That’s Wild
ByWe just announced the winner for Product 106: a hard boiled egg caddy submitted by “fatboy”.
While it initially fell under the radar, we became excited about this idea because it will allow us to explore a common ritual from a design point of view — which is just the kind of project we love tackling with the community.
The idea didn’t get all too much love during community evaluation, though, which is why we’re writing this post. We struggled over selecting this as the winner because numerically, there was no way our scores could outweigh the community scores for the top 5.
During the last Town Meeting, when we were discussing this very scenario , one person raised a question: “If these ideas are truly wild cards, why should the numbers count?”
We’ve thought long and hard about that question. At the end of the day, we want to choose the idea that presents the best opportunities for making an amazing product. To let numbers get in the way of that goal is silly. Until our Task Forces overhaul the Product Evaluation system to make it kick serious ass, we think setting aside the numbers requirement for wild cards is the way to go.


36 Comments
Ken Somerby | 03/11/2011 8:24 PM
There are plenty of solutions for this on the market already, so I don’t understand this being picked as the winner….Who cooks that many eggs at once anyway?????????
Congrats to FatBoy but………………..
Nichole | 03/11/2011 8:30 PM
I’m sorry Quirky, but really? Like Ken said above there are a lot of these on the market and it didn’t get any love because it didn’t even give a solution or design!
Way to pick another “Let’s build a better ________”.
Cody | 03/11/2011 8:39 PM
I’ll have to agree with Ken and Nichole, there were a lot of other great ideas that round that could have been chosen, and I’m not talking about just mine, people didn’t vote for it, but you except us to help it through presale? Yeah, yeah. I know, I’m working at making presale better but come on.. I can’t make miracles happen. I would have at least chosen a second product, that the community liked that could of kicked ass.
ben h | 03/11/2011 9:00 PM
Just so you guys know, not everyone at Quirky HQ voted for this. I will not name my co-conspirators, but there was a small group of dissenters, and despite our superior logic, we were ignored…
+1 to everything said above.
Michael Taylor | 03/11/2011 9:06 PM
Can’t wait to see how we compete with a 12 in 1 tool like the Chef Basket. Oh, you can hard boil lots if eggs with it too and transport them safely. Good luck with that! I hope in your comp shop this came up with the $14.99 price and all the extras that come with this As Seen On TV product.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C6LKooCBcXQ
Ken Daniels | 03/11/2011 10:37 PM
They might as well pick whatever the hell they likes since the QDS won’t be Influenced by anything said or submitted by the Community anyway.
CKLeming | 03/11/2011 11:44 PM
While I realize that this product idea would only come in handy for making deviled eggs or boiled eggs that would be included in a packed lunch, I applaud Quirky for choosing an idea with a challenge that intrigues the design staff. I had hoped as much for my Q-Stick lip balm, but I was happy to get my final score, as it was my best to date – thank you!
That said, as a small child, my grandmother had me help her make deviled eggs, pies and potato salad for grocery stores, and I learned early-on that one must bring boiled eggs back to the sink in the pan, rinse in cold water, then crack & peel them under water to remove the shells. It’s the only efficient way of removing the shells. With this product idea, you’d have to either have a separate bowl for de-shelling or bring the pan of boiling water over to the sink to dump, refill with cold water, then remove the shells. I know….I had a boring childhood – yet, a rewarding one, in Grandma’s kitchen.
David King | 03/12/2011 12:43 AM
great another week of no videos. Way to keep us in the dark.
amp | 03/12/2011 3:07 AM
…banging my head on wall… why, why, why
- Did anyone google “How to make hard boiled eggs”. Or remind the group that people own spoons, collanders, strainers and steamer baskets? This is as bad as Frosty Faces. I’m truly embarrassed to be a quirk when this happens.
.
PS (Someone’s gotta say it, “The Emperor’s Got No Clothes”)
.
Ben h and posse – thank God you are there. Please, Rent “Moonstruck”, closely study the scene when Cher smacks Nick upside the head and says, “Snap out of it.”
Peter G. | 03/12/2011 6:39 AM
Really scratching my head on this pick, Q.
How often does one need to boil more than 1 dozen eggs???
A rather limited market to dedicate $180k in development costs no?
Aren“t there specialized electric egg boilers for serious egg heads?
