The creative process is often informed by the things we have seen and experienced over the course of our lifetime. Sometimes, similar designs and concepts can be produced, independently, by two people. When an inventor submits an idea to Quirky, we assume that they are submitting an innovation derived from an original thought, and do not automatically assume that just because there is a similar product or concept out there, that the idea is plagiarized.
After a review of certain submissions, we found a pattern of ideations that seemed to be heavily inspired by concept art from a single website. Recap appears to be one of these heavily inspired ideations. While we knew that a concept similar to Recap existed when it was picked, we moved forward as we always have in the past, assuming the submitter had not directly appropriated the concept, and that the similarities were coincidental. When we found indications that this might not be the case, we decided it was best to remove Recap from our website and move it out of our development process at this time.
This is not a decision Quirky has taken lightly. As our company expands, it is important that we do so in a healthy and reputable way. We have made this decision, despite the effort already invested in Recap by the community and staff, to ensure that we continue to collectively design products that offer the highest degree of innovation possible.


6 Comments
Mike K | 04/27/2012 4:12 PM
The update and integrity is appreciated
Fred Ende | 04/27/2012 9:13 PM
Thanks for the quick response.
kerry collins | 04/28/2012 3:28 PM
Interesting post…first time I’ve seen this as it was recently brought to my attention. I am working at my job right now and writing from my phone. Trust me, I will be commenting on this as soon as possible.
Kerry Collins | 04/28/2012 9:12 PM
Hi guys, sorry I have been working and didn’t see how far this thread had gone.
Anyhow, I had some conversations with Quirky. They said that the recap idea was similar to the yanko pencil sharpener even though my design called for a pencil holder and they decided against it.
Also, they said my hammer idea was the same as the yanko idea. I just reposted the hammer idea in a NO VOTE ideation for you to determine similarities.
http://www.quirky.com/ideations/216214?sc=true
With 110 ideas on Quirky, I have always tried to be original but, of course, have had ideas come up that were similar. We have 200,000 ideas on this site. And NO, I am not a copy cat not will I ever try to be one.
I love Quirky, Ben, Gaz and everyone who has made all of this possible. I just feel that RECAP was pulled without a jury of my peers “the community” to decide its fate.
Kerry Collins | 04/28/2012 9:22 PM
Also, I have new 3D models on what I envisioned my original design to be…I will release the new pics on Monday.
Brandon Craven | 04/30/2012 8:06 PM
Family Guy is on.