This was a far more informative eval and I appreciate them reading and adapting info about things discussed in the forum since last week. I was really disappointed they didn’t apologize last week.
When I see ur recaps I’m wondering why you don’t use that flatscreen in the back to show each idea you’re talkin’ bout?
Would be much easier to understand which one you mean.
1) Is it possible to modulate the sound on these things? Ben comes across as so much louder than Gaz (maybe he’s nearer the mic, maybe he’s just pumped) that I had to choose between ear pain or not hearing Gazwisdom. Tough choice there.
2) This has been discussed before, but I’m wondering if there’s a way to improve community feedback by weeding out some of the nonviable ideas. Why have your community wasting man/woman-hours discussing something that just isn’t viable (like a lock that screws into a dorm-room drawer)? Since we’re all competing here (for wins, for influence), useful critical comments from community members are always suspect (reference previous discussions of gaming). If QS sees nonviable/market infringing ideas bubbling to the top, wouldn’t we all benefit from a QS comment to that effect, so our energies can be put to use more productively?
Thanks! Fun and promising choices this week, especially.
Use the flat screen behind you when you are talking about product(s), this way we have a better understanding of what you are talking about. You guys are getting better on communicating on the evaluations. You guys should talk more about manufacturing, this way people can design according to manufacturing capabilities. The more understanding that the community have on your process, helps them come up with ideas that is close to your capabilities and the things you want to design. As your capabilities increase, let the community know. I think communication is vital to the success of this new online collaborating concept.
@Stalias, In most cases, the viability is heavily influenced by feedback from the patent lawyers. They give submissions a score for ‘Potential To Infringe’ and ‘Potential To Protect’. In an ideal world, all submissions would be run past the lawyers and we would weed out the ones that are nonviable/market infringing. Unfortunately, that would mean dropping serious $$$ each eval and would take many man hours to execute.
@stalias
I’ll talk to the film department about the sound, we just use a webcam with built in mic for the eval video. Ben’s a pretty loud dude and i’m a mumbling englishman, so we need to balance it out a bit!
gaz- when i was listening, it buzzed my headphones when ben got loud — i love the idea of the
live-edit and getting better / clearer sound from the mikes-
Thanks for responding, Gaz. Hear you on lawyer fees, and don’t blame you for not wanting to go there before you have to. But it’s not just patent issues: Everyone at QH knew the screw-in drawer lock wasn’t viable way before the lawyers were consulted. Hearing it from QS (vs. our “competitors”) would save a lot of time and energy, and result in better decisions. Ditto some of the design issues, when you guys don’t see a lot for the community and QDS to work with. And, as kalel points out, we would benefit from a greater understanding of manufacturing capabilities.
And thanks for looking into the sound. Would hate to miss your pearls of wisdom OR have to mute Ben’s infectious enthusiasm!
We are very hesitant to ‘weed out’ ideas too early just because the perception is that they ‘won’t get picked’. Throughout staff eval we are reading community comments, discussing in-house, conducting competitive research and consulting relevant third parties. Opinions on the potential of submissions are constantly morphing and maturing during staff evaluation; indeed, discussions during the eval meeting itself often completely redefine our understanding of a submission’s possibilities. Those of you who were at the community summit saw this in action.
As much as it seems that early weeding out would save a lot of time and energy, it’s that time and energy from both the staff and the community that is essential to allowing a potentially great submission get the attention it deserves.
Appreciate the clarification. Let me see if I’ve got this straight: I’m wanting not to read 60 comments on a product you all won’t pick because it’s not viable, and you’re waiting to see if one of those 60 comments will MAKE the product viable?
@Stalias
Let me get this straight: you’re basically saying that eval is a complicated machine that is still a work in progress, that will get better and better over time and debates like these are only going to make it increasingly effective?
As promised, soon the community will be able to ‘thumbs up/thumbs down’ comments, so hopefully the useful ones will rise to the top. Just one little thing to help eval become more effective…
We are working toward making eval the perfect mechanism for doing one thing: ensuring Quirky are making the world’s best products.
Gaz…nevermind…I didn’t really have something to say to you…just felt left out of the conversation with you. I must be having issues with sharing Gaz with everyone. Ha!
Great stuff. I’m bummed I listened to the crowd and withdrew my plunger vote in the final hours. This eval really helped see the bigger picture-fun to watch too!
21 Comments
Clinton | 01/21/2011 10:51 PM
ha- was that a “3″…”2″…”ONE” at the beginning?
Clinton | 01/21/2011 11:51 PM
Hey, I think they read the submissions! (…and I think I’ve got another dozen “payback” comments coming – ha)
Ken Daniels | 01/22/2011 1:34 AM
They know everything there is to know about the submissions, with the possible exception of the winner’s name. hehe
amp | 01/22/2011 1:46 AM
This was a far more informative eval and I appreciate them reading and adapting info about things discussed in the forum since last week. I was really disappointed they didn’t apologize last week.
Dave Fulton | 01/22/2011 2:18 AM
:O OMG! Thank you for not emailing me about winning that was the best way to find out I won EVER! Jeeze! I’m tired but I can’t fall asleep now!
StatusQuirk | 01/22/2011 4:54 AM
When I see ur recaps I’m wondering why you don’t use that flatscreen in the back to show each idea you’re talkin’ bout?
Would be much easier to understand which one you mean.
