I think it’s great that our Community makes an effort to surface IP issues, and brings them to our attention. The purpose of this blog post is to encourage continued efforts from the Community in this regard, and to politely propose a narrower channeling of these contributions.
Questions of trademark infringement are rarely black and white, and often must be made by balancing many factors. For example, several Community members have voiced concerns over Quirky’s use of the Linkets name for our cardboard connectors product, in view of the Edushape Linkets product. Both products are directed primarily to children, and share the same name, so I can understand the questions from those Community members who may have avoided the name Linkets during the product naming phase. However, several important factors mitigate against risk of trademark infringement. First, Edushape’s use of Linkets is heavily descriptive of their product. It is fundamental to trademark law that one cannot trademark a word/phrase that is primarily descriptive of the related goods or services. Second, Edushape has taken no clear steps to claim any trademark rights in the name for use with its product, either through attempts to register the name with the USPTO or by claims to common law trademark rights on its website or product packaging. These two factors reasonably lead to the conclusion that Edushape would not object to Quirky’s use of the name Linkets in connection with the cardboard connectors product.
However, the foregoing analysis has shifted somewhat now in view of the volume of discussion in the Quirky blog and forum positing that Quirky’s use of Linkets constitutes trademark infringement. This public discussion increases the likelihood that Edushape may take notice and object to something that they may otherwise have left alone. While we have not changed our assessment of the legal merits concerning our use of “Linkets” in view of the Community discussion, we have shifted our assessment of the practical merits – namely that it is now more likely that we might have to expend resources on defending our use of the name than it was prior to the blog and forum discussions. As such, we think it is now prudent to move to a different name and tagline proposed by the Community that may have not been our first choice, but doesn’t present the expenditure risk that has developed over the past several days.
The new name and tagline for the cardboard connectors is JUGO and JUST ADD CARDBOARD.
In the future, so that we might attempt to avoid repeating an outcome of this nature, please contact us with IP issues concerning our products, via direct email at [email protected], so that we can investigate the issue privately. In the end, this approach will yield a more beneficial outcome for the Community as a whole.
Continued thanks to the Community for supporting us.


28 Comments
d | 02/03/2012 6:41 PM
No offense but it 2012 with twitter, fb, etc and a discussion can go from a just a few people to tens of thousands in a short amount of time. I highly doubt people will refrain from discussing these types of matters publicly in the future just cuz you asked. That is just way too idealistic and unrealistic on your part imo. Just sayin…..stay away from names and taglines already in use period. Sounds simple to me.
clinton | 02/03/2012 7:45 PM
What? Trademark is automatic, no action needed. Further, “We’re OK if they don’t notice” is very poor legal advice indeed.
Cody | 02/03/2012 7:52 PM
Quirky is a SOCIAL product development company, what did you expect community members to do? I didn’t know there were any issues with the name until this blog post but come on, community members have expressed concerns with various IP/infringement concerns previously what made QS think it wouldn’t happen with this? If you want to prevent it from happening again, simply pick a name where it couldn’t happen.
Cody | 02/03/2012 7:55 PM
Quirky is a SOCIAL product development company, what did you expect community members to do? I didn’t know there were any issues with the name until this blog post but come on, community members have expressed concerns with various infringement concerns previously what made QS think it wouldn’t happen with this? If you want to prevent it from happening again, simply pick a name where it couldn’t happen.
clinton | 02/03/2012 8:28 PM
Charlie, I’m extremely concerned by your post.
First, “made up” words such as Linkets are potentially the strongest trademarks possible – you seem to be sidestep that.
Second, trademark simply exists if used to identify a good or service in trade – you seem to suggest that Edushapes needed to take some other action.
Third, you first conclude that Edushapes would not mind our use of the name, then state that the name will be changed because they may have overheard the community and may protest – which is it? If they know they won’t mind, or if they know they may sue?
Fourth, you seem to suggest that keeping product names hidden is your preferred method for avoiding future trademark infringement issues – which seems to run counter of Quirky’s attempts to sell products nationwide.
Maria | 02/03/2012 9:13 PM
Exactly my thoughts Clinton. Why was the tag changed?
Brandon Craven | 02/03/2012 9:37 PM
I like Jugo!
zabber | 02/04/2012 9:01 AM
Clinton that is exactly what I thought…why are you promoting “hidden” names on a social product development company…maybe doing a bit more research up front might actually be worthy, that’s why they pay a lawyer and or should have a legal team that does research (in depth) prior to naming or taglines…please don’t BLAME a community that is here to help you as the “result” of changing names and taglines…your lucky we are here discussing IMO!
Patricia Bender | 02/04/2012 10:23 AM
Charlie,
In the future If I have major concerns about a product I will email Quirky first and give them the opportunity to make a decision on the matter. It’s the right thing to do. The community and Quirky team need to work together.
