This week, big news: we’ve selected THREE winners instead of the regular two! Tune in to our live uStream product evaluation recap for all the details on Products 85 and last week’s floor protection brief. We’ll be formally selecting the winners later this evening.
Remember: the reason we make these videos public is to educate and inform our community on our evaluation and selection process. So use this here information wisely!
UPDATE: Big round of applause for our intern, Glen! He listened through 30 minutes of scratchy audio to bring you this transcribed summary:
The winners for this week:
Product 85 (two!): Cookie Keeper and Finger Mitts
Product 86 (floor protection brief): Retractable Rubber Chair Wheels
Top five products for general submissions:
Easy Hold Bowl
Given a good score by the community and would be a simple solution to the “bowl holding problem,” so design also gave it a good score. Market scored it about average because it is a good solution, but there is not a widespread problem.
Digital Measuring Tape
Was liked less by the community and design. Its design would have to be opened up and features added because it is not a unique product. Market gave it an above average score because, although it is not unique, the market for this product is large. It is viable, there are preexisting relationships with factories that specialize in this area.
Cookie Keeper
Does solve a problem and is unique to the market place. Scored well with design, 7. Very marketable, Chad sold a lot of cup cake cutters. Moderate risk of infringement due to existing patents involving vertical slots, but does not include any other features, unlike the Cookie Keeper; only problem with prodcut.
iPhone Projector
Projectors already exist and there would be competition.
Titan Water Bottle
There are many water bottles on the market already. The push to drink feature may not be enough to separate the bottle from others on the market. It would be viable to produce.
…and the wild card:
Finger Mitts
Good problem to attack. Could make a mitt that could be worn at all times, throughout cooking and even washing. Opportunity to explore new materials and redesign an existing product.
Top five products in the Floor Protection submissions:
Decorative Roller Mat
Could explore materials, but there is not much to design. Marketing gave it a low score because the new graphics would not be enough to set it apart from other mats. It is viable, but would be a large product.
Super Rolling Casters
Could be tricky to design and may not protect the floor. In terms of marketability, the solution exists, but could be done cheaper, which is a plus.
Retractable Rubber Chair Wheels
Good design, will protect the floor. Very marketable, could have different sizes and sell in packs. It is very possible to produce.
Furniture Roller
May not protect floor.
90 Degree Dustpan
Does not protect floor. It is a good idea, but the pan is too shallow and open.
…and the wild card:
Indoor/Outdoor Dirt Trapping Mat
Good idea and design to protect floors; attacks problem by preventing dirt from getting into the home. Opportunity to redesign existing product.


15 Comments
MichelleB | 01/10/2011 6:14 PM
Say what now?
AliKira | 01/10/2011 6:27 PM
The sound quality on that is horrible. I wish I could stand watching it.
Andrew Agate | 01/10/2011 7:31 PM
Guys, Can this be redone or the sound be filters to remove the highly annoying static? Cannot understand anything Gaz is saying and only part of what Ben is saying.
JJ14 | 01/10/2011 8:22 PM
I have very hard time to understand, sound quality has a problem. I know it’s a long video, but it’ll be great, if you guys can do it again.
zabber | 01/10/2011 9:10 PM
Thanks for the win this week Ben and Gaz, I know I am totally surprised but hey, I will take it! Good luck on the design, it needs it!
Username (required) | 01/10/2011 9:58 PM
Really wish I could hear Gaz’s answer when Ben asked him if I should resubmit my dustpan idea.
Dave Vaccaro | 01/10/2011 9:58 PM
Really wish I could hear Gaz’s answer when Ben asked him if I should resubmit my dustpan idea.
Ken Somerby | 01/11/2011 12:19 AM
Win some lose some I am O.K. with it, but I would like to know why you thought my submission sucked:{???
powerrose | 01/11/2011 3:57 AM
I can’t hear….can you tell us the gist?
Ken Daniels | 01/11/2011 8:56 AM
Yeah, that live thing was not so good.
jess | 01/11/2011 11:14 AM
@Ken: Don’t worry — just because your idea didn’t win doesn’t mean it sucks. One big concern is that a product like this already pretty much exists, reducing “wow” factor. Feel free to reach out to me personally if you want any more info…
@All: Sorry for the audio quality. I have our rock star intern working on a written summary of the main points — we’ll aim to post it later today!
JJ14 | 01/11/2011 7:41 PM
I appreciate for your help, Glen.
slbcatrin3 | 01/11/2011 8:02 PM
Guys you mentioned in one of your evaluation videos that you wanted to be able to show people the next big thing and sound all excited about it. After all the submissions and all the money people spent submitting their ideas and voting and commenting and evaluating. We came up with a cookie holder and a mitten of some sort. You really think stores and customers are going to be excited about putting either one of these products infront of all the other glad ware and containers out there or all the heat resistent gloves out there. Really?
zabber | 01/11/2011 11:15 PM
Um, slbcatrin3, I guess your answer is in the recap…