Rogier | 01/22/2011 5:42 AM
Congratz to you winners!
Really thought that I would be in the top 5 based on popularity in 89, but what the hell it is over
Always shit when your idea is not picked ;(
Very cool eval show btw, Ill keep the ideas comming!
Stalias | 01/22/2011 10:59 AM
Thanks for this video — quite elucidating.
Throwing two requests out there:
1) Is it possible to modulate the sound on these things? Ben comes across as so much louder than Gaz (maybe he’s nearer the mic, maybe he’s just pumped) that I had to choose between ear pain or not hearing Gazwisdom. Tough choice there.
2) This has been discussed before, but I’m wondering if there’s a way to improve community feedback by weeding out some of the nonviable ideas. Why have your community wasting man/woman-hours discussing something that just isn’t viable (like a lock that screws into a dorm-room drawer)? Since we’re all competing here (for wins, for influence), useful critical comments from community members are always suspect (reference previous discussions of gaming). If QS sees nonviable/market infringing ideas bubbling to the top, wouldn’t we all benefit from a QS comment to that effect, so our energies can be put to use more productively?
Thanks! Fun and promising choices this week, especially.
Judi | 01/22/2011 11:13 AM
Thank you! I’m very thrilled & looking forward to the design process.
Have to echo Stalias thoughts here too–I think there is a presumption that anything up for voting can be/could be viable. Need more weeding out.
Anyway, I’m so excited for Quirky’s HSN debut!
kalel | 01/22/2011 5:39 PM
Use the flat screen behind you when you are talking about product(s), this way we have a better understanding of what you are talking about. You guys are getting better on communicating on the evaluations. You guys should talk more about manufacturing, this way people can design according to manufacturing capabilities. The more understanding that the community have on your process, helps them come up with ideas that is close to your capabilities and the things you want to design. As your capabilities increase, let the community know. I think communication is vital to the success of this new online collaborating concept.
gaz | 01/22/2011 5:58 PM
@Stalias, In most cases, the viability is heavily influenced by feedback from the patent lawyers. They give submissions a score for ‘Potential To Infringe’ and ‘Potential To Protect’. In an ideal world, all submissions would be run past the lawyers and we would weed out the ones that are nonviable/market infringing. Unfortunately, that would mean dropping serious $$$ each eval and would take many man hours to execute.
gaz | 01/22/2011 6:01 PM
@stalias
I’ll talk to the film department about the sound, we just use a webcam with built in mic for the eval video. Ben’s a pretty loud dude and i’m a mumbling englishman, so we need to balance it out a bit!
gaz | 01/22/2011 6:03 PM
@Kalel
Better than using the screen behind, we can live-edit the submission slides into the uStream so it will be crystal clear
zosomojo | 01/22/2011 10:36 PM
gaz- when i was listening, it buzzed my headphones when ben got loud — i love the idea of the
live-edit and getting better / clearer sound from the mikes-
Stalias | 01/23/2011 9:50 AM
Thanks for responding, Gaz. Hear you on lawyer fees, and don’t blame you for not wanting to go there before you have to. But it’s not just patent issues: Everyone at QH knew the screw-in drawer lock wasn’t viable way before the lawyers were consulted. Hearing it from QS (vs. our “competitors”) would save a lot of time and energy, and result in better decisions. Ditto some of the design issues, when you guys don’t see a lot for the community and QDS to work with. And, as kalel points out, we would benefit from a greater understanding of manufacturing capabilities.
And thanks for looking into the sound. Would hate to miss your pearls of wisdom OR have to mute Ben’s infectious enthusiasm!
gaz | 01/23/2011 11:49 AM
@Stalias
We are very hesitant to ‘weed out’ ideas too early just because the perception is that they ‘won’t get picked’. Throughout staff eval we are reading community comments, discussing in-house, conducting competitive research and consulting relevant third parties. Opinions on the potential of submissions are constantly morphing and maturing during staff evaluation; indeed, discussions during the eval meeting itself often completely redefine our understanding of a submission’s possibilities. Those of you who were at the community summit saw this in action.
As much as it seems that early weeding out would save a lot of time and energy, it’s that time and energy from both the staff and the community that is essential to allowing a potentially great submission get the attention it deserves.
Stalias | 01/23/2011 12:23 PM
@gaz
Appreciate the clarification. Let me see if I’ve got this straight: I’m wanting not to read 60 comments on a product you all won’t pick because it’s not viable, and you’re waiting to see if one of those 60 comments will MAKE the product viable?
gaz | 01/23/2011 4:09 PM
@Stalias
Let me get this straight: you’re basically saying that eval is a complicated machine that is still a work in progress, that will get better and better over time and debates like these are only going to make it increasingly effective?
As promised, soon the community will be able to ‘thumbs up/thumbs down’ comments, so hopefully the useful ones will rise to the top. Just one little thing to help eval become more effective…
We are working toward making eval the perfect mechanism for doing one thing: ensuring Quirky are making the world’s best products.
Michael Taylor | 01/23/2011 6:51 PM
Gaz…nevermind…I didn’t really have something to say to you…just felt left out of the conversation with you. I must be having issues with sharing Gaz with everyone. Ha!
Daniel | 01/24/2011 1:37 PM
Great stuff. I’m bummed I listened to the crowd and withdrew my plunger vote in the final hours. This eval really helped see the bigger picture-fun to watch too!