Also, when this concern was first posted by a member on the blog it should have been addressed immediately. The Quirky staff need to be more proactive and decisive whenever a concern is raised by the community.
I believe if one of the above things were done we could have avoided this whole issue. Hopefully we will learn from this experience and be better Quirky’s because of it.
Clinton | 02/04/2012 10:38 AM
That’s my concern, Andrea. Instead of the insight and credibility of a “Sorry we missed it, glad you caught it” post, it seems intended to justify the miss.
As Seth Godin say’s, “…when the very first interaction we have is one where you are sort of not telling the relevant truth, where do we go from here?”
MichelleB | 02/04/2012 1:55 PM
@Clinton I think you are slightly off point in your criticism here.
What I hear Charlie saying is that PRIOR to the community whipping up discussion about the name, Edushapes had not meet it’s obligation under trademark law to secure the name Linkets.
Merely using the name is not necessarily enough to secure a name, you need to be able to prove you had actively taken steps to secure it’s use and had been using it as a trademark, things like including the TM and a whole lot of other legal stuff. Yes you don’t have to register it, but it is a good idea.
One of the things the trademark office do when they do their examinations is look for evidence that the company (or anyone) had published the word or phrase, or if their is a link in the public’s mind.
By the Quirky community talking about the association between the company and the name or the product and also talking about it’s prior use, in a strange way we have shot ourselves in the foot. We helped create the augment against our use of the name.
I’m not a lawyer but I have several trademarks so I am just going by my experience.
I have always found that if you are paying for a lawyer you might as well take their advice.
Clinton | 02/04/2012 5:50 PM
ha – well, MichelleB, that, we could discuss further.
Here’s my opinion.
A trademark exists when it is being used to offer a product for sale, and Linkets is that. Nothing else required. (All the other legal stuff, like registering, may be smart, but it simply makes it easier to enforce – for example, the owner of a registered trademark has a lot less to prove to a court, etc. – but it still exists in full even if not registered.)
A trademark is strong if it is a made up word, and Linkets is that. (In fact, I’ve often wondered why Q seems to avoid made up words – Linkets was unusual).
And a trademark is mostly easily infringed if it’s strong and its use is likely to confuse a buyer…by being the same kind of product in the same market with the same tradename.
And that’s where I need to back up.
I had earlier mistaken their Linkets for Octa Clips (and thought, “same kind of product, same strong name, same market – and they won’t mind?”)
Now that I know it’s not, I’m not sure our Linkets infringes on their Linkets. It’s probably less likely a buyer would be confused.
But I’m still not understanding why Charlie thinks our talking about Linkets and trademark infringement is what would cause the original owner to notice. If I was selling Linkets, then another company did the normal Quirky national blog blitz to sell Linkets – I think I would notice….without any discussion by anybody about trademarks.
anonymous | 02/05/2012 12:44 AM
Why is the lack of staff doing basic, bare bones quality control and failing, our responsibility? You should have looked up the top 10 candidates for existing and other language meanings. We don’t need another NOVA. (If you don’t know that the car didn’t sell well because the name translates to No Go, look it up. Says its an urban legend and is taught in MARKETING classes the world over.) Between legal and marketing, this should have been caught. Once again, poor quality control and chain of responsibility is a problem. When this is your job, WEEKLY, why is the system to check and double check such a failure? Not OUR fault, you choose from a short list, expecting us to choose from hundreds. Not worth our time, so don’t take US for granted.
M Cavada | 02/05/2012 7:48 AM
Wow! This has to be the best example of “shooting the messenger” I’ve ever seen. Pardon my blood. :-/
Clinton | 02/05/2012 8:13 AM
@M Cavada…except charlie is no messenger. He’s Q’s inside lawyer.
M Cavada | 02/05/2012 8:24 AM
@Clinton… No… “I” was the initial messenger/whistle blower.
Patricia Bender | 02/05/2012 12:04 PM
M. Cavada,
Here are some virtual band aides for that wound. Hopefully your inner Quirky is still intact and fully functional.
You are the one that I spoke of in my previous post. I believe what happened was that you made the first comment about the name and it wasn’t addressed. So, as a result, it went into further discussion in the forums as a concern from the community members. Your intentions were great and I admire you for taking the bullet for the community by saying that you were the messenger.
The Quirky community members are a passionate and caring bunch so it was natural to discuss the concern further. But what I/we didn’t realize is that the concern was a legal issue in nature. Which means that we should have emailed Quirky directly with our concern. Maybe if we did that it could have been resolved and we could move on to the next product. Basically, all legal and/or product safety concerns should be immediately directed to Quirky and not discussed in the forums or blogs. And, I would question someone’s intentions for the Quirky community and products if they didn’t do so. I would have never commented on the issue if I saw the bigger picture at that time.