(And such a thinly presented idea on the part of the ideator)
NotMe | 03/12/2011 6:55 AM
Maybe this was a dream. Go back to bed everyone. When we wake up, all will be right with the Quirky world. ; ) Like everyone else, I do have serious concerns. There is really one proper way to boil eggs and get them to the sink and CKLemming described it perfectly. Ask any chef out there and they will tell you the same. I admire you for taking on a design challenge – but….
jess | 03/12/2011 7:49 AM
@David King: You can usually expect to see eval recap videos up within 48 hours.
Michelle Drake | 03/12/2011 8:06 AM
I’m really trying to see the positives with this choice:
1. Quirky has proven that they do look at ALL of the ideas
2. Quirky tries to recognize some kind of potential in anything submitted
3. My decision to stop commenting on submissions because it was taking too much time was good, because Quirky (even if they do read it, as they say) doesn’t put a lot of faith in community comments.
Stalias | 03/12/2011 9:32 AM
Theories:
* Drama for TV
* Someone on staff really, really like eggs
* BB&B has totally lost it
* There’s an international design prize being offered for egg devices
* The Egg Council has invested serious capital in Quirky
* Fatboy is a pseudonym for someone we love, and this is an April Fool’s joke
Linda | 03/12/2011 9:33 AM
I’m new to Quirky so probably not as qualified to comment but this is my take. I like the idea of a wild card (or override) as you guys are in the thick of it and should be able to follow something that excites you on occasion. It also gives hope to those whose comments may not be that positive. That said, I also think given there is a product already invented and not a huge need for this product given comments above, do you think your wild card system might allow for a redo or announcement of a runner-up if a comparable product is discovered?
Ken Daniels | 03/12/2011 9:37 AM
On the plus side they may finally win that much coveted design award, provided the Razzies sponsor a competition that is.
Emmet | 03/12/2011 9:38 AM
It is a good argument but slowly you Quirky is becoming less about the community and more about the professionals that are paid to make good solid decisions and I believe they are, but sorry that is not what I thought I was signing on to be party too. A lot of us spend a great deal of your time going through and vetting these ideas. So I could just run through every idea rating them as 1 star down the row and still receive my influence sort of just for showing up. Is the community now just a gimmick for the company a thing that just makes us different. If the design team wants to tackle rituals have them take up Voodoo. I’ll leave it at that before I get any snarkier.
Denny Fong | 03/12/2011 9:41 AM
That’s ok. The Quirky Community will help develop this into a great product and get next to nothing in terms of influence on essentially figuring out how the whole thing will work and be marketed. Can’t wait to contribute to this one… Not! I’ll just sit back and watch how the original Ideator and QT will make of this.
Gary Lindsley | 03/12/2011 9:43 AM
Way to go Quirky team! I am not sure I agree with the choice, but I am happy you have seen through many of the community comments and votes on ideas that are so faked and gave consideration to ideas that appear overlooked and systematically ignored. Many low rated ideas have much more potential. Some votes and comments are very meaningful, but often quantity means little.
justin | 03/12/2011 10:08 AM
If the community had nothing to do with this pick, why do voters and raters get 15% influence?
Popeye | 03/12/2011 11:22 AM
I disagree with most of the comments here simply because it doesn’t jibe with my primitive logical mind. Quirky foots the bill. To me that is the bottom line. Next.
ben h | 03/12/2011 11:53 AM
@David King – You have to realize that video doesn’t happen instantly. Editing, exporting, compressing and uploading a 30 minute HD video involves a lot of time waiting for the computer to process. And on top of that, our proprietary card reader for the proprietary media that our camera uses, broke yesterday. And since we are based in NYC and every camera store is run by Orthodox Jews, there isn’t a single place with that item in stock that will be open before tomorrow. Again video isn’t instant, so don’t expect it to magically appear the minute eval finishes. We do these videos as a favor to the community, they consume the entirety of our Friday nights, and often a good chunk of our weekend; on top of that there are way more interesting projects here I rather work on, but we want to keep the community happy, so instead we dedicate the time to half hour informative videos.
We could always go back to using Utream, but then everyone would just complain about the technical aspects of a video that is a rushed production of two guys talking to a camera for half an hour, instead of the important part, the content.
