In our second installment of creativity-killers, we’re going to explore the dreaded “topic fixation.”
Topic fixation is human nature to dangerously focus on whichever idea is first projected, especially if it’s met with popularity. The results? The exclusion of all others. And that’s not the worst part (dun, dun, dun)… truth is, no matter how well-trained we are in managing our creative outputs, the latest research reveals that we are all susceptible to conforming our ideas and possibilities.
Researchers from Texas A&M University performed three experiments in which group creativity was proven to be an overestimated method of generating ideas. In observing the phenomenon, lead researcher Nicholas Kohn explained that, “Fixation to other people’s ideas can occur unconsciously and lead to you suggesting ideas that mimic your brainstorming partners. Thus, you potentially become less creative.”
Say it ain’t so. Well, it doesn’t have to be, Quirks, because we’ve found an antidotal solution:
1. Perform individual brainstorming exercises, like these written creativity drills.
2. Devote time to simply reading and considering the value of the ideas of others.
3. Be open minded and aware of the tendency to conform.
4. Take influence breaks to improve the quality and quantity of your ideas.
By combining the four tips above you too can add to a more vibrant, fresh discussion on Quirky with a wider range of product solutions. Kind of magical, huh?



4 Comments
Stalias | 06/11/2010 1:42 PM
Excellent points, all.
Perhaps the Quirky team would consider rejiggering the platform to actively discourage topic fixation:
1) separate submission and voting phases
provide a “staging” area for pre-voting, where we can flag the ideas we like and give them the consideration they deserve, without the distraction of so many less-appealing ones.
2) enforce “time off” for frequent contributors/voters
3) experiment with “no comments” for a while
4) display ideas randomly, with new-to-the-viewer ideas showing up in a different color (à la namethis)
5) using a thumbs-up/down initial voting phase to limit the amount of time users must devote to “simply” reading and considering so many ideas (it ain’t simple when there are tons of ‘em!)
6) try blind submissions (would make things less collegial, but would also focus energy on the task at hand). We could still have the forum for great comments/jokes/revealing of whose name is whose.
7) provide a “worksheet” area on the page for people to futz (is that how you spell it?) around with ideas. It’s always helpful to see one’s idea in the same font as others’.
Thanks, as always, for your openness and for considering our product AND process ideas.
Stalias | 06/11/2010 1:56 PM
9) stop limiting the number of submissions. With a management tool (see above), large numbers of submissions wouldn’t be nearly as problematic. And some of us aren’t strongest straight out of the gate. Limited submissions = self-censoring = reduced risk-taking/creativity. Or at least allow us to pull ones we don’t like for ones we like better (this would work if you have separate submission and voting phases).
10) figure out a way to avoid the “I got there first” problem. This would take some creativity on the QT’s part, but it could be solved with separating submission/voting phases — you’d lump similar names together and ideators would share influence. Or you might institute a time delay between phases so people could digest the last phase before they LEAP into the next….
Σας ευχαριστούμε. (That’s thank you in Greek. Hope it comes through.)
JG | 06/11/2010 3:45 PM
Also consider the Six Thinking Hats technique for lateral thinking.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Six_Thinking_Hats
Good stuff.
Danielle | 06/14/2010 2:33 PM
Stallas: Thank you for the suggestions! We will definitely keep them in mind as Quirky evolves.
JG: I’m sure we all appreciate those tips… thanks!