Remember, we are participating members. We are NOT employed by Quirky and have not been given the expressed permission to discuss legal matters on the behalf of Quirky. Besides, when the dust settles, it’s better that Quirky is holding the bag than a community member. And lets not allow another community member to get wounded.
Now with that being said let’s reconnect with our inner Quirky and get back to participating in making that next great Quirky product.
Elizabeth Wingfield | 02/05/2012 12:05 PM
Linkits
Linkitz
Link It
.
Or any of the other 90+ pages of names that were considered.
Clinton | 02/05/2012 7:50 PM
JUGO wasn’t an entry?
What? Is the name Quirky’s/charlie’s attempt to “punish” us?
Patricia – as you correctly point out, we are not Quirky employees. Therefore, a public forum is the correct place to discuss our concerns. (The age of instant, wide spread interaction means “keep it quiet” is no longer a viable legal strategy.)
Michael Mattox | 02/06/2012 12:42 PM
How funny is that? Don’t discuss, collaborate, exchange ideas, points of view. Isn’t that what a forum is for?
Isn’t that what has put Quirky somewhere on some map some place? What is best for the community probably is not what is foretold in private. Read your Quirky history book.
charlie | 02/06/2012 4:33 PM
Hi there. Hopefully I can effectively address a few concerns raised in these comments.
First, we didn’t change the name in order to “punish” the QC for raising concerns. I tried to make it clear in my post that we appreciate and value the QC’s input, and want it to continue. My request was that this input be made via private email rather than public posting because such input often is more helpful on the whole when made in private than when made in public. If the QC would rather make the input public despite this request, that’s your decision to make.
Second, we’re not picking product names without pre-clearing for trademark infringement concerns. We were not concerned with the Edushape use of Linkets because such use is primarily descriptive and therefore not trademarkable, and Edushape’s failure to indicate any attempt to claim trademark protection in the word reasonably conferred that they saw their use of the name as being descriptive as well.
However, the uproar in the blog and forum over Quirky’s use of Linkets in view of Edushape’s use of Linkets created an increased level of risk that Eduspape would take notice of our use of the name, and object to it. As a result we moved to another name. Our analysis of the law did not change, however our cost benefit analysis did.
Third, trademark protection is not “automatic” or simply based on use alone. As discussed above, a primarily descriptive use is not trademarkable. McDondald’s can trademark Big Mac, but they can’t trademark Hamburger or Sandwich.
Fourth, we do not select product names based solely on the trademark strength of a product name in isolation. Branding concerns (eg. aesthetics) also play a big part in the decision process. There are times when we may choose a more descriptive and less distinctive name that most effectively introduces the product, while knowing that we’ll be pairing this name together with the Quirky name, which in itself offers us trademark protection. By analogy – Apple TV.
I don’t want the point of this blog post to get lost in the mix of these comments. First and foremost – I love your input – please keep it up. And a related request (not a demand) – to the extent you can provide such input via private email instead of public post, we’d appreciate that favor.
Imagine | 02/06/2012 5:13 PM
Well, I read this Blog too late after creating a Forum Post, so I did’t know that Q want to keep it Private, my bad, We are human that make mistakes every day. I believe that Q will be one the greatest company in the future and anything that affect Q will affect US as a community, I was doing the right thing or maybe NO.
Sincerely
Tony
d | 02/06/2012 5:41 PM
Charlie
I can’t believe you’re still asking for private email in 2012. God forbid this idea isnt actually killed and becomes a hit, don’t you think the other companies using the name, then, might have a problem with with? Geesh can anyone at Q accept they made a mistake and move on?
charlie | 02/06/2012 6:26 PM
Hi d. You’re missing the point.
The risk is not presented by the general notion of increased attention to our use of the name. The risk is presented by numerous comments from our own community accusing us of trademark infringement. Even though these statements were based on flawed legal analysis, they could still be used by Edushape to make our fight against a trademark assertion by Edushape more difficult. As a result, the risk of a confrontation with Edushape increases, as does the expense of dealing with it.
As i stated above, we asked for the favor a private email instead of public post – we didn’t demand it. If you don’t want to help us out with that favor, no one is forcing your hand to do other than you desire.
M Cavada | 02/06/2012 8:50 PM
Lesson learned, but, you also need to be aware that with the continuous influx of new members, there is little doubt that this will occur time and time again.
What I still don’t fully understand is the reason for gambling ANY level of risk that would impose legal costs of trademark issues.
anonymous | 02/09/2012 4:58 PM
Charlie- Our job is not to short list or double check the short list. This would not happen if you have a quality control, name checking process in place.
.
Telling us, after the fact, that this is a legal issue, is moot. The influx of new users and this not being mentioned as a FAQ, does no good for anyone. You need to institute checks and balances IN YOUR PROCESS, before choosing a winner & announcing it. Then the problem is non existant.
UNO | 02/09/2012 11:02 PM
Oh crap! Something that attaches CARdboard together but sounds like a CAR name JUGO!!!