Hope | 03/12/2011 12:09 PM
babs | 03/12/2011 12:54 PM
I did have an idea in the top 5 and am pretty disappointed about the results but not only that I’m just amazed that the Gorilla Grip got Quirky passed up as well. Rarely does Quirky get such a rounded out idea that has a working prototype and common problem solved so beautifully.
I’m also confused on how this idea gets a design score of a 4 and a market score of a 4 and a viability of a 7. These are the same scores the Gorilla Grip got but the problem is that there is no design for the egg carrier. The market I would have to say would be alot bigger than a egg carrier since many more people have trash in a house than they do boil eggs, and the Gorilla Grip certainly is very viable since he already has a prototype.
Ill be curious what they say in the evaluation movie, but it gives you the impression that these numbers they do for scoring are just guestimates and they will manipulate them to get the idea they want. Just my 2 cents.
Jas Hennessy | 03/12/2011 4:10 PM
I with babs. I like the initiative of picking a wildcard and not being tied down by numbers. Still very confused that you reached for this product since your own numbers didn’t show much love for it either.
D: 4 M: 4 V: 7
If even Quirky thinks the market is so low, why is it investing in it?
Ken Daniels | 03/12/2011 5:12 PM
Why is the eval video in HD? Just post the slideshow they are looking at with the audio track and 95% will be as happy or happier. That the appearance of the thing is being disproportionately weighed versus the content is very emblematic of the issues many of us have with everything coming out of QHQ in general.
Clinton | 03/12/2011 8:27 PM
I’m neither here nor there about the egg caddy…
…but the staff ignoring the community scores is the best idea since sliced bread…
…it instantly, though messily, corrects for much of the inaccuracies in the voting results.
Sam Knoll | 03/12/2011 9:04 PM
ken LOL, u are definitely part of the 5% of people who would still be grouchy no matter what they do! ;^)
i like the videos though, gaz is funny! I’d feel we’d be miss them if they were just slides
Gaz | 03/12/2011 9:58 PM
Did you guys ever check out this wonderful and clever company:
http://www.fusionbrands.com
They do simple, smart and iconic kitchen items. They have no less than 5 products for helping cook eggs, and they do extremely well with them in international markets and in America.
@AMP Don’t bang your head! We need it intact.
Michelle Brewster | 03/12/2011 10:20 PM
So now we know where you want to be… ?
Stalias | 03/12/2011 11:51 PM
Wow, they sure do love themselves some silicone! Although I do like the egg bowl (and would order one if it weren’t plastic).
Emmet | 03/13/2011 10:56 AM
@Ben h look at you spittin mad venom, chill brother the fam’s having a bit of a spat it’s gonna be alright. It seems like your a really intense brother that’s great, but trust me were your peeps. There seems to be a lot of pressure since we’ve moved up to 2 products a week small amount on the community and a huge amount on the quirky staff. Just stay positive your a great motivator.
@Gaz really cool website and interesting items, but I don’t know anyone who owns any of their products. I know tons of people that own pampered chef items and they have little or no innovation.
Ok group hug and lets get back to work there’s a lot to be done.
amp | 03/13/2011 3:22 PM
I’m still frustrated and 2 days later, can’t think of anyone who would make dozens of eggs at a time, outside a well equipped restaurant. Since you bring eggs to a boil for one minute, then move the pot to a cold burner to cool, there is no need to lift the pot or eggs hot. You can cool and lift them out by hand or scoop with a strainer or slotted spoon. This is STUPID beyond belief. Who the HECK do you think is going to BUY this thing?
.
The website Gaz showed is for common consumers, but they DON’T make dozens of eggs at a time. apples- and- oranges kids!!!!!
hezonit | 03/13/2011 7:02 PM
I’m going to submit a THREE dozen egg basket this week!
Jon Corral | 03/13/2011 9:08 PM
Harsh criticism! Don’t blame them. I think there is some merit to the “wild card” idea, but perhaps it’s done IN ADDITION TO a popular selection. If Quirky really finds something they want to work on and it truly is “wild,” they could take it on in addition to something that’s won over the public sphere.
Basically, what they’ve done in the past. I don’t think anyone would mine their “unpopular” idea being selected – but there’s obviously some rough feedback from people who feel ignored.
rowan none | 03/14/2011 3:18 AM
Does anyone at Quirky boil their own eggs? I think not if this is something they would consider as a winner. I boil eggs all the time and would not use this at all.