V:7

Design noted that this item could be a versatile alternative to current cleaning products and that it would fit well with our line of cleaning tools.  Market liked the set of attachments idea and expressed that we could explore several potential uses to show consumers how versatile this product would be.  Viability indicated that at this early point of ideation they could not do a thorough patent analysis.

Inventor: Kasey Corwin
Submission: Towel Sanitizer

Community: 9
D: 6
M: 5
V: 7

Design felt that this idea had a fair amount of potential and liked the fact that it addressed a real issue with which many people relate. Market liked the uniqueness of this idea and said that this product would fall in line with our other kitchen products.  Viability said depending on the final design there could be possible patent protection available.

Inventor: Emanuel Maia
Submission: Mini Rotary Cleaning Tool

Community: 4
D: 5
M: 3
V:6

Design like the fact we could merge this idea with our existing line of cleaning products.  Also they thought that this solution addressed a solution for the need for having several cleaning tools for the kitchen.  Market indicated that similar items exist on the market.  Viability said that this idea probably lies within the public domain.

Inventor: Hank Brock
Submission: Palm Carpet Cleaner

Community: 4

D: 5
M: 3
V: 4

Design felt that this product would have to prove to be more useful than existing products on the market and if it succeeded in doing so it would be a easy solution for carpet cleaning.  Market said the carpet cleaning tool market was fairly saturated, thus the final design would have to be very unique in order to compete well with similar existing products.  Viability noted there do exist several patents so there could possibly be some design around necessary.

Inventor: Bradley Sippl
Submission: Reusable Disposable Towels

Community: 2

D: 4
M: 5
V: 8

Design thought that this idea had potential to become an interesting product and this could be used to show consumers how much waste they produce.  Market said that it would be difficult to market at retail because similar items do exist.  Viability said that is too early to complete a meaningful patent search.